Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

Court of Appeal upholds Commerce Act breach by CHH

Media Release

Issued 9 November 2001/111

Court of Appeal upholds Commerce Act breach
by Carter Holt Harvey

The Court of Appeal upheld a High Court judgment that Carter Holt Harvey Building Products Group Limited breached the Commerce Act by trying to deter competition from a small Nelson company, New Wool Products Limited.

In Wellington this week, the Court of Appeal ruled in favour of the Commerce Commission that Carter Holt, the manufacturer of "Pink Batts" fibreglass insulation, used its market dominance to deter New Wool Products from competing against it in the South Island insulation market, with its all woollen product, Wool Bloc. This was a section 36 breach of the Commerce Act.

"The Commission is obviously pleased with the Court of Appeal decision," said Commission Chair John Belgrave. "It is important that the Commerce Act is effective in protecting innovation in the marketplace.

"This case is about a small Nelson company, New Wool Products, inventing a leading edge process to produce an all woollen insulation product to compete against Carter Holt's dominant fibreglass product "Pink Batts."

The Court in its judgement said: "There was a determination [by Carter Holt] to compete with New Wool Products Limited on price and to prevail by virtue of the strength of the distribution structure. So focussed was that objective that the true cost of the product was not even calculated. The price proved to be well below even average variable cost. That was not competing vigorously and legitimately; it was, for a firm enjoying a dominant position in the market, illegitimate use of that market position to prevent New Wool Products Limited consolidating and expanding its market entry."

Although the Court of Appeal upheld the section 36 breach, it dismissed the Commission's cross appeal on a section 27 breach and also the Commission's appeal for a higher penalty than the $525,000 penalty previously awarded by the High Court.

Background

New Wool Products began operation in 1992 as the manufacturer of "Wool Bloc", the only completely woollen insulation product in New Zealand. In a short time it proved very popular in the Nelson region and claimed to significantly reduce the sale of "Pink Batts" in that and other areas.

In response to the popularity of Wool Bloc, Insulation New Zealand Company (INZCO), a division of Carter Holt, introduced a 60% polyester/40% wool insulation product called Wool Line. It was approximately twice the price of Wool Bloc and its sales were low.

As a result, in March 1994, INZCO supplied Wool Line to hardware outlets, mainly in the Nelson/Marlborough region, on a "2 for 1" basis with the effective result that Wool Line was sold at half its previous price and approximately 30 or 40% below its cost of production.

The High Court described Pink Batts as the source of INZCO's profitability and the "dreadnought" of the INZCO fleet and the "behemoth" of the insulation marketplace. The High Court found that Carter Holt had sold its Wool Line insulation product below cost to preserve its "Pink Batts" sales and through them the profitability of INZCO.

Media contact: Commission Chair John Belgrave Phone work (04) 498 0963, cellphone 021 650 045

Senior Advisor Communications Jackie Maitland Phone work (04) 498 0920, cellphone (025) 249 3407

Commission media releases can be viewed on its web site www.comcom.govt.nz


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 


Serious Fraud Office: Commences Enquiries Into Allegations Of COVID-19 Wage Subsidy Fraud
The Serious Fraud Office has commenced a number of enquiries into alleged abuse of the Government’s COVID-19 Wage Subsidy. Director Julie Read said the allegations relate to multiple complex cases of potential fraud that have been referred to the agency following extensive investigations ... More>>



Environment: Preliminary Environmental Data On New Zealand’s Air Quality Released Today

The Ministry for the Environment and Stats NZ have published the Our air 2021: preliminary data release today. We are currently working to revise the Our air 2021 report to incorporate analysis of the World Health Organization (WHO) 2021 air quality guidelines that were released on 23 September 2021... More>>


Statistics: Food Prices Rise For Sixth Consecutive Month
Food prices rose 0.5 percent in September 2021 compared with August 2021, mainly influenced by higher prices for grocery food and meat, poultry, and fish, Stats NZ said today. September’s movement is the sixth consecutive monthly rise. After adjusting for seasonality, prices rose 0.9 percent... More>>



Reserve Bank: Robust Balance Sheets Yield Faster Economic Recovery

Stronger balance sheets for households, businesses, financial institutions and the government going into the pandemic contributed towards maintaining a sound financial system and yielding a faster economic recovery than following previous deep recessions... More>>


Transpower: Releases Independent Report Into Events Of August 9
Transpower’s Chief Executive Alison Andrew has today released an independent report into the grid emergency of August 9 when insufficient generation was available to meet demand, leading to some customers being disconnected... More>>

Bayleys: Latest Lockdown Adds Further Fuel To Industrial Property Market

The recent construction shutdown resulting from Auckland’s Covid 19’s lockdown restrictions has put additional pressure on an industrial property market that is already struggling to keep pace with demand... More>>