Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Saving Air NZ: An Open Letter To Helen Clark

Note: Scoop is a supporter of the Save Air New Zealand campaign...

An Open Letter To Helen Clark

Update #7 Of The Save Air New Zealand Campaign

PO Box 2947

13 October 2003

The Rt Honourable Helen Clark

Dear Prime Minister


The delay by the Commerce Commission in releasing its final decision on the airlines’ two applications is puzzling given the small amount of new information provided by the airlines since the Commission’s draft decision back on 10 April.

Delay may enable the Commerce Commission to dot all the “i”s, but it also makes a mockery of the statutory process. The whole purpose of having a statutory timeline for such approvals is to ensure that everyone quickly knows whether or not a "marriage" is going to go ahead and be consummated. The longer the waiting period, the more uncertainty for everyone - the happy couple, disappointed suitors and everyone left waiting in the church in expectation. Similarly with the Air New Zealand - Qantas alliance. They are seeking authorisation for price fixing and market sharing. In most circumstances at least the former would be unlawful. The longer the authorisation process takes, the longer the parties can act as if what is unlawful is going to be permitted. During this wait employees, suppliers and other stake holders are obliged to ignore the inherent unlawfulness of it all.

SaveAirNZ contends that it is time for Government in its roles as shareholder, regulator and guardian of the public good to say “enough, time to move on”. While we wait for this, take the opportunity to mull over what has unfolded and where it leads.

A year ago Air New Zealand negotiated a deal with its main competitor Qantas. The deal involved:

- Qantas to invest $550million to acquire 22.5% of Air New Zealand at a price of $0.445 cents per share, about 15% less than the market price of Air New Zealand shares.

- Qantas and Air New Zealand to form a joint venture over all Air New Zealand’s services, and to preclude Air New Zealand flying within Australia. The joint venture to be jointly managed and result in Qantas receiving approximately 20% of Air New Zealand’s income by not flying in New Zealand.

In sum, Qantas stops Air New Zealand competing on its turf and vice versa. Qantas gets about 42% of Air New Zealand’s profit with a 22% shareholding. Qantas buys its shares at a 15% discount to the market value. Qantas gets control of Air New Zealand’s offshore marketing via Qantas Holidays. Qantas gets comprehensive information on all Air New Zealand’s operations, plus a say, if not control, on most of Air New Zealand’s operations and decisions.

A year ago, Air New Zealand’s board and management seemed to think this was the best they could achieve with the airline in which New Zealand had just invested $850million. The SaveAirNZ group was formed to oppose this poor transaction by encouraging public debate before Government exercised its Kiwi-share rights. Initially we failed as there was no public input to Government’s exercise of its Kiwi-share rights.

Why have Kiwi-share rights when they are side-lined by insiders with vested interest?

Subsequent to the non-exercise of the Kiwi-share rights the airlines approached the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission and the New Zealand Commerce Commission for approval.

The ACCC said “no” in its draft determination, and then said “no” again in its final determination of 9 September, noting that “The proposed alliance would be highly anti-competitive and offer little benefit to the Australian public… ‘national interest’ would seem better served by continued competition between Qantas and Air New Zealand than an alliance. Both parties have indicated publicly that neither airline is realistically in danger of failure even in the medium term… The proposed alliance is highly anti-competitive and its benefits are small. The overall anti-competitive nature of the proposed alliance is reflected in the range and complexity of the undertakings offered by the applicants. The ACCC does not believe that undertakings can redress the identified anti-competitive detriment associated with the proposed alliance to the extent that authorisation could be granted.”

In its draft determination of 10 April the Commerce Commission noted “In the Commission’s preliminary view, the overall detriment expected to result from the proposed Alliance would clearly outweigh the expected benefits.” The Commission calculated that net detriments would be in the range of $195 million to $467 million per annum.

Has anything happened to change anyone’s opinions on the disadvantages of this deal since then?

- For the year to 30 June 2003 Air New Zealand has reported a pre tax profit of $220 million and positive cashflow from operations of $523 million.

- The Australian government has entered into a new agreement with Singapore which continues to exclude Singapore Airlines from flying between North America and Australia and maintains Qantas near monopoly on this route.

- Virgin Blue and Qantas have established a $30million joint venture to maintain jet engines.

- Virgin Blue’s much anticipated Tasman/New Zealand expansion materialised as a daily link between Christchurch and Brisbane which Christchurch City seems to have underwritten.

- Qantas Holidays are reported to be under investigation by the ACCC for alleged misuse of market power, not a good portent given its desire to become the major marketer of New Zealand offshore if the airline alliance is approved.

- Air New Zealand took delivery of the first Airbus that it is to use to replace its 737s and flew several journalists who have been following the airline alliance to Toulouse for the launch. Some of those journalist noted their receipt of Air New Zealand largess in their subsequent reports.

- Air New Zealand has launched a number of predatory actions against Origin Pacific that has resulted in Origin requesting that the Commerce Commission investigate Air New Zealand.

- Ralph Norris confirmed that Air New Zealand was only talking to Qantas as other airlines “weren’t right then and they’re not right now.”

Air New Zealand is 85% owned by the public. It is making good profits. It claims to need protection from Virgin Blue and Qantas in order to increase profitability from New Zealand and Tasman operations. It sees only Qantas as an attractive partner, because while other airlines can offer international links only Qantas and Air New Zealand can form a domestic monopoly and near control of the Tasman. Market dominance is the single reason the airlines want this alliance and is precisely why everyone else with an interest in a viable New Zealand air travel industry is opposed to it.

How responsive are the Air New Zealand board and senior management to their shareholders’ interests? By their behaviour it is clear they are indifferent.

If Qantas were to get board representation on Air New Zealand who would call the shots? Certainly not the New Zealand Government.

SaveAirNZ was established and is supported by a group of people keen to see Air New Zealand fly the Koru around the globe and to provide good, cheap, frequent services within, to and from New Zealand. It must now be time for Government in its role as shareholder, regulator and guardian of the public good to say “enough, time to move on”, and to perhaps revisit some of the people they have charged with setting Air New Zealand’s directions thus far.

Yours sincerely
Ian Prior ONZM


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Auckland Transport: Successful Bridge Repair Opens Two Additional Lanes To Traffic

The opening of two additional lanes on the Auckland Harbour Bridge this morning will help relieve some motorway congestion for motorists heading home to the North Shore tonight. More>>


Statistics New Zealand: COVID-19 Sees Record 12.2 Percent Fall In New Zealand’s Economy

Gross domestic product (GDP) fell by 12.2 percent in the June 2020 quarter, the largest quarterly fall recorded since the current series began in 1987, as the COVID-19 restrictions in place through the quarter impacted economic activity, Stats NZ said ... More>>


Climate: Scientists Release ‘Blueprint’ To Save Critical Ecosystems And Stabilize The Earth’s Climate

A group of scientists and experts produced the first comprehensive global-scale analysis of terrestrial areas essential for biodiversity and climate resilience, totaling 50.4% of the Earth's land. The report was published in Science Advances ... More>>


MPI: Independent Review Launched Into Assurances For Safe Transport Of Livestock By Sea

The Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) has launched an independent review of the assurances it receives for the safe transport of livestock by sea. MPI Director-General Ray Smith says Mike Heron QC has been appointed to lead the review, which is expected ... More>>


Computers: New Zealand PC Market Grows Nearly 40% Due To Work From Home Demand

COVID-19 had large impacts on demand for PCs as businesses prepared for lockdowns by purchasing notebooks to mobilise their workforce. In the second quarter of 2020, New Zealand's Traditional PC market experienced a 39.7% year-on-year (YoY) growth ... More>>


University Of Auckland: Whale-Watching By Satellite – Follow Their Travels Online

Scientists have successfully attached satellite tracking tags to six New Zealand southern right whales, or tohorā, and are inviting the public to follow the whales’ travels online. Part of a major research project involving the University of Auckland ... More>>

Commerce Commission: Kiwibank Admits System Failures And Agrees To Pay Customers $5.2 Million

Kiwibank has entered into a settlement agreement with the Commerce Commission after reporting that it failed to have in place robust home loan variation disclosure policies, procedures and systems. In a settlement dated 27 August 2020, Kiwibank admitted that ... More>>

Ministry of Health: Public Transport Distancing Requirements Relaxed

Physical distancing requirements on public transport have been reviewed by the Ministry of Health to determine whether they are still required at Alert Level 2 (or below). The Ministry’s assessment is that mandatory face covering and individuals tracking ... More>>


NZHIA: New Zealand Hemp Industry Set To Generate $2 Billion Per Annum And Create 20,000 Jobs

A new report says a fully enabled hemp industry could generate $2 billion in income for New Zealand by 2030, while also creating thousands of new jobs. Written by industry strategist Dr Nick Marsh, the report has prompted calls from the New Zealand Hemp ... More>>


Stats NZ: One In 14 Employed People Report High Risk Of Losing Jobs

About one in 14 workers say they expect to lose their job or business by mid-2021, Stats NZ said today. A survey of employed people in the June 2020 quarter showed 7 percent felt there was a high or almost certain chance of losing their job or business ... More>>

ASB Quarterly Economic Forecast: NZ Economy Doing Better Than Expected, But Challenges Remain

August lockdown estimated to have shaved 8% off NZ’s weekly GDP, and 0.5% off annual GDP Economy now expected to shrink 5% (year-on-year) by end of 2020 Unemployment rate now expected to peak at 7.2% The latest ASB Quarterly Economic Forecast is less ... More>>