Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

IRD Seeks Imprisonment

14 October 2005

IRD Seeks Imprisonment

New Zealand’s Inland Revenue Department is attempting to seek immediate imprisonment for taxpayers who fail to act on court orders to supply IRD with documents or returns. The first attempt at doing so today in the Wellington District Court was frustrated when Judge Susan Thomas ordered that the matter be deferred pending further submissions.

Judge Thomas found the IRD request to be “quite extraordinary” and noted that the effect would be to have defendants taken straight from the court room to Rimutuka Prison for breach of a civil matter. When Judge Thomas questioned IRD counsel on the fairness of such a request the counsel replied that the defendants would be free to seek bail.

Judge Thomas noted that she was “very concerned about Bill of Rights issues” and was “very uncomfortable” with the whole notion.

IRD’s Cath Cowper said that using the civil jurisdiction in tandem with the penalties available to them under the criminal jurisdiction appeared to Inland Revenue to be an effective and legitimate means of getting taxpayers to comply with Inland Revenue requirements.

In all a total of five taxpayers were sought to be imprisoned by IRD on the spot but only one taxpayer, Scott Anderson, seemed to take the matter seriously enough to turn up. Mr Anderson has been waging a personal battle with IRD for years and argues that he has supplied the IRD with everything they have asked for, sometimes many times over.

Mr Anderson’s submissions to court include an internal IRD email which discusses what to do about Mr Anderson’s many disputes with IRD. It says that “when he is broke he won’t be a problem”. Mr Anderson says that “as well as trying for years to make me broke, they want to send me to prison for not supplying documents I have already given them”.

IRD’s submissions to court state that imprisonment for not supplying returns or documents is not “unduly draconian”. Anderson says in response that if IRD does not view incarceration for failing to supply information as draconian, “would the Commissioner look to hanging or guillotine” as being the measure of draconian action?

Scott Anderson - Lawfuel

ENDS


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 


Retail: New Law Paves Way For Greater Supermarket Competition

Legislation that bans major supermarkets from blocking their competitors’ access to land to set up new stores paves the way for greater competition in the sector, Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs Dr David Clark said... More>>



International Business Forum: NZ EU FTA Coming Down To The Wire – Hold The Line

As negotiations accelerate to conclude an ambitious free trade agreement between New Zealand and the European Union, the NZ International Business Forum (NZIBF), representing a cross section of major exporters... More>>


MBIE: NZ space sector set to star in Moon mission
The New Zealand space sector is set to star in NASA’s CAPSTONE moon mission – with Rocket Lab launching a satellite to the Moon from New Zealand in June, and the lift-off of a separate NASA-NZ lunar research project... More>>



MYOB: New Data Shows Increase In SMEs Experiencing Stress And Anxiety

The lingering impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic have led to a surge in the number of local SME owners and operators experiencing stress and anxiety, according to new research from business management platform, MYOB... More>>



Carbonz: Cashing In On Carbon: The New Marketplace Helping Native Forest To Thrive

The country’s first voluntary carbon credit marketplace, Carbonz, is here to restore native biodiversity and help Aotearoa reach its carbon zero goals by selling the first carbon credits exclusively from native forest... More>>
Entrust District: Dividend Will Be Welcomed After Another Tough Year
We’ve all heard of the saying; “if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is” but for Aucklanders within the Entrust District, getting their share of Entrust’s 2022 annual dividend payment really is as good as it sounds... More>>