Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

False Timber Grading – Carter Holt Harvey

False Timber Grading – Carter Holt Harvey

1. Carter Holt Harvey is not a member of the New Zealand Timber Industry Federation (NZTIF) and wasn’t at the time when the false grading occurred. In 2002 we became aware of wrongly graded timber in the market and of rumours that Carter Holt Harvey was deliberately misrepresenting the grade of its MGP10 Laserframe timber.

We commissioned independent tests of CHH Laserframe MGP10. These tests confirmed that the grade was in fact being substantially misrepresented.

After taking legal advice we felt it necessary to inform the Commerce Commission and also the Minister of Forests. We were also concerned for any damage to the reputation of timber generally and to our own Member sawmills, wood processors and customers.

We wish to assure the public that we believe that these practices have ceased. The public can have every confidence in our grading standards.

Carter Holt Harvey has new owners and managers who we are sure are committed to maintaining correct grading standards.

We also wish to reassure the public that we believe there are no safety issues. The wrongly graded MGP10 Laserframe supplied however will not meet the expected performance of the grade represented. A typical issue might be the sagging of lintels or floor joists (e.g. squeaky floors). The customer will have paid too much for that timber. A good analogy would be the supply of 91 octane petrol represented as 96 octane.

NZTIF will continue to be vigilant on grading standards to uphold the excellent reputation of timber. NZTIF supports an independent grading verification scheme, Verified Timber Ltd, which will give even greater assurance to customers.

With the guilty plea the way is now open for compensation claims by competitors and customers.

With Laserframe MGP10 sales of close to $200 million over the three years in question the claims can be expected to be very substantial.

Our Members will have suffered from unfair competition because we supplied the correct grade of timber our costs would have been higher. this would result in reduced sales, lower prices and lower margins.

At that time CHH also initiated an attack on visually graded timber – the traditional and proven method of grading used by almost all of our Members at that time.

CHH proposed changes to the grading standards to favour machine stress grading.

It had moved a large volume of its grading to machine stress grading and believed this would give them an advantage (as they had about 80% of the machine stress grading capacity).

Their deliberate decision to derive an even greater advantage by misrepresenting their machine stress grades clearly put anybody who was visually grading at an even bigger disadvantage.

ends

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 


International Business Forum: NZ EU FTA Coming Down To The Wire – Hold The Line

As negotiations accelerate to conclude an ambitious free trade agreement between New Zealand and the European Union, the NZ International Business Forum (NZIBF), representing a cross section of major exporters... More>>


MBIE: NZ space sector set to star in Moon mission
The New Zealand space sector is set to star in NASA’s CAPSTONE moon mission – with Rocket Lab launching a satellite to the Moon from New Zealand in June, and the lift-off of a separate NASA-NZ lunar research project... More>>



Air New Zealand: Relaunching 14 International Routes In 16 Days

Air New Zealand is gearing up for the busiest July in two years with the relaunch of 14 international routes in 16 days... More>>


Carbonz: Cashing In On Carbon: The New Marketplace Helping Native Forest To Thrive

The country’s first voluntary carbon credit marketplace, Carbonz, is here to restore native biodiversity and help Aotearoa reach its carbon zero goals by selling the first carbon credits exclusively from native forest... More>>
Entrust District: Dividend Will Be Welcomed After Another Tough Year
We’ve all heard of the saying; “if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is” but for Aucklanders within the Entrust District, getting their share of Entrust’s 2022 annual dividend payment really is as good as it sounds... More>>

BusinessNZ: NZ Economy - Prevailing Headwinds
The latest BusinessNZ Planning Forecast reveals business and consumer confidence is low, with factors at home and abroad hampering our recovery... More>>