Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Decline in Public Hospital Productivity


Report Reveals Substantial Decline in Public Hospital Productivity

"A new study on the performance of New Zealand's public hospitals produced for the New Zealand Business Roundtable reveals a substantial decline in productivity. Despite large additional expenditure on health in recent years, it appears that taxpayers have not received commensurate value for money", Roger Kerr, executive director of the Business Roundtable, said today.

"The study updates and reinforces the findings of a 2005 Treasury report on the sector and reveals some clear trends (see attached graphs):

· the real (ie inflation adjusted) cost per unit of public hospital outputs increased by approximately 18 percent over the five years from 2000/01 to 2005/06

· overall productivity of personnel in public hospitals decreased 8 percent over the same period (this compares with a decrease in productivity for medical personnel of 15 percent and 11 percent for nursing personnel), and

· the overall real average personnel costs for hospital services increased approximately 16 percent over the same period.

The 2005 Treasury report (obtained under the Official Information Act) showed a fall in hospital efficiency of 7.7 percent in the period 2000/01 to 2003/04.

Productivity Performance of New Zealand Public Hospitals 1998/99 to 2005/06 was written by specialist public sector analyst Mani Maniparathy of Bakker Maniparathy Claridge Ltd. Dr Graham Scott, former Secretary to the Treasury and former chair of the Health Funding Authority, arranged for the study to be conducted with partial funding from the Business Roundtable and wrote a foreword.

Mr Kerr said the purpose of the study was not to draw policy conclusions but to stimulate research and discussion. Nevertheless, the main findings suggested serious grounds for concern.

"In essence, it appears that, in spite of continuing substantial - and possibly unsustainable - increases in funding each year, productivity in the public hospital system is actually deteriorating.

"This raises a number of important questions, not the least being why what amounts to almost a fifth of government expenditure and 8 percent of the total economy has received so little attention in respect of productivity and value for money."

Mr Kerr said that the data on hospital performance were very difficult to obtain from the Ministry of Health. Moreover, they are not routinely collected or consistently assembled, and are further compromised by weaknesses such as the lack of consistent definitions about even such simple concepts as full-time equivalents. This makes the task of evaluating performance in the sector extremely difficult.

"The findings raise another important question: what exactly would the full slate of public health services actually cost if all the undertakings about access were met effectively and safely?", Mr Kerr said.

"Understanding the true value of spending in the public hospitals sector is not only critical for meeting health sector goals but also for fiscal policy and improvements in the wider economy."

Mr Kerr said that Bakker Maniparathy Claridge Ltd intends to update the study periodically and make it available to researchers. The report also suggests that Statistics New Zealand could be mandated to produce performance information to high and consistent standards across the health sector to support a drive for performance improvement.

"Besides stimulating further research, it is hoped that the report will help refocus public debate on problems with the performance of the health system and alternative policy approaches rather than be confined to calls for more health spending, some of which may represent poor value for money", Mr Kerr concluded.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Electricity Authority: Review Of Competition In The Wholesale Electricity Market Raises Questions

In March 2021 the Electricity Authority announced it would conduct a review into competition in the wholesale electricity market. The period of the review covers the sustained elevated electricity prices since an unplanned outage at the Pohokura gas facility in Spring 2018... More>>

Government: RSI ‘State Of The Nation’ Report Published
latest research, science and innovation system report card is now available, and outlines how the system is performing, Research, Science and Innovation Minister Megan Woods has announced. “The report seeks to increase transparency, act as a reliable data source and stimulate discussion... More>>

Fonterra: Increases 2021/22 Forecast Farmgate Milk Price

Fonterra Co-operative Group Limited today increased and narrowed its forecast Farmgate Milk Price range to NZD $7.90 - $8.90 per kgMS, from NZD $7.25 - $8.75 per kgMS. The midpoint of the range, which farmers are paid off, has increased to NZD $8.40 per kgMS, from NZD $8.00 per kgMS... More>>

Pamu & Westpac: Market-leading Sustainability-Linked Loan

Westpac NZ and Pāmu have signed New Zealand’s most comprehensive Sustainability-Linked Loan to date, also the largest in the agricultural sector, and the first involving a state-owned enterprise. Pāmu, also known as Landcorp, is New Zealand’s biggest farming business. It will borrow $85m from Westpac NZ over three years... More>>

Retail NZ: Some Good News In COVID Announcements, But Firm Dates Needed

Retail NZ is welcoming news that the Government is increasing financial support for businesses in light of the ongoing COVID-19 lockdown, and that retail will be able to open at all stages of the new “Covid Protection Framework... More>>

ComCom: Companies In Hot Water For Selling Unsafe Hot Water Bottles And Toys

A wholesaler and a retailer have been fined a total of $140,000 under the Fair Trading Act for selling hot water bottles and toys that did not comply with mandatory safety requirements. Paramount Merchandise Company Limited (Paramount) was fined $104,000 after pleading guilty in the Manukau District Court... More>>