Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

Constant regulatory 'tweaking' irks foreign funders: Vector

Constant regulatory 'tweaking' irks foreign funders, Vector tells court

By Pattrick Smellie

Aug 15 (BusinessDesk) – Potential foreign lenders to network monopolies such as Vector Ltd. are being put off by “constant tweaking” of the regulated pricing regime administered by the Commerce Commission, the Wellington High Court heard this morning.

In opening submissions for Vector in its application for a judicial review of aspects of the commission’s recent decisions dictating what it and other network owners can earn, Alan Galbraith QC said the commission’s actions were creating the opposite to the intended effect to Commerce Act reforms in 2007.

He quoted from a memo by an American funder to a senior executive at another major network company, Powerco, saying “one of the reasons we don’t like lending into New Zealand is that we don’t like the regime.”

“The constant tweaking is a credit negative. We have other places to put our money into,” the memo said, citing Australia’s larger opportunities and greater regulatory certainty.

Galbraith argued the reforms to Part 4 of the Commerce Act were expressly intended to increase regulatory and investment certainty, but had instead produced a “self-defeating outcome”, especially as the Commerce Commission had come to three different conclusions over the last year, each of which had material impacts on affected companies’ future earnings and investment intentions.

“Investors become gun-shy,” he said. The commission’s rulings were leading to higher costs of capital and lower prices.

In the current action, being heard by Judge Denis Clifford, Vector is seeking a judicial review of the commission’s decisions on the so-called “input methodologies” for calculating networks’ allowable rates of return.

The Auckland-based electricity, gas and telecommunications network operator argues the commission should have included a “starting price adjustment” in the input methodologies.

It is also seeking a “merits review” of the default price path determined by the commission, also to be heard by Judge Clifford, but not scheduled for hearings until late 2012.

“The intent of the default price path was to be a low cost way of setting a price path which wouldn’t require the extent of information required to do a full ‘building blocks’ approach,” said Galbraith. However, the approach being taken “means the extent of information required get the answer is closer to a full-blown building block approach which, for each supplier, will impose an unexpected burden.”

Galbraith argued the commission should be disclosing the data sets it intended using in its input methodology calculations, to allow investors a better understanding of what to expect, and to prevent the commission changing its approach at each seven yearly resetting exercise.

Without such certainty, “long term planning and capital raising is extremely problematic.”

(BusinessDesk)

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 


FIRST Union: Do Shareholders Realise Marsden Point Conversion Could Cost More Than Half A Billion Dollars?

FIRST Union, the union representing workers at Refining NZ, are querying whether shareholders voting on Friday on whether to convert the Marsden Point refinery to an import-only terminal realise the conversion could cost $650-700 million dollars... More>>



Civil Contractors: Massive Rebound In Civil Construction Business Confidence

New Zealand’s civil construction industry is riding a massive rebound in post-pandemic business confidence – but this may be undermined by skills shortages, which continue to be the industry’s number one challenge... More>>



Energy: Feeling Our Way Towards Hydrogen - Tina Schirr

Right now hydrogen is getting a lot of attention. Many countries are focusing on producing hydrogen for fuel, or procuring it, or planning for its future use... More>>





ASB: New Support Finder Tool Helps Connect Customers With Thousands In Government Support

ASB research alongside benefit numbers from the Ministry of Social Development shows an increased number of Kiwis are struggling financially, and many may not be aware they’re eligible for government support... More>>


Housing: New Home Consents Continue To Break Records

A record 44,299 new homes were consented in the year ended June 2021, Stats NZ said today. “The annual number of new homes consented rose again in the June 2021 year, the fourth consecutive month of rises,” construction statistics manager Michael Heslop said... More>>


Real Estate: June Home Transfers Remain High
There were 44,517 home transfers in the June 2021 quarter, the highest June quarter figure since 2016, Stats NZ said today. The number of home transfers was very similar to the March 2021 quarter and was up 18,252 from the June 2020 quarter... More>>