Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Westpac wrong to hold funds in Hamilton case, court says

Westpac wrong to hold funds in Hamilton accounting case, Supreme Court says

By Paul McBeth

Aug. 16 (BusinessDesk) – The Supreme Court has told lender Westpac New Zealand Ltd. it was wrong to withhold client funds amid suspicions over where the money was going and it will have to pay interest and costs.

The full Supreme Court bench of Chief Justice Sian Elias and Justices Peter Blanchard, Andrew Tipping, John McGrath and William Young unanimously dismissed Westpac’s appeal and ordered it to pay $15,000 plus disbursements to Hamilton accounting firm Map & Associates Ltd.

The bank was trying to avoid costs and interest after asking the accounting firm to get a court order in 2008 to release funds held on behalf of investors in a Bolivian bank when it got nervous about the proposed transfer of funds.

Westpac argued that the potential for helping acts of dishonesty was enough to justify its actions, though the court ruled that was too low a benchmark.

“Acceptance of the bank’s submission would leave the customer bearing the loss when there was in fact no problem with the customer’s instructions, but the bank, albeit reasonably, suspected or believed there was,” Justice Tipping said when delivering the judgement.

If the court found in favour of Westpac, it would have the best of both worlds, with “the benefit of a lesser standard for a defence, but a higher standard for liability,” he said.

Westpac could have entered a contract to limit its potential liability for a breach of mandate, “but it did not,” he said.

In 2008, Westpac refused to act on instructions from Map to transfer some US$50 million that was held by about 20 shareholders in Prodem, a privately-owned Bolivian bank. Map was acting as the deposit agent for the investors, having put the money with Westpac in December 2006.

The Prodem investment had its rights assigned to another bank called Bandes during a transaction in early 2008, and when Westpac was called to transfer the funds, it refused to do so, saying “the money it was holding was in substantial part to be paid out to people or organisations who appeared not to be shareholders and it was unaware of the basis upon which they were to receive payment,” the judgement said.

Westpac was unwilling to act on the instructions of the shareholders’ attorney and invited Map to apply to the High Court, which ordered the bank to carry out the transfer and pay interest on the sum withheld and costs. That decision was upheld by the Court of Appeal last year.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Consumer NZ: Bank Complaints On The Rise, Survey Shows

Nearly one in five Kiwis had a problem with their bank in the past year, Consumer NZ’s latest satisfaction survey finds. Consumer NZ chief executive Jon Duffy said the number of bank customers reporting problems had jumped to 18%, up from 11% in 2020... More>>

Federated Farmers: Applauds UK-Australia Free Trade Deal

News that Australia and the UK have signed a free trade agreement is a promising step forward in the fight against tariffs and protectionism, Federated Farmers says.
"It reinforces the international rules-based trading framework and is important for rural producers and global consumers," Feds President Andrew Hoggard says... More>>

REINZ May Data: House Price Rises Continue; Auckland Hits New Record Median Price Again

Median prices for residential property across New Zealand increased by 32.3% from $620,000 in May 2020 to $820,000 in May 2021, according to the latest data from the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand (REINZ), source of the most complete and accurate real estate data in New Zealand... More>>

Stats NZ: GDP Climbs 1.6 Percent In March 2021 Quarter Following December Dip

Gross domestic product (GDP) rose by 1.6 percent in the March 2021 quarter, following a 1.0 percent fall in the December 2020 quarter, Stats NZ said today. "After an easing of economic activity in the December quarter, we’ve seen broad-based growth in the first quarter of 2021... More>>

Reserve Bank: Debt Serviceability Restrictions Added To Policy Toolkit

The Reserve Bank – Te Pūtea Matua and the Minister of Finance have agreed to update their shared Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) on macro-prudential policy and add debt serviceability restrictions to the list of potential tools available... More>>

Auction: 1.4 Million In Rare Vintage Watches, Gems, Jewels & Diamonds Go Under The Hammer At Webb’s

An auction event showcasing over 1.4 Million dollars in rare jewels, gems, diamonds and vintage watches is due to take place this Sunday by Auckland based auction house Webb’s... More>>