Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Fight for Bridgecorp $20M insurance cover hits appeal court

Fight for Bridgecorp's $20M insurance cover hits appeal court

By Paul McBeth

Sept. 5 (BusinessDesk) - The battle for Bridgecorp's $20 million insurance cover hit the Court of Appeal today, with the failed lender's receivers arguing their claim should trump legal fees when the pay-out is made.

The former Bridgecorp directors Peter Steigrad, Bruce Davidson and Gary Urwin are appealing a ruling in the High Court last year that blocked access to the D&O policy to cover their defence costs.

Another appeal testing similar ground, involving Chartis New Zealand and former Feltex Carpets shareholder Eric Houghton, is being heard at the same time. Houghton is leading a class suit against the failed carpetmaker, which had indemnity cover with Chartis and wants guidance following the Bridgecorp ruling.

Counsel for the receiver, Murray Tingey, told Justices Mark O'Regan, Terence Arnold and Rhys Harrison in Wellington the structure of the Bridgecorp directors & officers' liability policy meant defence costs ranked behind a potential claim on liability and couldn't be drawn on.

Tingey argued the full amount should come to the receivers. By pooling the policy's limit, rather than divvying up how much could be allocated to defence costs and how much to liability, secured creditors had priority.

"When those directors came to claim their costs, the liability limit was exhausted by the charge, so the insurer can say we're not going to pay this," Tingey said. "They chose to take a policy with composite (pooling) - the reason they may have done that was for the benefit of the company, but that's just what the bargain is."

Michael Ring QC, counsel for Chartis, told the court it wasn't an either/or proposition, because "defence costs cover are fundamental" to the policy contract. The defence cover is designed to either prevent legal liability, or minimise it, with anything left over to go to a claimant.

Alan Galbraith QC, counsel for the former Feltex directors, said the obligation between the insurer and the insured party would be breached if defence costs couldn't be claimed, and would "increase exposure of the insurer" and "change the contract entitlements for the insured."

The hearing is set down for two days and is proceeding.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Stats NZ: Quarterly Inflation Rising Steadily Across The Board

Higher prices for transport and food have driven up inflation for the all households group in the June 2021 quarter, Stats NZ said today. The ‘all households group’ represents all private New Zealand-resident households... More>>

Stats NZ: Primary Products Push Exports To A New High

New Zealand exports reached a new high in June 2021, off the back of record export values for logs and beef, Stats NZ said today. In June 2021, the value of all goods exports rose... More>>

Energy: New Zealand Could Be World’s First Large-scale Producer Of Green Hydrogen

Contact Energy and Meridian Energy are seeking registrations of interest to develop the world’s largest green hydrogen plant. The plant has the potential to earn hundreds of millions in export revenue and help decarbonise economies both here and overseas... More>>

Statistics: Household Saving Falls In The March 2021 Quarter

Saving by New Zealanders in the March 2021 quarter fell to its lowest level in two years after rising sharply in 2020, Stats NZ said today. Increases in household spending outpaced income growth, leading to a decline in household saving from the elevated levels that prevailed throughout 2020... More>>