Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

Granting Dotcom access to documents would leave NZ exposed

Granting Dotcom extradition documents will leave NZ standing alone, Solicitor-General says

By Paul McBeth

July 30 (BusinessDesk) - Granting internet tycoon Kim Dotcom access to documents supporting his extradition to the US would leave New Zealand as an outlier, as no other country has ever ordered that kind of disclosure, according to the Solicitor-General.

Acting ultimately on behalf of the US Federal government, Solicitor-General Mike Heron told a full Supreme Court bench no other appellant court across common law has upheld a disclosure request in the pre-trial stages, and doing so would leave New Zealand as an outlier in the international community.

“Were it to be made in this court, we would stand alone,” Heron said. “This order, is in effect, an order against a foreign state.”

Heron said the issue had been covered extensively over the past two decades and has consistently been upheld at the highest levels.

The US Federal government is seeking to extradite Dotcom and his co-accused Finn Batato, Mathias Ortmann and Bram van der Kolk to face charges of conspiracy to operate websites used to illegally distribute copyrighted content.

The District and High Courts upheld their request for a trimmed down disclosure, though that was overturned in the Court of Appeal earlier this year.

Heron told Chief Justice Dame Sian Elias and Justices John McGrath, William Young, Susan Glazebrook and Terence Arnold the treaty governing extraditions between New Zealand and the US was to facilitate efficiency, and extra disclosure undermined that.

New Zealand courts aren’t empowered to make orders against foreign sovereign states, and if judges have any qualms about the evidence put forward, they can strike it out, make a request for more, or turn down the application, Heron said.

Earlier in the hearing, Dotcom’s counsel Paul Davison QC, told the court the extradition treaty didn’t prevent the courts from making disclosure orders, saying the legislature had kept a regulation-making ability for that very issue.

Davison said the summary of evidence would be more burdensome and onerous than handing over much of the full documentation, which in digital form was available simply by pushing a button.

Heron said Dotcom’s team had oversimplified the evidence put forward by the US government, which he said was based on undercover activity and actual emails.

“This is massive copyright and other fraud alleged,” Heron said.

The judges reserved their decision at the end of the one-day hearing.

(BusinessDesk)

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 


Commerce Commission: Appeals Record $2.25m Fine In Vodafone FibreX Case

The Commerce Commission has filed an appeal in the High Court against a record $2.25 million fine imposed on Vodafone NZ Limited (Vodafone) for its offending under the Fair Trading Act during its FibreX advertising campaign. While the sentence imposed in the Auckland District Court on April 14 was the largest-ever fine under the Fair Trading Act, the Commission will argue that it is manifestly inadequate... More>>



All District Health Boards: Historic Pay Equity Settlement

An historic agreement has been ratified that addresses a long-standing undervaluation of a workforce that is critical to the smooth running of our hospitals and the delivery of healthcare... More>>


MPI: Dry Autumn In Waikato And South Auckland Leads To Drought Classification Drought conditions affecting the primary sector in the Waikato and South Auckland were today classified as a medium-scale adverse event, enabling a package of support for farmers and growers... More>>


Barfoot & Thompson: Rents Up By Around 3% In Most Areas

The average weekly rent paid for homes in most areas of Auckland has risen by around 3 percent year-on-year. The figures for end March from more than 16,000 properties... More>>


DoC: Smeagol The ‘Gravel Maggot’ Leaves Its Rare Mark On The Remote West Coast
An extremely rare species of sea slug or ‘gravel maggot’ has been detected for the first time on a remote beach in South Westland... More>>



Immigration: Annual Net Migration Loss Of 7,300

The provisional net loss of 7,300 people in the year ended March 2022 was the lowest net migration for a March year since 2012, Stats NZ said today... More>>