Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Wilaci argues A$33.6mn in late payment fees not a penalty

Wilaci argues A$33.6mn in late payment fees weren't a penalty in Court of Appeal

By Sophie Boot

Oct. 4 (BusinessDesk) - Lawyers for Australian businessman John Grill's Wilaci investment unit have argued that A$33.6 million in late payment fees it wants from Pyne Gould Corp subsidiary Torchlight Fund No 1 LP weren't penalty fees in the Court of Appeal this morning.

Last October, Justice Matthew Muir in the High Court ruled the Torchlight unit didn't have to pay the fee on a A$37 million loan from Wilaci, which "so significantly exceeds the loss likely to be caused by the breach that it qualifies as extravagant and therefore unenforceable," saying the A$2.17 million per month fee "was undoubtedly extravagant in relation to any such loss."

Wilaci loaned the funds to Torchlight on Aug. 22, 2012, to help the Pyne Gould entity through what managing director George Kerr described as "a very tight liquidity situation" when Bank of Scotland International was leaving Australasia and calling for repayment from its debtors, including Torchlight's Australian real estate investment, RCL Group. A high-profile dispute with the Financial Markets Authority made it more difficult for Kerr to recapitalise Torchlight.

The loan was due to be repaid by Oct. 26, a deadline Torchlight missed, although Wilaci didn't immediately call on the loan, rather it managed the repayment through seven tranches between October 2013 and May 2014.

Justice Stephen Kos, president of the appeal court, said he had summarised Wilaci's appeal case in five points. Wilaci has relied on the Australian Federal Court's 2015 decision in Paciocco v ANZ Banking Group, where it was found that late fees charged by the bank on credit card payments weren't penalties and therefore were enforceable, in its arguments in the High Court and the appeal court today.

"The first is that in Paciocco, to be a penalty, the sole purpose of the provision must be functional," Justice Kos said. "The test is not simply whether the provision is designed to incentivise payment on the due date. Third, the relevant interests of the innocent party go beyond simply breach damages otherwise payable. That may be particularly in the case where the parties are substantial, sophisticated commercial entities. The trend seems to be to constrain the doctrine rather than to expand it, and it is easier to justify the doctrine in a consumer context rather than a commercial one."

Wilaci is also arguing that to be a penalty, the fee charged "would need to be out of all proportion to the innocent party's legitimate commercial interests," Justice Kos said, which the appellant's Sydney-based lawyer, David Jackson QC, agree with.

Justice Forrest Miller grilled Bruce Stewart QC, one of Pyne Gould's lawyers, on whether Grill's capital had been placed at risk

"Now we're talking about $37 million being at risk, and we're gauging the reasonableness of this fee against that context. Isn't this your essential problem? We're not talking about damages on the assumption that $37 million has been repaid, we're talking about $37 million being at risk," Justice Miller said.

Stewart said that didn't affect whether the payment was a penalty or not, but Justice Miller said it was important to the question of whether the payment was "extravagant or unconscionable."

Justice Kos questioned why Torchlight's Kerr had not taken a loan elsewhere when the fund couldn't pay back the money within the 60 day loan period.

"Sixty-one days into the transaction, he could have taken this to another banker and got a presumably more expensive funding option," Kos said. "Instead he has essentially gained the prospect of being able to set aside the continued financing effect on the basis it's a penalty. He gets the money on that basis - 1.5 percent above market - that's a very cheap rate in the circumstances."

Stephen Hunter, the other lawyer for the respondent, said the capital wasn't necessarily at risk despite the fund not meeting the payment obligations as Torchlight had assets but not cash.

"When we're talking about a fee for late repayment, you have the damages recoverable in law, which in this case is either the cost of getting the money elsewhere or the interest costs Wilaci itself was incurring from Credit Suisse, which was $1.8 million - measure that against the penalty, which is $31 million," Hunter said.

The hearing is set down for two days and is continuing.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


RNZ: Porirua Most Expensive Region To Rent, According To Trade Me

A rental website shows this town is now New Zealand's most expensive region to rent a house, ahead of Wellington and Auckland cities. More>>


Stats NZ: Nearly 1,000 More Big Businesses Now Than Two Decades Ago – Media Release

There are now 2,690 big businesses in New Zealand employing more than 100 staff – nearly 1,000 or 58 percent more than 20 years ago, Stats NZ said today. Over the 20 years to February 2020, the total number of enterprises in New Zealand increased ... More>>


RNZ: Housing Boom Could Get Worse, Economist Warns

Economists are calling on the Reserve Bank to reinstate lending restrictions, warning the housing market is spiralling out of control. More>>


Westpac: Sets Out Plan To Go Cheque-Free

Westpac NZ has announced details of its plan to phase out cheques, after signalling in May that it would be supporting a move to other forms of payment. Cheques will cease to be available as a means of payment after 25 June 2021. Westpac NZ General ... More>>


NZTA: Major New Zealand Upgrade Programme Projects Go To Tender

Two major New Zealand Upgrade Programme projects are beginning tenders for construction. The New Zealand Upgrade Programme is a $6.8 billion investment to get our cities moving, to save lives and boost productivity in growth areas. The first Auckland ... More>>

Reserve Bank: RBNZ Seeks To Preserve Benefits Of Cash

The Reserve Bank – Te Pūtea Matua is taking on a new role of steward of the cash system “to preserve the benefits of cash for all who need them”, Assistant Governor Christian Hawkesby told the Royal Numismatics Society of New Zealand annual conference ... More>>


CERT NZ: Malicious Computer Virus Targeting New Zealanders

CERT NZ, the government agency which supports organisations and individuals affected by cyber security incidents, says a recent surge of increasingly sophisticated malware attacks is affecting everyday New Zealanders as well as large organisations. The ... More>>


Economy: NZ Small Business Recovery Continues In September

Xero, the global small business platform, today released its Small Business Insights (XSBI) for September revealing an uptick in small business jobs and year-on-year revenue growth in New Zealand. Nationwide, the average number of jobs in the small ... More>>


Courts: Businessman Eric Watson Sentenced To A Four-Month Jail Term

New Zealand businessman Eric Watson has been sentenced to a four-month jail term in the UK for contempt of court, TVNZ reports. More>>

OECD: Area Employment Rate Falls By 4.0 Percentage Points, To 64.6% In Second Quarter Of 2020

The OECD area employment rate – the share of the working-age population with jobs – fell by 4.0 percentage points, to 64.6%, in the second quarter of 2020, its lowest level since the fourth quarter of 2010. Across the OECD area, 560 million persons ... More>>

Spark: Turns On 5G In Auckland And Offers A Glimpse Into The Future Of Smart Cities

Spark turned on 5G in downtown Auckland today and has partnered with Auckland Transport (AT) to showcase some of the latest in IoT (Internet of Things) technology and demonstrate what the future could look like for Auckland’s CBD with the power of 5G. 5G is ... More>>

Stats NZ: Monthly Migration Remains Low

Since the border closed in late-March 2020, net migration has averaged about 300 a month, Stats NZ said today. In the five months from April to August 2020, overall net migration was provisionally estimated at 1,700. This was made up of a net gain ... More>>