Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Spark shareholders reject virtual-only annual meetings

Friday 04 November 2016 12:52 PM

Spark shareholders give the thumbs down to virtual-only annual meetings

By Fiona Rotherham

Nov. 4 (BusinessDesk) - Spark New Zealand's intention to move to a virtual-only annual meeting next year raised the ire of shareholders attending this year's one in person in Auckland today.

Chairman Mark Verbiest said as the country’s leading digital services company, Spark intends to take a leadership role in what it regards as “the inevitable transition to virtual shareholder meetings”.

“The reality is in today’s world all procedural aspects of the traditional shareholder meetings can now be virtualised, at considerably less cost to companies and to attending shareholders in terms of travel, and at considerably more convenience to those shareholders who live elsewhere and cannot attend (which is the majority of our investor base),” he said.

But the proposal met strong opposition from many of the 130 or so shareholders who turned up at the annual meeting in Auckland, including the New Zealand Shareholders Association, which favours continuing the current hybrid model, where shareholders can participate online through their computers or mobile phones or physically attend. “Hybrids are the way of the future,” said association chairman John Hawkins.

He said the move to a virtual meeting was discussed two years ago with the Spark board but the association thought it would be a retrograde step.

“That view hasn’t changed,” he said. “What it signals is a disenfranchisement of shareholders who don’t have access to or are not comfortable with using modern technology.”

Z Energy is the only other NZX-listed company considering holding virtual-only meetings, due to poor attendance, and Verbiest said shareholder attendance at Spark’s annual meetings has declined by 30 percent in the past five years. He’s had similar feedback of declining attendance from directors in other companies.

Telecommunications network operator Chorus held its annual meeting at its Wellington offices this week, attracting three dozen people and fielding just two questions from the floor.

About 90 listed companies in the US have now moved to fully virtual meetings, Verbiest said.

While access to board and management was always important, shareholders can already actively engage with Spark in different ways, he said. It provided a continuous flow of information through the stock exchange and media announcements, and held regular briefings with institutional investors and proactively engaged with the New Zealand Shareholders Association.

He assured shareholders their views would be taken into consideration before a final decision is made but after the meeting said moving to virtual meetings “was inevitable and sensible”.

Verbiest has also pledged that physical meetings will still be held if any controversial issues arise that need to be debated.

Hawkins said the question is who decides what is controversial and many shareholders expressed their concern at losing the ability to bale up directors and management after the annual meeting on matters they wanted to raise or seek further explanation on.

Shareholder Martin Geary, who is a small shareholder in around 70 NZX companies, said older investors like himself would feel awkward using the web to question directors rather than through face-to-face communications.

“Is this like an ‘Animal Farm’ kind of thing where they can cut us off if they don’t like what we’re saying?” he said.

He also blamed poor shareholder attendance on the venue near Spark’s head office, which has a lack of adjacent free parking.

At the traditional free spread provided by companies after annual meetings, Hawkins said, tongue-in-cheek, he was surprised no shareholder had raised missing out on the food as an objection to virtual meetings.



© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Commerce Commission: Latest Broadband Report Confirms Improved Performance Of Premium Fibre Plans

The latest report from the Commerce Commission’s Measuring Broadband New Zealand programme shows that the performance of Fibre Max plans has improved substantially. This follows a collaboration between the Commission, its independent testing partner, ... More>>

Air New Zealand: Capital Raise Deferred

Air New Zealand has decided to defer its planned capital raise to later in 2021 allowing more time to assess the impacts of recent developments on the airline’s path to recovery. 'We’ve seen some clearing of COVID-19 clouds recently, with ... More>>

Commerce Commission: Cartel Conduct Now Punishable By Up To 7 Years’ Jail Time

Cartel conduct can now be punished with a term of imprisonment of up to 7 years, after the Commerce (Criminalisation of Cartels) Amendment Act 2019 came into effect today. Cartel conduct includes price fixing, market allocation and bid rigging (see ... More>>

Stats NZ: Auckland Population May Hit 2 Million In Early 2030s

Auckland’s population may rise from about 1.7 million currently to 2 million by early next decade, Stats NZ said today. “Auckland will likely have the highest average annual growth of New Zealand’s 16 regions over the next 30 years, from ... More>>

Stats NZ: March Card Spending Rebounds Despite COVID

There was a lift in retail card spending in March following a fall in the lockdown-disrupted February month, Stats NZ said today. Seasonally adjusted retail card spending rose by $53 million (0.9 percent), compared with February 2021. Visit our website to read ... More>>

PwC: Outcome Of Review Into Air New Zealand Gas Turbines Business

Air New Zealand has received the report into its Gas Turbines business from independent external advisers PwC. Air New Zealand Chairman Dame Therese Walsh says the report identified a range of effective controls in the Gas Turbines revenue contracting ... More>>

LPG Association: Renewable LPG Achieves Emissions Budgets With No Need To Ban New LPG Connections

Renewable LPG can supply New Zealand’s LPG needs and achieve the emissions reductions proposed by the Climate Commission without the need to ban new connections, a new study shows. The investigation, by leading consultancy Worley, was prepared for the ... More>>