Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

Fairfax & NZME face difficult decision

Simpson Grierson says Fairfax & NZME face difficult decision whether to appeal Commerce Commission determination


While the Commission's determination to decline clearance and authorisation of the merger is of little surprise, seeing as it reflected the draft determination released last year, the question remains whether Fairfax/NZME will appeal that determination.

Competition partners Anne Callinan and James Craig say the Commission's finding that the merger would substantially lessen competition in relevant markets is unlikely to be the main angle of an appeal.

"While Fairfax/NZME will no doubt be unhappy that the Commission has rejected their confidential submissions as to the likely future for each of their businesses without the merger, this is a factual determination by the Commission, which is typically harder to challenge in an appeal."

Rather, Callinan and Craig say the more productive line for an appeal will probably be regarding whether the public benefits of the merger outweigh the detriments.

The Commission has accepted that there will be quantified benefits of between NZ$40 – $200m over the next five years from the merger. However they have determined that these are outweighed by unquantified detriments relating to the likely loss of media plurality and quality.

"There is a live legal issue as to whether loss of plurality in particular can be considered as a detriment and, even if it can, the extent of that detriment. We would expect this to be a key focus of any appeal."

Ultimately, the chances of success on an appeal aren't clear cut, Simpson Grierson say, and there's also the major issue of the time and cost that it will take to bring an appeal to the High Court.

"Even if Fairfax / NZME were successful there, the Commission could appeal that decision to the Court of Appeal."

ends

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Media: NZME 'In Discussions' To Buy Stuff

NZME confirms that it is in discussions with Stuff’s owners Nine and has put a proposal to the Government regarding a possible transaction. However, NZME notes that these discussions are preliminary... More>>

Consultation: Plan Of Action To Protect Seabirds

The draft National Plan of Action plan outlines the Government’s commitment to reducing fishing-related captures of seabirds, with clear goals and objectives, supported by an implementation plan. More>>

ALSO:

Housing Issues: Fairer Rules For Tenants And Landlords

The key changes include: - Limit rent increases to once every 12 months and banning the solicitation of rental bids by landlords. - Improve tenant’s security by removing a landlord’s right to use no cause terminations to end a periodic tenancy agreement... More>>

ALSO:

Reserve Bank: Official Cash Rate Unchanged At 1 Percent

The Monetary Policy Committee has decided to keep the Official Cash Rate (OCR) at 1.0 percent. Employment remains around its maximum sustainable level while inflation remains below the 2 percent target mid-point but within our target range... More>>

ALSO:

Food Prices: Avocados At Lowest Price In Almost Three Years

Avocados are at their cheapest average price since February 2017, with tomato, lettuce, and cucumber prices also falling, Stats NZ said today. More>>