Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


ERA makes ground-breaking ruling in workplace bullying case

ERA makes “ground-breaking” ruling in workplace bullying case: advocate

The Employment Relations Authority has made a ground-breaking ruling in a workplace bulling case, according to a Hamilton organisation that advocates for victims of workplace bullying.

CultureSafe NZ represented a North Island kindergarten teacher after she alleged she had been bullied by the head kindergarten teacher. Their client was later dismissed by the kindergarten after she refused to return to work under her head teacher because she felt unsafe.

CultureSafe NZ Ltd director Allan Halse said he felt the unjustified dismissal ruling by the ERA* was ground breaking due to the $15,000 humiliation compensation granted being double the usual amount given in these cases and the 17-month wage reimbursement amount also exceeded the average maximum timeframe granted.

“Normally the average amount given if you win at the Authority is between $6000 and $8000 compensation for hurt and humiliation cases, and a maximum of three months’ wage reimbursement, and that’s only if you win,” Halse said.

After more than 20 years as a primary school teacher, CultureSafe’s client retrained as an early childhood education teacher and was offered a job at the centre where she had completed her required practicum training.

In March 2015, she made a written bullying complaint against the head teacher and by agreement was placed on paid special leave while the investigation took place. On June 12, 2015, her complaint was upheld and the head teacher was disciplined, but not dismissed.

“The bully was found to be a bully,” Halse said.

She was concerned about returning to work under the head teacher in the same circumstances. The head teacher refused to acknowledge any wrongdoing and was not prepared to apologise for her actions.
CultureSafe NZ Ltd was enlisted to help her resolve the situation by prompting her employer to acknowledge that the bullying had caused harm.

“Our client wanted more reassurance to be able to return to work in a safe working environment,” Halse said.

He said the Kindergarten Association advised his client that if she wanted to return to work she must do so under their conditions and that she must compromise all potential legal claims against the kindergarten or they would take it as her resigning from her job.

CultureSafe responded to the Kindergarten Association advising them that their client was reluctant “to be forced in to exactly the same work environment under the same bully” and felt the Association intended to bully her in to resigning.

“One of the things that we see occurring time and time again is that when a person says that they feel unsafe, they are forced to remain in their same working environment despite the physiological and psychological damage that it has on their wellbeing,” said Halse.

The termination case ended up being ruled in CultureSafe NZ Ltd’s favour, stating that it was an unjustified dismissal for their client.

The ERA ruled that she will have her wages reimbursed of what she would have earnt since the unjustified dismissal in October 2015 up until the date of determination at the ruling on February 28, 2017. She would also receive a $15,000 compensation for her humiliation suffered during the ongoing investigation.
He said the ruling sends a message to employers and organisations that they cannot force staff to work in an unsafe working environment.

“Unfortunately, we deal with a lot of employers who don’t like to follow legitimate processes and this occasion is a good example of that,” Halse said.

“We’re incredibly pleased to see the ERA pass down this important ruling, which employers should heed.”
However, the win was short-lived as the publication of this decision has been fought since March 1, 2017, just a few days after the ruling, when a non-publication order was put in place by the Authority and an application for permanent non-publication had to be challenged.

The determination was subsequently anonymised in order to have it published. Halse said there has been a significant delay due to the Authority not putting the determination on the Employment Law Database website even though the second determination was issued and received on May 18. Because of the impact the ruling will have, Halse has been trying for four months, since the original determination was received on January 28, 2017 to have it published.

Halse said he was disappointed that it had taken six weeks for the final determination to be published.
“It should have only taken days to put up, rather than months.”

Halse cited CultureSafe NZ Ltd’s most recent determination from the Authority as an example – that of Morgan vs the Auckland District Health Board, dated June 26, 2017, has already been published.
“The delay in publishing the determination is actually preventing access to justice for not only our clients but all other workplace bullying victims being represented by unions and lawyers,” Halse said.

He said that throughout New Zealand 1 in 5 people are bullied in the workplace.
“That equates to 400,000 New Zealanders who are being bullied right now.”
* ([2017] NZERA Auckland 14)

© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Consumer NZ: Buy-now, Pay-later Raking In $10m+ In Late Fees Annually

A Consumer NZ survey has found buy-now, pay-later services are costing shoppers more than $10 million a year in late fees. Close to four out of 10 Kiwi consumers use buy-now, pay-later services, such as Afterpay, Laybuy and Zip... More>>

Westpac: Catherine Mcgrath Appointed New Zealand CEO

Westpac Group CEO Peter King and the Westpac New Zealand Board today announced the appointment of Catherine McGrath as Chief Executive Officer, Westpac New Zealand... More>>

Amazon: AWS To Open Data Centres In New Zealand

Today, Amazon Web Services (AWS), announced plans to open an infrastructure region in Aotearoa New Zealand in 2024. The new AWS Asia Pacific (Auckland) Region will consist of three Availability Zones (AZs) and join the existing 81 Availability Zones across 25 geographic AWS Regions at launch... More>>


Statistics: Surge In Imports Results In Record Monthly Trade Deficit
Imports increased $1.8 billion in August 2021 compared with August 2020, resulting in a record monthly trade deficit of $2.1 billion, Stats NZ said today. Exports were little changed, down $42 million. "This is a larger deficit than normal because of higher values for imports.. More>>

Fonterra: Completes reset, announces annual results and long-term growth plan out to 2030

Fonterra Co-operative Group Limited today announced a strong set of results for the 2021 financial year, reflected in a final Farmgate Milk Price of $7.54, normalised earnings per share of 34 cents and a final dividend of 15 cents... More>>

Statistics: GDP rises in the June 2021 quarter

Gross domestic product (GDP) rose by 2.8 percent in the June 2021 quarter, following a 1.4 percent increase in the March 2021 quarter, Stats NZ said today. June 2021 quarter GDP was 4.3 percent higher when compared with the December 2019 quarter... More>>