Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Supreme Court rules on PwC, litigation funding case

Supreme Court rules on PwC, litigation funding case despite out-of-court settlement

By Sophie Boot

Oct. 6 (BusinessDesk) - The Supreme Court has ruled that litigation funder LPF Group was allowed to back a legal claim against PricewaterhouseCoopers, despite the two parties settling their dispute in private.

The lawsuit from the liquidators of David Henderson's failed property development firm Property Ventures (PVL), which was bankrolled by LPF in return for 42.5 percent of any settlement, had alleged PwC and managing partner Maurice Noone advised PVL on ways to continue trading when by some accounts it was insolvent while at the same time giving the company a clean bill of health as auditor. PwC had denied the allegations.

PwC asked the High Court to stay the proceedings, saying the funding was an abuse of process, but that was dismissed in 2015. That ruling was upheld by the Court of Appeal in 2016, and a further appeal was heard in the Supreme Court in March this year.

In August, the parties reached a confidential settlement, though the Supreme Court said it had still chosen to issue its judgment today "because the appeal involves important issues" and the underlying proceeding is continuing against other defendants.

The majority of the bench said they would have allowed the appeal to the extent that they would have allowed the litigation funding to remain, but would have required the funders to enter into a contract which lessened their control of the litigation and ensured it would pay out any money recovered to unsecured creditors.

The litigation funders made undertakings to do both of those things in court submissions, but the undertakings were not presented in the High Court or Court of Appeal hearings, and the Supreme Court said it was undesirable that the court be presented with a position that differs materially from that presented in the lower court and that both issues could and should have been dealt with earlier. The majority of the bench would not have awarded any costs.

Chief Justice Sian Elias gave a dissenting judgment, saying the court should not deliver its findings following the settlement. She said it was "well-arguable that the litigation funding agreement in issue here is contrary to law", though PwC had not asked the courts to consider that, but thought it was "undesirable" for the court to give judgment as the dispute was settled and the scope of the argument had been constrained.

The Chief Justice said that the likely effect of the judgment was that it will be considered a development in litigation funding law, "even though such development was not the subject of argument", and that such a development should only occur after it has been fully argued.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Stats NZ: Consents For New Homes At All-Time High

A record 41,028 new homes have been consented in the year ended March 2021, Stats NZ said today. The previous record for the annual number of new homes consented was 40,025 in the year ended February 1974. “Within 10 years the number of new homes ... More>>

Stats NZ: Unemployment Declines As Underutilisation Rises

The seasonally adjusted unemployment rate decreased to 4.7 percent in the March 2021 quarter, continuing to fall from its recent peak of 5.2 percent in the September 2020 quarter but remaining high compared with recent years, Stats NZ said today. ... More>>


Digitl: The Story Behind Vodafone’s FibreX Court Ruling

Vodafone’s FibreX service was in the news this week. What is the story behind the Fair Trading Act court case? More>>

Reserve Bank: Concerned About New Zealand's Rising House Prices

New Zealand house prices have risen significantly in the past 12 months. This has raised concerns at the Reserve Bank of New Zealand – Te Putea Matua about the risk this poses to financial stability. Central banks responded swiftly to the global ... More>>

Westpac: Announces Strong Financial Result

Westpac New Zealand (Westpac NZ) [i] says a strong half-year financial result has been driven by better than expected economic conditions. Chief Executive David McLean said while the global COVID-19 pandemic was far from over, the financial effect on ... More>>

MYOB: SME Confidence In Economic Performance Still Cautious

New insights from the annual MYOB Business Monitor have shown the SME sector is still cautious about the potential for further economic recovery, with two-in-five (41%) expecting the New Zealand economy to decline this year. The latest research ... More>>