Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

Lawyers disagree on 'moveable feast' in media merger case

Lawyers disagree on 'moveable feast' appeal in media merger case

By Sophie Boot

Oct. 18 (BusinessDesk) - Lawyers in the media merger appeal case in Wellington's High Court have clashed over a second appeal made by lawyers for Stuff and NZME, which the Commerce Commission says has been undisciplined and inappropriate.

The media companies have filed a second appeal running parallel to the first. The primary appeal is on the factual and legal errors they say the commission made in rejecting the merger, while the second is on the process the regulator used to reach its decision, which they argue didn't abide by principles of natural justice and procedural fairness, so have asked the court to disregard some evidence.

Justice Robert Dobson had suggested the second appeal be heard after the commission's lawyers have finished its arguments on the first appeal, so that lay person Professor Martin Richardson, who is assisting him, would be spared the arguments on procedural law.

The media company's lawyer David Goddard QC accepted this, but James Farmer QC, representing the commission, said this morning that there was an "unhappy history around the process allegations which have been made", with the scope of the case contracting and broadening over time, and he wanted as much time as possible to consider the commission's response to the arguments brought up in the second appeal.

"It's been very much a moveable feast, and we're rather unhappy at the prospect of that feast moving yet again when we hear the presentation of oral submissions to this court," Farmer said. "Equally, we're not totally convinced there might not be some inter-relationship between the two [appeals], and for those reasons we would prefer to hear the whole of the appellant's case and then we will follow with the whole of our case in response."

The judge said the case "has certainly been a concertina in its scope" and he would discuss the matter with Professor Richardson and come back to the lawyers, but was sympathetic to Farmer's views.

In regards to the second appeal, the media lawyers say that the commission placed too much reliance on interviews of third parties known to be opposed to the proposed merger, especially as it didn't give the publishers themselves the opportunity to review and comment on the interviews, though their lawyers have had access. They also say there was "inadequate process" around a report by BDO Wellington, and have asked the court to place no weight on the interviews and the BDO report.

The regulator's lawyers, in a synopsis of their submissions on the process appeal, say there was no breach of procedural fairness, and the current appeal can cure any prejudice, meaning excluding the relevant evidence "is both novel and inappropriate." They also say that in many cases, the alleged deficiencies were known about at the time but the appellants didn't object to them.

The commission also indicated it wishes to recover costs from the media companies over the second appeal, which it says has been pursued in a way which "lacked appropriate discipline and put it to considerable unnecessary expense".

(BusinessDesk)

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Reserve Bank: Ongoing Monetary Tightening
The Monetary Policy Committee today increased the Official Cash Rate (OCR) to 3 percent from 2.5 percent. The Committee agreed it remains appropriate to continue to tighten monetary conditions... More>>



Statistics: Weekly Earnings Rise As More In Full-time Employment

Median weekly earnings from wages and salaries rose by 8.8 percent to $1,189 in the year to the June 2022 quarter, Stats NZ said today... More>>



Bell Gully: Uncertainty Ahead With New Unconscionable Conduct Legislation

new prohibition against ‘unconscionable conduct’ in trade is one of a number of changes to the Fair Trading Act 1986 that come into force from 16 August 2022. The new prohibition may have wide-ranging implications for many businesses... More>>


Electricity Authority: Imposes Interim Restrictions On Very Large Electricity Contracts

Consumers of electricity will be protected from potentially paying more than they should due to the impact of very large electricity contracts on wholesale prices, under urgent changes announced today by the Electricity Authority... More>>


Westpac: Economic Overview, August 2022 – Pushing Through

The New Zealand economy faces some lean growth in the year ahead as households’ budgets are squeezed, according to Westpac’s latest Economic Overview... More>>


Kiwi Group Holdings: Fisher Funds Acquires Kiwi Wealth Business

Kiwi Group Holdings Limited (KGHL) today announced the sale of Kiwi Wealth to Fisher Funds for NZ$310 million... More>>