Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

LPF Group Seeks Investigation Over Chief Justice’s Conduct

LPF Group Seeks Investigation Over Chief Justice’s Conduct

LPF Group has laid an official complaint to the Judicial Complaints Commissioner against the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of New Zealand, the Right Honourable Dame Sian Elias, relating to a case brought by the liquidators of PVL Limited, against PricewaterhouseCoopers and the Directors of PVL.

The complaint is brought “on the basis of a breach of natural justice, judicial bias and a failure to disclose potential conflicts of interest to all parties,” LPF Group director Phil Newland said today.

“This isn’t a decision LPF Group has taken lightly,” Mr Newland said. “However, the Chief Justice is the most senior judge in New Zealand, and her opinions carry considerable weight in the legal community.”

“Given the potential implications for plaintiffs accessing justice through litigation funding, often against well-resourced defendants typically with large insurance companies behind them, LPF Group feels very strongly that the circumstances need to be investigated in this instance.

“The potential impact of the comments has been highlighted by the way a significant insurance law firm representing the other side in the case has reported the decision in a public newsletter, as “creating uncertainty over litigation funding” Mr Newland said.

“The complaint is not related to the legal outcome of the case. The Chief Justice offered a series of unfair and unjustified opinions which were not related to the legal questions before the Court, and made incorrect and highly concerning remarks about the legitimacy of litigation funding in New Zealand.”

“Further, we believe potential material conflicts of interest with the insurance industry should have been disclosed by the Chief Justice. It was never disclosed to the parties that the Chief Justice’s husband Hugh Fletcher, is chairman of IAG New Zealand Limited which we believe is likely to be an insurer of one of the parties to the case in question and the largest insurer of professional liability in New Zealand.”

“Mr Fletcher is also a director and shareholder of the parent company Insurance Australia Group Limited, which is one of the largest insurers of professional liability in Australasia. The defendants in this case, as in most of the high-profile cases LPF Group is currently funding, have professional liability insurance.”

Mr Newland adds “In any case like this, with prominent directors, and professional services firms involved, it would have been obvious that the defendants had any number of professional liability insurance firms involved. Vero Insurance is even a named party to the claim.”

“Some of the Chief Justice’s historical concerns about litigation funding can be found in the Minutes of the Courts of New Zealand Rules Committee. In fact, the topic of litigation funding arose for discussion at a meeting of the Rules Committee in February 2017 at which counsel for PWC, Bruce Gray QC, was present. That meeting took place just one month before the hearing of the PWC/PVL appeal in the Supreme Court.”

“Many plaintiffs who have suffered losses can’t afford to bring litigation to hold those responsible to account. As in the PVL case, they are often up against well-resourced defendants who have professional liability insurance, and cannot afford many of the delaying tactics employed by defendants and their insurance companies to avoid being held accountable through the Courts.”

“Litigation funding levels the playing field so plaintiffs with meritorious cases can access justice. The Chief Justice’s comments have increased the risks associated with litigation funding which can only make funding less available and increase the cost of obtaining funding for plaintiffs” Mr Newland said.

The matter between the liquidators of PVL and PWC was settled before judgment was issued. The other four judges issued a judgment which indicated how they would have ruled had they been required to – and that ruling was favourable to the liquidators and LPF Group.


ENDS


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Government: Delivering Lower Card Fees To Business

Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister David Clark has today announced the Government’s next steps to reduce merchant service fees, that banks charge businesses when customers use a credit or debit card to pay, which is estimated to save New Zealand businesses ... More>>

SEEK NZ Employment Report: April 2021

OVERVIEW OF APRIL 2021: STATE OF THE NATION: April, for the second consecutive month, saw the highest number of jobs ever advertised on seek.co.nz. Applications per job ad fell 9% month-on-month (m/m). SEEK job ads were up by 12% m/m. SEEK job ads were ... More>>

Commerce Commission: Warns Genesis Over Business Billing Errors

The Commerce Commission has issued a warning to Genesis Energy Limited about billing errors concerning electricity line charges to business customers. Genesis reported the errors to the Commission. The Commission considers that Genesis is likely to ... More>>

Stats: Lower Job Security Linked To Lower Life Satisfaction

People who feel their employment is insecure are more likely than other employed people to rate their overall life satisfaction poorly, Stats NZ said today. New survey data from the March 2021 quarter shows that 26 percent of employed people who thought ... More>>

The Conversation: The Outlook For Coral Reefs Remains Grim Unless We Cut Emissions Fast — New Research

A study of 183 coral reefs worldwide quantified the impacts of ocean warming and acidification on reef growth rates. Even under the lowest emissions scenarios, the future of reefs is not bright. More>>

The Conversation: Why Now Would Be A Good Time For The Reserve Bank Of New Zealand To Publish Stress Test Results For Individual Banks

Set against the backdrop of an economy healing from 2020’s annus horribilis , this week’s Financial Stability Report (FSR) from the Reserve Bank (RBNZ) was cautiously reassuring: the country’s financial system is sound, though vulnerabilities remain. More>>