Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Justice not blind after all

In the past a lot has been said about Lady Justice wearing a blindfold, but every now and again it would seem like she peeps out from underneath, just to wink and let us know that she might be blindfolded but that that doesn’t mean she is blind.

This was the case once again in the matter of D & L Smith vs S Muir in the Employment Relations Authority (ERA) recently.

Mr & Mrs Smith applied for a position with Mr Muir as a 2IC and farm hand. They both provided their CV’s, listing three previous farms as references. Mr Muir tried contacting the listed references but were only able to reach one of the three, whom gave them a positive reference.

During the interview the employment agreement was discussed and both Mr & Mrs Smith were shown a copy and acknowledged that they were familiar with the standard Federated Farmers agreement. A formal offer was made and the Smiths were informed by Mr Muir that they could sign the agreement when they arrive on the farm.

The Smiths arrived on the farm on the 31st of May 2017, received the employment agreement and commenced work on the 1st of June 2017. Needless to say, their employment commenced without them signing the employment agreement. This point is important as it invalidated the 90 day trial period.

During their tenure, Mr Muir had endless problems with the Smiths with regards to punctuality, their demeanour and capability to work as a 2IC and farm hand. Mr Muir was also informed that the Smiths actually moved around extensively and were not stationed on the farms as mentioned in their CV’s. Mr Muir tried contacting the reference again, with no success this time.

Mr Muir then decided the invoke the 90 day trial period clause and to terminate the service of the Smiths.

Subsequent to the termination a previous employer of the pair made contact with Mr Muir, informing Mr Muir that the Smiths were employed by him from 1 June to 23 July 2016. He terminated their service under the 90 day trial period for being unreliable, verbally abusive, not competent and causing distress to the animals. This proved that the Smiths were dishonest on their CV’s.

Correctly, the Member of the Authority presiding over this matter found that Mr Muir could not have relied on the 90 day trial period when he dismissed the Smiths as they had started employment before they signed the employment agreement.

The 90 day trial period was not the only issue to rule on, but for the sake of keeping the article short, we only refer to this issue.

Interestingly and rightfully so, the Member of the Authority made a ruling on the remedies, relying on previous case law, Xtreme Dining Ltd t/a Think Steel v Dewar (2016), where the Court said that where there has been outrageous or particularly serious employee misconduct, the absence of a remedy may be appropriate. In other words, even though the employee was found to be unjustifiably dismissed, the Authority or Court can determine that the employee do not receive a remedy as he/she is primarily responsible for the situation due to their misconduct.

In this particular case the Member of the ERA found that the Smiths were guilty of outrageous, particularly egregious or disgraceful misconduct in two areas specifically;
1. They delayed signing the employment agreement provided to them before commencement of work, knowing this would invalidate the 90 day trial period. Knowing that Mr Muir relied on this clause to terminate their service, believing it is valid, they didn’t act in good faith towards their employer by informing him of the invalidity but rather relied on this misperception to build their case.
2. They submitted falsified CV’s to Mr Muir misrepresenting themselves and obtaining a job that they would not otherwise have been offered.

No remedy was awarded to the Smiths.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Tiwai Point: Rio Tinto Announces Plans To Close Tiwai Point Smelter

Rio Tinto has just announced that it will wind down New Zealand Aluminium Smelters - the Tiwai Point smelter - saying the business is no longer viable. More>>


Freight: New Report On Auckland Port Relocation

The Government has released a major new report on the options for relocating the Port of Auckland’s freight operations while deferring any decision on the issue. More>>


Chartered Accountants: COVID-19 Fails To Knock Kiwi Investor Confidence, But More Disclosure Wanted

Three months of COVID-19 lockdown and investment turmoil has done little to knock confidence in New Zealand capital markets and listed companies with overall investor sentiment very similar to 2019, an investor survey held in mid June shows. However, ... More>>


Taxation: Black-Market Tobacco Sidesteps $287 Million In Excise Tax

Year-on-year increases in consumption of illicit tobacco in New Zealand have seen illegal trade swell to 11.5% of the total market. If consumed legally, illicit products would have netted the Government $287 million in excise tax during 2019. Independent ... More>>


Energy Sector: Meridian Spilled Water To Hike Electricity Prices - Authority Ruling

The Electricity Authority has found that generator Meridian Energy manipulated the power market, costing consumers about $80 million. More>>


XE Data Update: RBNZ Official Cash Rate Decision

The RBNZ will keep the Official Cash Rate (OCR) at 0.25%. T he key points in the RBNZ statement are: RBNZ keeps the OCR unchanged at 0.25% Maintain the LSAP (large scale asset purchase) at NZD$60 billion. Committee prepared to use additional monetary ... More>>


Electricity: Kiwis Ignore Promise Of Cheaper Power

Electric Kiwi and Flick Electric Co are joint winners of Canstar Blue’s award for Most Satisfied Customers | Electricity Providers From putting on an extra layer – rather than turning on a heater – to turning off lights and choosing the energy-saving ... More>>


Electricity: Transmission Pricing For A Low Carbon Future

The Electricity Authority has decided on new guidelines for transmission pricing. James Stevenson-Wallace, Chief Executive of the Electricity Authority says the new guidelines will deliver significant benefits to consumers, through lower electricity ... More>>


RNZ: Economic Activity And Business Confidence Bouncing Back

Two surveys from ANZ show business confidence and economic activity have rebounded, but uncertainty about the future remains extreme. More>>


NIWA: The Climate Record That Keeps Getting Broken

Among the multitude of New Zealand climate statistics there is one record that continues to be broken month after month. Since January 2017 there has not been one month that recorded a below average nationwide temperature, according to NIWA’s seven station ... More>>


Govt: Extended Loan Scheme Keeps Business Afloat

Small businesses are getting greater certainty about access to finance with an extension to the interest-free cashflow loan scheme to the end of the year. The Small Business Cashflow Loan Scheme has already been extended once, to 24 July. Revenue and Small ... More>>


Science: 2019 Prime Minister’s Science Prizes Announced

The 2019 Prime Minister’s Science Prizes have been announced in a digital livestream event today. The Prizes recognise the impact of science on New Zealanders’ lives, celebrate the achievements of current scientists and encourage scientists of the ... More>>


RNZ: Fuel, Alcohol Costs To Go Up From Today

The increase today in the taxes on fuel, road user charges and alcohol is being called a tone-deaf move. More>>


Stardome Observatory: Young Kiwi Astro-Photographer Shoots For The Stars

Matariki by Josh Kirkley. The stars are aligning for up-and-coming Auckland-based astro-photographer Josh Kirkley (Kāi Tahu). During lockdown, one of his images was picked up by NASA and shared on the space agency’s Instagram to its 59.2 million ... More>>

DCANZ: Time For EU To Commit To A Level Playing Field For Trade

The Dairy Companies Association of New Zealand (DCANZ) has welcomed New Zealand Trade Minister David Parker’s statement that it is unacceptable for New Zealand exporters to continue facing an ‘unlevel playing field’ in the EU. Details leaked ... More>>


New Zealand Government: Supporting Kiwi Businesses To Resolve Rent Disputes

The Government will legislate to ensure businesses that suffered as a result of the COVID-19 response will get help to resolve disputes over commercial rent issues, Justice Minister Andrew Little announced today. More>>