Y2k: Fourth Business and Sector Progress Surveys
NATIONAL READINESS
Fourth Business and Sector Progress
Surveys
Introduction
The fourth set of surveys was carried out between 2 and 13 August 1999 on an anonymous basis. The survey methods were the same as those used for the first three apart from these differences:
a
fifth sub-sample comprising very large firms of 500 or more
persons was added to the business telephone-based
survey;
paper-based sector surveys were added
for samples of General Practitioners and Truck Operators.
The business survey comprised 1383 completed interviews and the response rate was 63%. 15 sector surveys were carried out.
Additional questions were added to those used in the third survey in order to:
measure
progress towards readiness with the computers and equipment
essential for business survival as well as progress with all
of the items used;
explore the reasons why firms
state that they do not need a business continuity
plan;
examine in more detail the expected
completion dates for all Y2K preparations and the reasons
for any slippage which had been experienced in recent
months.
Readiness of Business Generally
Large and Very Large Business
Previous surveys treated all firms with 50 or more persons as a single survey sample referred to as "large". In the August survey, firms with 500 or more persons were separated out into a separate "very large" category.
Forward progress has continued and firms continue to anticipate completing all Y2K preparations before the end of 1999. However slippage is also apparent. In June one quarter of firms anticipated completing in the last quarter of the year; in August the proportion was one half. 18% of very large firms expect to complete all of their preparations in December.
Very large firms lead all others in the extent to which they are regularly monitoring their suppliers’ progress and communicating their own progress to customers:
Size of firm::::::% regularly
monitoring suppliers::::::% regularly communicating own
progress to customers::::::% with all computers "ready
now"
1 – 3:::::: 11::::::6::::::51
4 –
9::::::18::::::11::::::53
10 –
49::::::17::::::9::::::49
50 –
499::::::25::::::21::::::34
500
+::::::52::::::32::::::28
The proportion of firms
stating that their computers are "ready now" has not changed
significantly over the two months.
SMEs
The proportion of very small firms (1 to 3 persons) which have not yet started on managing the risk in their own computers and equipment is now down to 9%. Approximately one half of all SMEs state that their computers and equipment are ready now, with no significant change from the June survey. However the proportion of them anticipating that they will not be ready by the end of 1999 is now down to 3% in the August survey down from 9% in June.
The proportion of SMEs who state that they do not need a business continuity plan has decreased only slightly despite the Commission's second direct mail brochure focusing attention on this area of need.
::::::Do not need continuity plans
::::::1 -
3::::::4 - 9::::::10 - 49
June 1999
%::::::49::::::35::::::23
August 1999 %::::::43
::::::33::::::25
A number of reasons are advanced by SMEs for this as the following table, in respect of the smallest firms, shows:
Reason for not needing a business continuity
plan::::::% of 1 - 3 person firms
The problem will only
affect us for a very short time::::::41
We can manage any
problems that arise::::::23
The only problem we expect
will be with services about which we can do
nothing::::::20
Any problems will be sorted out by the
time we come back from the Christmas break::::::18
We
won't know what we can do until it happens::::::18
In many cases these reasons may not be soundly based though the individual business concerned is best placed to make such a judgement. It may be that, with less than four months to go, further use of Commission resources on the SME sector may not be warranted, beyond urging firms to make use of the advice in the "Plan Now To B Y2K Wise" brochure sent to all SMEs recently.
When compared with other countries that are considered to be relatively advanced in their management of Y2K, New Zealand's SME sector has made good progress. Taking into account the proportion of firms which have no computers or equipment of their own, the survey results suggest that around 16% of New Zealand SMEs have not yet started to address their Y2K risks in any way. These are mainly micro firms in the 1 to 3 person range.
This figure contrasts with the Australian Bureau of Statistics’ figures for June 1999 indicating that around 40% of Australian businesses intended to do nothing. Action 2000 from the United Kingdom report, also in June, that 54% of their micro businesses (1 to 9 persons) were taking "appropriate action".
With respect to progress in management of external risks and business continuity plans New Zealand 1 to 3 and United Kingdom 1 to 9 person micro businesses were roughly on a par in June.
State Sector / Public Hospitals / Local Government / Large Business
In this analysis, the August survey results for the three government sectors are compared with the combined large and very large samples merged into one sector to enable comparison with the June survey results. The June figures are shown in parenthesis:
::::::Remediation or avoidance - all
computers and equipment::::::Testing - all computers and
equipment::::::Regularly Communicating to
Customers::::::Business Continuity Plans
Sector::::::%
Completed::::::% Completed::::::%::::::% Completed
State
Sector::::::54 (44)::::::27 (21)::::::19 (19)::::::35
(23)
Public Hospitals::::::58 (50)::::::32 (14)::::::42
(57)::::::74 (29)
Local Govt::::::56 (36)::::::32
(10)::::::39 (28)::::::42 (28)
Large Business
(50 +
persons)::::::44 (44)::::::25 (28)::::::23 (25)::::::30
(26)
The government sectors have now overtaken large business in almost every particular.
Major Utility Sectors (Banking, Energy, Telecommunications etc)
::::::Remediation or avoidance - essential computers
and equipment *::::::Testing - essential computers and
equipment *
::::::Regularly Communicating to
Customers::::::Business Continuity Plans
Sector::::::%
Completed::::::% Completed::::::%::::::%
Completed
Banking and Finance::::::92 (70)::::::77
(60)::::::92 (80)::::::85 (70)
Electricity::::::67
(47)::::::43 (37)::::::30 (30)::::::30 (14)
Oil
Fuels::::::86 (80)::::::57 (40)::::::86 (80)::::::71
(0)
Tele-communications::::::96 (94)::::::86
(81)::::::100 (100)::::::85 (75)
Air Transport::::::61
(30)::::::66 (35)::::::38 (50)::::::17 (10)
All Large
Business (50 + persons)::::::53 (44)::::::25 (28)::::::23
(25)::::::30 (26)
*::::::The August figures refer to computer systems and equipment essential for business continuity; the June figures (in parenthesis) refer to all systems.
The utility sectors have made substantial progress towards readiness in their essential systems and are substantially ahead of large business in general. Their anticipated dates for completion of all preparations are likewise earlier.
Percentage completing in the last
quarter of 1999:
::::::
::::::% completing in last
quarter 1999
Banking and
Finance::::::16
Electricity::::::23
Oil
Fuels::::::28
Telecommunications::::::2
Air
Transport::::::39
Large Business (50 +
persons)::::::50
Slippage
The range of slippage being experienced across all businesses is shown by these figures: 20% of 1 to 3 and 49% of 500+ person businesses report that their preparations will be completed later than was planned a few months earlier. Across all businesses the reasons advanced for the slippage by those who had experienced it were:
Reason for
slippage::::::%
Becoming Y2K ready is more difficult than
expected::::::36
Critical HR not available when
needed::::::20
Upgrade equipment or software not
available when needed::::::15
Other
priorities::::::10
Waiting on others for
information::::::9
It is the nature of the Y2K problem
that you have to keep working at it until December and
beyond::::::8
Procrastination::::::7
Lack of
time::::::5
Able to fit non-Y2K work into the
schedule::::::5
All other reasons ::::::17
Don't
know::::::2
Note: Multiple answers were obtained for this question so the percentages do not add up to 100%.
The reasons advanced for slippage suggest that in the bulk of cases it is real and not due either to an improved view of good practice or to deliberate delays resulting from better-than-expected progress. On the other hand, while 22% of all businesses have experienced slippage, 7% expect to complete earlier than they expected a few months ago and 60% expect to complete on time as planned. Only 4% of all firms and 2% of 500+ person firms do not expect to be ready before the end of this year.
Confidence in essential services
Businesses were again asked to express their levels of confidence in the essential services on which they depend. Overall confidence levels remain high. Of particular interest, however, in the context of Y2K are the levels of "no confidence" because there is the danger that these could translate into negative actions such as panic buying or withdrawals of funds.
Levels of "no confidence" in essential services are shown below:
Essential service::::::Level of "no confidence"
among 1 to 3 person firms - 32% of these have monitored
their suppliers::::::Level of "no confidence" among 500+
person firms - 93% of these have monitored their
suppliers
Electricity::::::7::::::0
Gas::::::7::::::0
Oil
fuels::::::7::::::2
Water::::::8::::::7
Sewerage::::::10::::::7
Tele-communications::::::12::::::5
Goods
and passenger transport::::::8::::::2
Banking and
finance::::::15::::::2
The levels of no confidence among micro businesses are slightly lower or the same as those recorded in June. The lower levels among very large business can be taken to reflect their more thorough assessment of the state of readiness of their suppliers.
This view is also supported by percentages of "no
confidence" and "have monitored suppliers" for selected
sectors presented below:
Sector expressing level of "no
confidence"::::::
%
who have monitored their suppliers
::::::Electricity::::::Gas::::::Oil::::::Water::::::Sewerage::::::Telecommunications::::::Transport::::::Banking
Electricity::::::94::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::3::::::3::::::3::::::4::::::0
Gas::::::100::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0
Oil::::::100::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0
Water/Sewerage
(Local
government)::::::97::::::2::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::5::::::0::::::0
Telecommunications::::::100::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0
Transport
- Civil
aviation::::::83::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0
Transport
–
Land::::::90::::::5::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0
Banking::::::100::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0::::::0
1
to
3::::::32::::::7::::::7::::::7::::::8::::::10::::::12::::::8::::::15
500+::::::93::::::0::::::0::::::2::::::7::::::7::::::5::::::2::::::2
General
Practitioners::::::36::::::10::::::4::::::14::::::12::::::12::::::10::::::10::::::10
The essential service sectors express extremely low levels of "no confidence" in one another associated with an even higher degree of monitoring of their suppliers' progress than very large businesses. It would be very desirable if this level of informed confidence could be transferred to the general public and small businesses.
General Practitioners
It is noteworthy that General Practitioners, who were included as a sector for the first time in this survey, are exhibiting similar rates of progress to small businesses in general. This is evidenced in the table above by their relatively high levels of no confidence in essential services combined with their low level of monitoring of their suppliers. The Gartner Group noted in a recent report (Year 2000 World Status: The Final Countdown) that medical practices comprised one of the sectors which was least advanced world-wide, in managing Y2K risk. The Ministry of Health has taken initiatives already to assist GP practices to manage their Y2K risks in time.
Progress on Critical Systems
This survey distinguished between progress with managing Y2K risk on critical computers and equipment as opposed to managing risk on all of those items, regardless of their significance to the business. The responses showed an interesting result, across the board, over business and sectors that progress taking all items into account is approximately 5% behind that achieved with the critical ones. Thus completion of testing all computers and equipment trails completion of testing for critical items in large business by 8% (25% as opposed to 33%) and in the electricity sector by 4% (43% as opposed to 47%).
John Good
::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::16 September
1999
Special
Adviser::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::