CAS Olympic Selection Appeal Decision - 28 April
CAS Olympic Selection Appeal Decision - 28 April
The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) has released its reason behind Yachting New Zealands appeal being upheld. Yachting New Zealand are relieved to see the reasoning released by CAS and to find that they found no fault of Yachting New Zealand’s Olympic Team selection panel. In their view "the approach adopted by the panel was an appropriate one and conformed with the criteria". The decision highlighted that the earlier the Sports Disputes Tribunal's criticism of the selectors was in the opinion of CAS "fatally flawed."
In the decision released last night CAS noted "the Tribunal has trespassed in to the forbidden field of reviewing the decisions of the panel on the merits as opposed to determining whether the nomination panel as a matter of law breached the criteria." CAS went on to note "the Tribunals reasoning seems to substitute its own views of the merits of the assessment of those results for that of the panel."
Yachting New Zealand’s Chief Executive Simon
Wickham comments, "We are pleased that CAS have supported
Yachting New Zealands view that our expert panel of
selectors properly implemented the appropriate nomination
criteria and that the decisions originally made were
correct.
The veracity of the Court of Arbitration for
Sport's report clearly justifies the Board and Yachting New
Zealands decision to appeal the Sports Disputes Tribunals
findings, to ensure the right of the selectors to exercise
their expert judgement in determining selections for the
Olympic Games.
We believed at the time and still believe
that conclusions reached by the Sports Disputes Tribunal
were unacceptable and untenable.
It is deeply regrettable
that we had to go to such lengths to have our beliefs
confirmed."