News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search


Stars plus warnings for healthier food choices

New Zealanders would find it easier to eat better and nurture their own and their families’ health if packaged food and drink had to carry a health star rating, a health warning, or both, University of Auckland experts say.

Professor Cliona Ni Mhurchu and her team compared the voluntary Health Star Rating (HSR) system used in Aotearoa New Zealand and Australia with the mandatory health warning system used in Chile.

The Chilean system involves one or more black ‘stop signs’ on the front of packages and bottles warning the product is high in energy (calories), added sugar, salt or saturated fat. It was put in place 2016 to help curb rising obesity, with 75 percent of Chileans over 15 years overweight or obese according to latest figures. In New Zealand, that figure is 65 percent. More broadly, dietary factors are the leading cause of avoidable health loss here.

The Health Star Rating system rates food from half a star (least healthy) to five stars (healthiest).
For the comparison, the Auckland researchers classified almost 14,000 packaged food and beverages according to both systems. They found that two-thirds (67 percent) of New Zealand products would have at least one health warning under the Chilean system. Around one-third would require a warning for high energy (37 percent), high sodium (34 percent), high sugar (33 percent) or high saturated fat (29 percent).

For almost nine out of ten products, the two systems largely agreed with each other. But around eight percent received conflicting ratings/warnings, mostly due to the Chilean system restricting warnings to food containing added (rather than naturally occurring) ingredients and the HSR awarding points for healthy components.

“A lot of public health experts here view the Chilean system as better than the HSR because it is mandatory, and because it provides unambiguous warnings on all foods that are high in nutrients that we know are harming people, usually due to over-consumption,” says Professor Ni Mhurchu, from the School of Population Health in the University of Auckland’s Faculty of Medical and Health Sciences.

“Often, these nutrients are ‘hidden’ in processed food – for example, when sodium is used as a preservative in food – and people don’t realise what they’re eating; or they’ve gotten used to highly salty or sweet flavours over years of eating ultra-processed food.”

She says if warning labels were introduced in New Zealand, they could co-exist with the Health Star Ratings, potentially off-setting each other’s limitations.

“The main thing is, whichever labelling system we use, it’s clear that it should be mandatory to work effectively. Currently, less than one quarter of New Zealand products display a HSR, and the rating is applied selectively on healthier products by most manufacturers.”

A separate, in-depth snapshot of packaged food published by Professor Ni Mhurchu with other University of Auckland researchers earlier this year revealed that nearly 70 percent of packaged food and drink in our supermarkets is ultra-processed, and nearly three-fifths (59 percent) qualify for a low star rating (less than 3½ stars).

“Most shoppers want to eat well for their own and their family’s health. A compulsory health warning, or health star rating, or both, on the front of every packaged item would allow them to make a quick, informed choice,” says Professor Ni Mhurchu.

A five-year review of the HSR system published earlier this year concluded it should continue with some changes to better reflect dietary guidelines, including automatically giving fruit and vegetables five stars, penalising total sugars more strongly and rating unsweetened flavoured waters closer to water to distinguish from juice and sugar-sweetened drinks.

The Australian and New Zealand Ministerial Forum on Food Regulation is expected to respond to the recommendations by the end of the year.

The study’s other authors were Senior Lecturer Dr Helen Eyles and Masters student Fredrik Söderlund. It was published in the Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health this week.

Professor Ni Mhurchu is a member of the New Zealand Health Star Rating Advisory Group which provides advice to the Government on implementation of the HSR system. The Advisory Group was not involved in this latest study.

© Scoop Media

Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines


Howard Davis: Dryzabone - Robert Conolly's The Dry

After the terrible devastation caused by last year’s bushfires, which prompted hundreds of Australians to shelter in the ocean to escape incineration and destroyed uncountable amounts of wildlife, The Dry has been released during a totally different kind of dry spell. More>>

Howard Davis: Benjamin Ree's The Painter and The Thief

The Norwegian filmmaker had long been fascinated by art thieves who commit high-stakes crimes with a delicate touch when a chance Google search in 2015 uncovered a botched heist in Oslo. More>>

Howard Davis: Anna Coddington Beams

Anna Coddington's thin, wispy vocals fit her songs beautifully, providing a wonderful lilting quality that pervades her latest album, producing instant ear worms. More>>

Howard Davis: Hit the Road, Jack - Chloé Zhao's Nomadland

Nomadland is perhaps the ultimately 'road' movie as it follows a group of dispossessed and disenfranchised vagabonds who find a form of communal refuge in camp sites and trailer parks after the economic contraction of 2008. More>>

Howard Davis: Byrneing Down the House - Spike Lee's American Utopia

Lee does an admirable job capturing Byrne's stunning live performance of his latest album, but the real star of the show is the staging. More>>

Howard Davis: The Phoenix Foundation Friend Ship Tour Docks in Wellington

A sense of local pride was certainly running high at the Opera House on Saturday night, as the lads ran through a tasty little set drawn mostly from their latest album Friend Ship (splash out for Xmas on the shocking pink extra-thick vinyl edition). More>>

Howard Davis: Avantdale Bowling Club

Auckland rapper and MC Tom Scott brought his stunning jazz-infused Taite Music Prize-winning project Avantdale Bowling Club to the Opera House headlining Wellington's 2020 Jazz Festival. More>>

Howard Davis: Troy Kingi Rules The San Fran

The award-winning Northland musician performed songs from his new record The Ghost of Freddie Cesar, the fourth installment in his 10/10/10 series - ten albums in ten years in ten genres. More>>



  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland