Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
License needed for work use Register

News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search


Nurse Breaches Woman’s Rights By Performing Excision That Was Not Consented To

The Deputy Health and Disability Commissioner has recommended a nurse complete HDC’s online training module on informed consent. She has also recommended the nurse apologise to a woman for breaching her rights to be fully informed, and to be provided services of an appropriate standard.

Dr Vanessa Caldwell found the nurse breached Rights 6, 7 and 4 of the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers’ Rights.

The decision centres around care the nurse provided to the woman when she requested a mole on her back be removed for biopsy. The woman said she had consented to a punch biopsy and not the wider excision the nurse actually performed. Furthermore, the nurse failed to remove the exact area that was of concern and removed tissue unable to be tested as required.

"I wish to reiterate that at no point did I ask for anything other than a punch biopsy…I was therefore very taken aback when the nurse showed me the very large piece of tissue removed and that the wound needed five sutures. I questioned this at the time and she simply said that was required," the woman said.

Dr Caldwell found the nurse did not inform the woman she was going to perform a wide excision, nor did she discuss the risks associated with this procedure adequately.

She said, "Before giving consent to health services, consumers are entitled to be given information that a reasonable consumer, in their circumstances, would expect to receive, and need to receive, to give informed consent. This includes information about the risks and benefits of the treatment and other options available to them. "

Advertisement - scroll to continue reading

Are you getting our free newsletter?

Subscribe to Scoop’s 'The Catch Up' our free weekly newsletter sent to your inbox every Monday with stories from across our network.

She further commented on the nurse’s standard of care noting several concerns. These included the nurse not documenting her discussions with the woman, the fact the nurse failed to more precisely remove the area of concern and not photographing the lesion. This was a breach of the medical centre’s policy.

Dr Caldwell also made adverse comment about the nurse in respect to the poor aftercare provided. The nurse has advised HDC she will now always use a written consent process for such procedures, ask the patient to mark the spot of concern, and take photos to record the precise area of concern. She will also undertake further formal education for such procedures.

The medical centre has provided HDC with a list of changes it has made since the events which included an improved minor surgery and punch biopsy patient information sheet, and updated consent forms that record the patient has read the information.

Health and disability service users can now access an online animation to help them understand their health and disability service rights under the Code.


Editors notes

Please only use the photo provided with this media release. For any questions about the photo, please contact the communications team.

The full report of this case can be viewed on HDC’s website - see HDC's ' Latest Decisions'.

Names have been removed from the report to protect privacy of the individuals involved in this case.

The Commissioner will usually name providers and public hospitals found in breach of the Code unless it would not be in the public interest or would unfairly compromise the privacy interests of an individual provider or a consumer. More information for the media, including HDC’s naming policy and why we don't comment on complaints, can be found on our website here.

HDC promotes and protects the rights of people using health and disability services as set out in the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights (the Code).

In 2022/23 HDC made 592 quality improvement recommendations to individual complaints and we have a high compliance rate of around 96%.

Learn more: Education Publications

© Scoop Media

Advertisement - scroll to continue reading
Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines

International Art Centre: Rare Goldie Landscape Expected To Fetch $150,000

When Evening Shadows Fall is one of four works by Goldie included in a sale of Important and Rare Art at the International Art Centre in Parnell on November 28. Goldie painted only a handful of landscapes, concentrating mainly on indigenous portraits, which earned him a global reputation as NZ’s finest painter of respected Māori elders (kaumātua). More

Mark Stocker: History Spurned - The Arrival Of Abel Tasman In New Zealand

On the face of it, Everhardus Koster's exceptional genre painting The Arrival of Abel Tasman in New Zealand should have immense appeal. It cannot find a buyer, however, not because of any aesthetic defects, but because of its subject matter and the fate of the Māori it depicts. More



  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland

Join Our Free Newsletter

Subscribe to Scoop’s 'The Catch Up' our free weekly newsletter sent to your inbox every Monday with stories from across our network.