Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


Of Mice and Men

Of Mice and Men

Point of View: with Barbara Sumner Burstyn

Sometimes a scientific breakthrough is so remarkable it stops you in your tracks. The announcement recently that Dr Ina Dobrinski, a researcher at The University of Pennsylvania has created mice with fleshy lumps on their backs is one of those. While the lumps look innocuous they’re actually transplanted goat and pig sperm factories, able to pump out as much pig and goat sperm a day as your average goat or pig. Dr Dobrinski, who is planning human-mouse grafts, is proud of her achievements and maintains the research will benefit infertile men, especially those about to undergo chemo or other invasive techniques. Instead of losing the change to procreate the doctor predicts they’ll soon be storing their sperm on the backs of their pet mice.

Relocated into a New Zealand context such genetic research is not unusual. We have over 40 research groups, some attached to universities, either state-owned or private companies doing all manner of experiments on animals, including cloning and genetic modifications. What is strange is Dr Dobrinski’ s openness about her research. In New Zealand such openness is almost unheard of.

Last week the state-owned AgResearch successfully appealed to the Office of the Ombudsmen to stop the release of information on people belonging to its animal ethics committee. In support of the information suppression, Auckland University animal ethics chairman Dr Don Love reassured the public that no scientist in this country wanted to cause suffering in animals. The approval process, he says, particularly where the animal would suffer severely, was extremely rigorous. "You really have to go through the mill to get the box ticked to go ahead with those ones. You always have to justify what you are doing. It's not as if it's open slather."


Peter Wills is not so sure. An associate professor at Auckland University's physics department, he said in a NZ Herald interview as saying a recent AgResearch application lacked important details, such as the effects of the research on the cows used. Boycotting the proceedings of the Environmental Risk Management Authority (Erma) the body that oversees applications, he said they had a record of "rubber-stamping" research applications and ignoring opposing views to applications. Combine Will’s concerns with the recent report that AgResearch effectively sidestepped scrutiny by a new ethics council for it’s controversial work involving inserting a range of goat and human genes into cows and you begin to wonder if AgResearch is the last organization we should trust to behave ethically. Especially to animals.

A well-operated ethics committee has two essential functions. The first is to work consistently to avoid unnecessary experiments and encourage the search for alternatives. The second is to be transparent and accountable, both to the expectations of the public and to the researchers. According to animal rights activists in New Zealand our research community is already one of the most secretive in the world. The Chief Ombudsman’s decision will only exacerbate that and result in accountability limited only to those with a vested interest in the outcome. It will mean all procedures and decisions will be controlled within the research community itself. And even if the committees do have highly developed accountability mechanisms they will now be incapable of hearing the public voice. While communities will be unable to promote awareness about animal research issues. Of course AgResearch had compelling reasons to seek and gain their suppression order. Citing an attack on a scientist last year that involved acid poured on a car and threatening phone calls they say they are simply protecting their scientists and the people who serve on their ethics committees. The one thing AgResearch has not realized is that people take extreme measures in extreme situations. The knowledge that acts of cruelty are being carried out on more than 300,000 animals each year in New Zealand in a closed environment may be enough to make any mildly angry activists a little agitated. Secrecy drives not only the crown owned AgResearch and all the private institutions underground but also the animal activists.

It’s not good enough for ethics committees to tell us they’re being ethical and abiding by the rules. They must be seen to be ethical as well and committee members should be willing to stand behind their decisions. As Green Party MP Sue Kedgley said last week, “Why is there this great veil of secrecy if there is nothing to hide?"

This suppression order is not about protecting scientists, only one of whom in New Zealand has ever reported an attack. It’s a selfish desire to behave unhindered, to position the science above all else, as if science were a morality unto itself. By agreeing to the suppression order The Ombudsman has effectively created an environment where the acts of cruelty can flourish and the public imagination can run wild. If they’re openly growing human life on the bodies of mice in America, how much more are they doing in secrecy here?

Want to have your say? Email Barb with your feedback…

© Scoop Media

Top Scoops Headlines


Richard S. Ehrlich: U.S. Sees "Threat" In The Golden Triangle

In Southeast Asia's crime-infested Golden
Triangle, Chinese entrepreneur Zhao Wei is constructing a sprawling
casino resort and airstrip despite being sanctioned by the U.S.
Treasury Department as a "threat to the United States" because of his
"horrendous illicit activities"... More>>

Peter Dunne: The Steadily Eroding Sands Of Credibility

The ever-shifting sands of the Covid19 vaccination programme are increasingly eroding the credibility of this government.
In January the Prime Minister proclaimed that 2021 would be the “Year of the vaccine” – much the same way as she had promised 2019 would be the “Year of Delivery... More>>

The Conversation: Aggressive Marketing Has Driven The Rise Of The Double-cab Ute On New Zealand Streets — Time To Hit The Brakes?

Explore your inner beast.” That was the slogan used last year to sell the Ford Ranger. At 2.4 tonnes, that’s a lot of “light” truck, but the stakes are rising. This year, the 3.5 tonne Ram 1500 “eats utes for breakfast”... More>>

Podcast: Buchanan + Manning On Cyber-Attacks And The Evolution Of Hybrid Warfare

Paul G. Buchanan and Selwyn Manning present this week’s podcast, A View from Afar with a deep-dive into cyber-attacks and hybrid warfare – Especially how 2021 has witnessed a Cold War II styled stand-off between global powers... More>>

Climate Explained: Is New Zealand Losing Or Gaining Native Forests?

Apart from wetlands, land above the treeline, coastal dunes and a few other exceptions, New Zealand was once covered in forests from Cape Reinga to Bluff. So was Europe, which basically consisted of a single forest from Sicily in southern Italy to the North Cape in Norway, before human intervention... More>>

Sydney Mockdown: The Delta Variant Strikes

It is proving to be an unfolding nightmare. For a government that had been beaming with pride at their COVID contract tracing for months, insisting that people could live, consume and move about with freedom as health professionals wrapped themselves round the virus, the tune has changed... More>>