Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search

 

Cunliffe Must Explain Flip-Flop Over Asylum Seeker

State Of It: Cunliffe Must Explain Why He Abandoned Support For Asylum-Seeker's Plight

Editorial by Selwyn Manning

Prior to David Cunliffe being promoted to his Minister of Immigration position, he met as an MP with asylum-seeker, Thomas Yadegary. The Labour MP interviewed Mr Yadegary, supported his plight to seek refuge from Iran in New Zealand, and wrote to him on a Parliamentary Service letterhead indicating his ongoing support for his refugee status application. (Graphic by Scoop's Lyndon Hood.)

However, that support was withdrawn once David Cunliffe accepted his Immigration ministerial warrant. Why? Surely the Minister must answer this question.

Another notable Labour minister, Phil Goff, had in 2004 also written to the then Associate Immigration Minister, Damien O'Connor, seeking reconsideration of Thomas Yadegary's case.

But those appeals on behalf of a man, who's religious conviction places him in danger of being persecuted in Iran by the current fundamentalist regime, had been relegated to history once David Cunliffe took over as Minister of Immigration.

In recent months, the credibility and standing of those engaged in Parliament has taken a severe pounding. This metamorphosis of David Cunliffe's character, that once considered Mr Yadegary's plea for refuge worthy and vital, to that of apparent indifference, is unbecoming of David Cunliffe – an MP and minister who many consider to be a rising talent within the Labour-led Cabinet.

If this incarceration matter is not satisfactorily concluded by balancing human rights principles with legal process, then not only Parliament's credibility will suffer but also that of the Executive, the Minister's sincerity will be questioned, and Mr Yadegary's right to a life of liberty free of unjust persecution will, on balance, be stolen from him.

It must be remembered that Ministers are not merely representatives of their respective departments and ministries, but primarily representatives of the public interest, the national interest and that of the New Zealand way - in this case, that national-condition, and the buck, stops with David Cunliffe.

Scoop Audio.Scoop Audio (UPDATE): National Party's Lockwood Smith asked the Minister of Immigration questions in Parliament today regarding the refugee applicant Thomas Yadegary who is held in Mt Eden Prison until he signs his own deportation passport papers. Answering is Associate Minister Clayton Cosgrove on behalf of David Cunliffe.

*******

To follow are sections of a letter (and links to pdf's of the letter) dated November 11 2004 where David Cunliffe spells out exactly why Thomas Yadegary ought to be considered a refugee.

Letter From David Cunliffe To Then Associate Immigration minister, Damien O'Connor, dated November 11 2004.

*******

Dear Damien

… "I am aware that Mr Yadegary has recently been detained in custody and that a letter from Mr Yadegary's local MP, Hon Phil Goff, requesting reconsideration has been received by your office.

"I write on the basis of support for that letter and respectfully request your urgent consideration on three grounds:

  • The presence of conflicting decisions in findings of the Refugee Status Appeals despite strong similarity between appellant cases.
  • The belief Mr Yadegary holds that he will be subject to persecution
  • The potential impact on community relations should the case become salient
  • The general character of Mr Yadegary as perceived by the community."
  • [snip]

    "The Authority (Refugee Status Authority) accepts that Mr Yadegary is a committed Christian who will 'spread the light' amongst family and friends and yet suggests that he is not at serious risk of harm.

    "Recent evidence indicates those who actively display their new faith in public, especially by proselytising, can expect to face severe repression in Iran.

    "Thus, Mr Yadegary has a plausible case however the RAA finding of his appeal is at odds with the following Refugee Status Appeals Authority precedents. (ref. RSAA Appeal 72323/00)."

    [snip]

    "New Zealand enjoys considerable religious and political freedom. The diverse ethnic and religious communities generally share positive and harmonious relations. There is a strong public interest in maintaining the situation. There is a risk that deporting Mr Yadegary to Iran to face significant risk of persecution could excite division between Christian and Moslem communities within New Zealand.

    "Based on interviews with Mr Yadegary and several of his neighbours, Mr Yadegary presents as well known and liked in the local community and appears to be of good character. He is working in a small successful business in my electorate."

    pdf copies of David Cunliffe's letter:

  • David Cunliffe letter, page: 1
  • David Cunliffe letter, page: 2
  • David Cunliffe letter, page: 3
  • David Cunliffe letter, page: 4
  • ALSO:

  • GPJA - Cunliffe Accepted – Now Rejects – Thomas Yadegary
  • GPJA - Labour’s Own Guantánamo Bay – Here in Mt Eden
  • Scoop Audio.Scoop Audio: The Prime Minister Helen Clark was questioned on the Thomas Yadegary case at the post-Cabinet press conference on Monday afternoon.

    ENDS

    © Scoop Media

     
     
     
    Top Scoops Headlines

     

    Gordon Campbell: On The Media Collusion With National’s Attack Lines

    For most of the past week, any consumer of this country’s management of Covid-19 would think New Zealand was actually Brazil, or Texas. The media language has been full of claims of “botches” at the border, and laxness and inexcusable errors ... More>>

    Gregor Thompson: Don’t Be Too Pessimistic About New Zealand’s Future.

    With the first hurdle hopped our Government will be turning its attention to trying to soften the economic damage this pandemic has on our little archipelago. More>>

    Eric Zuesse: U.S. Empire: Biden And Kerry Gave Orders To Ukraine’s President

    Eric Zuesse, originally posted at Strategic Culture On May 19th, an implicit international political warning was issued, but it wasn’t issued between countries; it was issued between allied versus opposed factions within each of two countries: U.S. and Ukraine. ... More>>

    Binoy Kampmark: Budget Cockups In The Time Of Coronavirus: Reporting Errors And Australia’s JobKeeper Scheme

    Hell has, in its raging fires, ringside seats for those who like their spreadsheets. The seating, already peopled by those from human resources, white collar criminals and accountants, becomes toastier for those who make errors with those spreadsheets. ... More>>

    Binoy Kampmark: Altars Of Hypocrisy: George Floyd, Protest And Black Face

    Be wary what you protest about. The modern moral constabulary are out, and they are assisted by their Silicon Valley friends in the Social Media club. Should you dare take a stand on anything, especially in a dramatic way, you will be found out ... More>>

    Binoy Kampmark: Welcome Deaths: Coronavirus And The Open Plan Office

    For anybody familiar with that gruesome manifestation of the modern work place, namely the open plan office, the advent of coronavirus might be something of a relief. The prospects for infection in such spaces is simply too great. You are at risk from ... More>>


    Binoy Kampmark: Why Thinking Makes It So: Donald Trump’s Obamagate Fixation

    The “gate” suffix has been wearing thin since the break-in scandal that gave it its birth. Since Watergate, virtually anything dubious and suggestive, and much more besides, is suffixed. Which brings us to the issue of President Donald Trump’s ... More>>



    Binoy Kampmark: Brutal Choices: Anders Tegnell And Sweden’s Herd Immunity Goal

    If the title of epidemiological czar were to be created, its first occupant would have to be Sweden’s Anders Tegnell. He has held sway in the face of sceptics and concern that his “herd immunity” approach to COVID-19 is a dangerous, and breathtakingly ... More>>