Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search

 

GC: The government’s belated moves on property speculation

Gordon Campbell on the government’s belated moves on property speculation

Is it a property tax on capital gains or a capital gains tax on property? The Jesuitical distinctions in the government’s spin about its latest moves on property speculators are all about whether the government can claim that it jumped, or confess that it was pushed, into a response. Calling it a property tax means that it was an extension of existing provisions – while calling it a capital gains would be to ’fess up to sleeping with the enemy.

Definitional issues aside – and since this new tax walks and talks like a capital gains tax, lets call it that – there is no doubt that the government has had to be dragged reluctantly to this position. Clearly, a politician can live in denial for only so long. For months, Finance Minister Bill English had been peddling the line that governments can’t really do much to dampen down the demand side of speculation in housing. Australia, English liked to point out, had (a) a stiffer capital gains tax and (b) strict rules against foreign speculators buying existing houses …but regardless, English claimed, they still have a housing price bubble in Sydney ! .

It was never a convincing argument. (Hey, we still have fires too, but no one thinks it would be good idea to live without the Fire Service.) Reserve Bank governor Graeme Wheeler for one, didn’t buy it. Last week, the RB signalled that our Wild West stance towards housing speculation in Auckland is putting the New Zealand economy at serious risk, if and when the price bubble eventually bursts. Speculators account for some 41% of Auckland house sales. Come October, the RB decreed, such people will need to stump up with a 30% deposit before they can get a bank loan.

With refreshing honesty, Wheeler has since explained what a “modest” impact these moves would have, and he cited a recent ANZ survey that Auckland house prices are expected to rise by 75% over the next 5 years. That’s a price bubble, by any standard. Yet by Wheeler’s own reckoning, the RB’s new counter-measures would achieve only an 8% decline in house sales, and a 2-4% decline in house prices. Given that Auckland house prices have risen 9.5% in the past three months, a 2-4% reduction is better than nothing, but would hardly be a game-changer. What the RB was issuing was a none-too-subtle invitation to the government to step up, and do more.

Ion passing, its worth noting the main reason for the modest effect of the RB’s moves. The RB’s tougher lending requirements will constrain only those speculators who borrow from local banks. Foreigners who pay cash, or who access their mortgage money from Singapore and China (at only 2.5 % rates of interest) would be unaffected. As Lyndon Fairbairn, a New Zealand developer based in Singapore told RNZ, we’re a very attractive place for foreign investors in property to do their business.

We offer high yields on rental property - roughly four times above those currently available in Sydney, New York or Singapore, Fairbairn claimed, and our compliance costs are minimal. “We don’t have stamp duties, or [until now] a capital gains tax. It’s a very easy place to transact…”

With his back pushed to the wall, English has finally acted. Yesterday, the government announced that the Budget will unveil a new regime that’s likely to include such things as (a) a de facto registration system for foreign speculators which will among other things, make money laundering more difficult (b) a capital gains tax on property on-sold within two years, with a few exceptions for the likes of family – inherited property and (c) possibly, a withholding tax for foreign investors.

For now, foreigners will still be able to buy existing homes in New Zealand. In Australia by contrast, foreigners are barred from buying existing houses and thus, they can’t fuel the price inflation spiral in the ‘secondary’ housing market. Since they can buy only new houses, this means that foreign investors add to Australia’s housing stock, and they create jobs in the construction industry in the process. It seems like a no-brainer for New Zealand to do likewise, but so far, we’ve chosen not to follow suit.

Until yesterday in fact, Bill English had seemed to be fixated solely on the supply side of the housing equation. Freeing up land and building houses is a worthy long-term goal, but it can also look like you’re doing nothing in the meantime. In that respect, these new taxation-based attempts to dampen down demand should be seen as a belated response to an inertia that was no longer politically viable.

For The Love of Money

Quite a few songs deal with taxes and money….starting all the way back in the 1920s with Fiddlin’ John Carson’s anthem “Taxes On The Farmer Feeds Them All.” From Philadelphia in the early 1970s, here’s Eddie Levert and the O’Jays doing their classic “For The Love of Money” on what looks like the Soul Train television show. It’s a world of flares, loud checks, snappy dance moves…and a cautionary message besides. Given that both of Levert’s sons – the musicians Gerald and Sean Levert – have since died from drug-related overdoses and withdrawals, the lyrics probably carry a personal weight for him now that they may not have, back in the day.

For the love of money

People will lie, Lord, they will cheat

For the love of money

People don’t care who they hurt or beat….

For a small piece of paper

It carries a lot of weight

Call it lean, mean, mean green

Almighty dollar….

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Top Scoops Headlines

 


Ian Powell: Are we happy living in Handy's Age of Unreason?

On 19 June the Sunday Star Times published my column on the relationship between the Labour government’s stewardship of Aotearoa New Zealand’s health system and the outcome of the next general election expected to be around September-October 2023: Is the health system an electoral sword of Damocles for Labour... More>>


The First Attack On The Independents: Albanese Hobbles The Crossbench
It did not take long for the new Australian Labor government to flex its muscle foolishly in response to the large crossbench of independents and small party members of Parliament. Despite promising a new age of transparency and accountability after the election of May 21, one of the first notable acts of the Albanese government was to attack the very people who gave voice to that movement. Dangerously, old party rule, however slim, is again found boneheaded and wanting... More>>


Binoy Kampmark: Predictable Monstrosities: Priti Patel Approves Assange’s Extradition
The only shock about the UK Home Secretary’s decision regarding Julian Assange was that it did not come sooner. In April, Chief Magistrate Senior District Judge Paul Goldspring expressed the view that he was “duty-bound” to send the case to Priti Patel to decide on whether to extradite the WikiLeaks founder to the United States to face 18 charges, 17 grafted from the US Espionage Act of 1917... More>>


Dunne Speaks: Roe V. Wade Blindsides National

Momentum is everything in politics, but it is very fragile. There are times when unexpected actions can produce big shifts and changes in the political landscape. In 2017, for example, the Labour Party appeared headed for another hefty defeat in that year’s election until the abrupt decision of its then leader to step aside just weeks before the election. That decision changed the political landscape and set in train the events which led to Labour being anointed by New Zealand First to form a coalition government just a few weeks later... More>>

Digitl: Infrastructure Commission wants digital strategy
Earlier this month Te Waihanga, New Zealand’s infrastructure commission, tabled its first Infrastructure Strategy: Rautaki Hanganga o Aotearoa. Te Waihanga describes its document as a road map for a thriving New Zealand... More>>


Binoy Kampmark: Leaking For Roe V Wade
The US Supreme Court Chief Justice was furious. For the first time in history, the raw judicial process of one of the most powerful, and opaque arms of government, had been exposed via media – at least in preliminary form. It resembled, in no negligible way, the publication by WikiLeaks of various drafts of the Trans-Pacific Partnership... More>>