Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
Beehive caught off guard by change of government
Jane Patterson, Political Editor
Public servants responsible for the transition between governments failed to support new ministers as no-one had planned for a full scale, new administration.
Image: Scoop
Officials were caught on the hop after last year's general election, having planned for change no greater than a Cabinet reshuffle - that caused problems like being unable to supply laptops and mobile phones and a lack of experienced staff for incoming ministers.
State Services Minister Chris Hipkins ordered the review after frustration about the level of staffing and administration support ministers received from Ministerial and Secretarial Support Services (MaSS) upon taking office.
The KPMG report, obtained by RNZ under the Official Information Act, found there was a shortage of skilled ministerial staff and IT support, which "affected some ministers' ability to get their offices up and running in a timely way".
There were "significant issues" with providing basic equipment like laptops and mobile phones, which the report said had a "significant impact on the ability of the ministerial offices to operate efficiently".
It said the funding for any change was based on a "medium-sized Cabinet reshuffle" and that "set the tone for the level of planning required".
The report listed a number of factors including a "lack of strategic governance" within the Department of Internal Affairs and other key agencies, and no "apolitical process" for engaging with political parties ahead of elections to discuss what they might need if they ended up in power.
It also acknowledged the work and commitment of MaSS staff and noted they appeared to be "under-resourced to deal with the volume of work" that came with the new government.
As a result of a 2016 restructure which led to the loss of some "key" staff, "most MaSS staff had not experienced a full change of executive before", the report said.
It found outgoing staff had a "relatively smooth transition" but those coming in felt "let down" by MaSS.
"Staff felt pressured to signing contracts without having sufficient time to seek independent advice and to negotiate contract terms" and that "staff displayed a high level of frustration and distrust with MaSS and DIA as their employer".
Recommendations included a governance group to plan between elections, detailed 'scenario planning' covering the full range of options, making sure there is continuity of skilled staff, and a transition period for the set-up of ministerial offices.
RNZ
New Zealand's public broadcaster, providing comprehensive NZ news and current affairs, specialist audio features and documentaries.
Radio New Zealand is a Crown entity established under the Radio New Zealand Act 1995. Radio New Zealand News are vital elements in our programming, providing impartial news and information to New Zealanders every day. Radio New Zealand (RNZ) provides listeners with exciting and independent radio programmes in accordance with the Radio New Zealand Charter.
Binoy Kampmark: Commemorating Mummy - Reflections On Mother’s Day
Gordon Campbell: On The New Pope, And The Israeli Attack On Peter Davis
Martin LeFevre - Meditations: For The Love Of Sycamores
Ian Powell: A Timely Call For A Social Contract In Health
Binoy Kampmark: Bratty Royal - Prince Harry And Bespoke Security Protection
Keith Rankin: Make Deficits Great Again - Maintaining A Pragmatic Balance