Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
Mayoral candidate John Tamihere defends 'sieg heil' comment
Auckland mayoral candidate John Tamihere is defending
his use of the words "sieg heil" during last night's lively
political debate with Phil Goff, despite being lambasted for
it on social media.
Photo: RNZ / Matthew Hutching.
A short clip of the debate circulating on Twitter has already been seen by thousands of people, showing Mr Tamihere's response to Auckland mayor Phil Goff speaking on diversity at a pub politics debate in Ponsonby last night.
Mr Goff said he would like his grandchildren to grow up in a diverse city "and we won't put up with the sort of nonsense that we get from racists coming into this country to tell us that multiculturalism doesn't work".
"In six weeks time I've got a grandson that will be born that's a quarter Māori, a quarter Filipino, and a quarter Irish and a quarter English, and I'll be really proud of that kid. That kid will represent the future of our city," Mr Goff said.
The video shows Mr Tamihere started off his response: "Well, I say sieg heil to that".
I suspect even Tamihere's stoutest defenders are tiring of this idiocy. https://t.co/vedeB7JuiS
— Russell Brown (@publicaddress) September 17, 2019
People have expressed concern at the use of the phrase associated with Nazis and former Prime Minister Helen Clark has waded into the ring calling the use of the Nazi slogan "appalling" on Twitter.
But Mr Tamihere has defended his use of the phrase in the context of the debate.
"Mr Goff was very strong on ensuring anyone that doesn't agree with him that he takes objection to, that he can suppress them coming into Auckland or using Auckland community facilities to host events, I'm talking about the two Canadians," Mr Tamihere said.
Controversial Canadian speakers Lauren Southern and Stephan Molyneux were banned from speaking at an Auckland Council venue earlier this year.
"My own view on it is that that is incorrect, that whilst I might vehemently oppose them the best disinfectant is daylight and to suppress them is to then determine that you're a dictator on what people can think or say."
Asked by RNZ if he was likening Mr Goff to Hitler, Mr Tamihere said:
"The analogy is about a dictator, what dictator would you choose?
"Because Hitler was a terrible person who was a dictator and wanted to determine who could speak, when they could speak and what they could say. Very simple analogy in a debate. When you're in the heat of a debate that's what happens."
He said the debate was fierce and called the video circulating on social media a "cut and paste".
"I don't need to think like you, I don't need to act like you and that's the whole issue of this whole mayoralty," Mr Tamihere said.
"I'm allowed in a democracy to have a say without people criticising me solely because of the way in which I run my debate. End of story I would have thought."
Auckland mayor Phill Goff said he was "astonished" Mr Tamihere was defending his choice of words
"I don't know where it came from and I really didn't believe that he has just said that. You don't expect that from a contender for the Auckland mayoralty, one of the diverse cities in the world, and almost six months to the day after the Christchurch terrorist attack," Mr Goff said.
Mr Goff said it will remind people that Mr Tamihere has said many insulting things over time.
"It's kind of sad that we should even be having this discussion that he had made that comment. I can't think of any debate that I've had over 14 elections that I've fought in that degrades to that sort of comment. It's not right."
Mr Goff said he was not expecting an apology from Mr Tamihere, even though it would be nice.
RNZ
New Zealand's public broadcaster, providing comprehensive NZ news and current affairs, specialist audio features and documentaries.
Radio New Zealand is a Crown entity established under the Radio New Zealand Act 1995. Radio New Zealand News are vital elements in our programming, providing impartial news and information to New Zealanders every day. Radio New Zealand (RNZ) provides listeners with exciting and independent radio programmes in accordance with the Radio New Zealand Charter.
Gordon Campbell: On The Coalition’s Awful, Not Good, Very Bad Poll Results
Ian Powell: Policy Vacuum Enables For-profit Corporate General Practice Ownership By Stealth
Gordon Campbell: On Iran Killing Its Rappers, And Searching For The Invisible Dr. Reti
Peter Dunne: MPs Unusually Quiet On Pay Rise
Ian Powell: Cuba And New Zealand: A Relationship Worthy Of Strengthening
Gordon Campbell: On bird flu, AUKUS entry fees and Cindy Lee