Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


Controversial Civic Centre Upsize Goes Ahead

New upsized $48 million Whangarei civic centre to be build on former RSA's bowling green in picture - part of a new civic precinct.
(Photo Northern Advocate NB single use only)

Whangarei ratepayers are to get an upsized $48 million new civic centre – without public consultation on its increased cost.

Whangarei District Council (WDC) councillors today (SUBS: Thursday 27 February) voted to go ahead with a bigger building - without any public consultation on the increase.

They chose to go with a 7000 square metre civic centre - in so doing committing ratepayers to spend $10 million more than initially budgeted for a smaller $38 million 5500 square metre civic centre settled on just 20 months ago.

“The decision (we’ve made today) is one we have made to ensure a facility that’s future-proofed for the next 50 years,” WDC Mayor Sheryl Mai said after the meeting decision.

Just over 70 per cent of WDC’s 14 councillors voted in favour of the supersizing. Councillors voted 10 to three - with one abstention - in favour of the upsized civic centre.

Mayor Sheryl Mai and councillors Greg Innes (deputy mayor), Gavin Benney, Ken Couper, Tricia Cutforth, Nick Connop, Shelley Deeming, Anna Murphy, Carol Peters and Greg Martin voted to go ahead with the building upsize.

Councillors Vince Cocurullo (SUBS: correct), Jane Golightly and Phil Halse voted against the upsize. Councillor Simon Reid abstained.

The councillors debated the issue for 57 minutes in an intense, vociferous and sometimes heated example of local democracy in action that at one stage saw a councillor’s voice crack with emotion. All spoke up except for Golightly who voted against the upsize. She later said she had not voted in favour of the bigger centre because her ratepayers would not expect her to make a decision to proceed without having enough information at hand. She couldn’t do so without being able to see a design for the building.

Mai said, as was common local government practice, the size of the civic centre budget had to be established before design and work contract negotiations could follow.

She said public consultation was not required for deciding on the extra $10 million budget spend for an upsized civic centre.

Mai kicked off debate by telling the meeting, proposed changes to boost the civic centre scope would lead to increased costs, but they fell below the threshold for being an issue of enough significance under council’s significance and engagement policy to trigger the need for further public consultation before a decision was made. An issue needed to trigger two or more of the significance assessment criteria to be deemed significant and therefore needing to go out to public consultation.

The five significance and engagement criteria are: impact on council’s direction, change in council’s current level of service, level of public impact and/or interest, impact on council’s capability (non-cost) and net financial cost/revenue of implementation, excluding any financial impact already included in a Long Term Plan or Annual Plan.

Lack of a building design drawing emerged as perhaps the major point of contention – among opponents and proponents alike - during councillors’ decision making debate.

Alan Adcock, WDC general manager corporate said in the wake of today’s decision, a design could now be put together. This would be available by June.

He said it had not been possible to develop a civic centre design for the project to date as key recent developments enabling critical aspects of final decision making on building size had not been fully dealt with until as recently as last year.

Incoming October 2019-elected Northland Regional Council councillors had only just, towards the end of last year, decided not to proceed with going in together with WDC on a building combining both organisations’ staff. Discussion on where the across-councils/New Zealand Transport Agency coalition (NZTA) Northland Transportation Alliance was to be housed had also only recently been finalised.

Adcock said as a result of this, the now-selected Rust Avenue site hadn’t been finalised until the end of the year. Building size, foundation and footprint were all aspects influenced by the result of these factors.

Mai moved the civic centre scope and budget review agenda item. It was seconded by councillor Shelley Deeming, one of two councillors whose on the council civic centre working party.

“The public expects council to be forward planning - 30 to 50 to100 years into the future,” Deeming said.

It was a red herring to say the civic centre size increase would mean loading big extra costs now on current ratepayers.

A project such as the centre was funded intergenerationally over a long term through borrowing she said.

Deeming said deciding on civic centre size today (SUBS: Thursday 27 February) was critical to then be able to go on to necessary design work.

The civic centre was not just for council staff to have a much-improved work environment, Deeming said.

It was for the public to more easily interact with staff - within the building and its surrounds.

“It’s not just a building, it will be a precinct,” she said.

“We are all reluctant to increase funding, but we need to make the decision quite clear – we either design a building that’s going to house our staff into the foreseeable future or something we’ll need to go back to and extend within a few years,” Deeming said.

Innes said the new upsized building provided a fit-for-purpose facility that also included contingency for growth.

The civic centre was not just a WDC building. It included NTA. Innes said he needed to be sure the alliance provided results-on-the-ground value for ratepayers.

Couper said the new upsized civic centre would hopefully create a better working environment and reduce WDC’s 17% staff churn, which although not as high as some other councils, was a big cost.

Reid abstained from voting. He said he could not make a decision without seeing a building design first to know what he was signing up to.

Cocurullo slammed the new bigger building, challenging meeting procedural points of order and standing up to deliver a heated view. He called for staff to get a design plan and come back to council.

Cutforth meanwhile delivered an opposite position. She is one of the two councillors on the council civic centre working group.

“We have to be brave and recognise we are building a building for a hugely growing district,” Cutforth said.

“We have staff in rented facilities costing a million dollars a year. There are overflow staff here and there.

“When I first came into the building (Forum North) I was surprised to see the conditions people are working in. People are squashed into rooms and occasionally a bit of paint is put on the walls to make them feel better,” she said.

A six-star green-rated, really good quality build was needed now.

“We must build for a district-wide purpose,” Cutforth said.

Connop said it was time to be positive. The building needed to be as sustainable as possible. It would cost a fair amount of money but Whangarei needed to have the best possible building it could have for the money spent.

Councillor Anna Murphy spoke strongly in favour of the building upsize.

“I support increasing the budget to see us going forward,” Murphy said.

She said it was great to see the work that had already gone in to date towards shaping pending building design.

But Councillor Phil Halse said he was voting against the proposal.

“There is no plan, no specs and no hope,” Halse said.

Whangarei’s Hundertwasser build was a case in point where a $13.4 million project had now blown out to $30 million.

“And we still don’t know the final cost for that,” he said.

Councillor Gavin Benney (SUBS: correct) grilled Adcock asking what guarantee there was the $10-million extra spend and upsized $48 million civic centre option would not further blow out in price.

Adcock said an open-book approach with very robust checking, cross checking and ongoing monitoring of margins, quotes and costs involved in the civic centre was already part of the project.

Auckland-based The Building Intelligence Group was contracted to project manage the civic centre build. Auckland-based Canam Construction has been chosen as lead contractor for the building.

Auckland based architect Kerry Avery, from Avery Team Architects, is detailed to design the building, pending the council decision.

Costs of about $6000 to $6500 per square metre for the building were high Benney said.

Adcock said his research of similar builds around New Zealand showed a cost range of $4000 to $9000 per square.

The new civic centre building $6000 to $6500 per metre cost included $1900 a square metre for fit out – and foundations up to 25 metres deep.

Murphy said there was no point proceeding with the smaller $38 million building which would not be a cheaper option in the long term when more space was required to meet staffing to deal with district growth.

“We don’t want a tack on,” Murphy said.

Martin said he voted in favour of the increased building option but wanted to be reassured around potential for cost overrun.

Meanwhile Peters also spoke in favour of the upsized centre.

© Scoop Media

Top Scoops Headlines


Gordon Campbell: On The Use Of Existing Drugs To Reduce The Effects Of Coronavirus

So now, we’re all getting up to speed with the travel bans, the rigorous handwashing and drying, the social distancing, and the avoidance of public transport wherever possible. Right. At a wider level…so far, the public health system has ... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Oil Market And Regulation Crusades

Safe to say, Vladimir Putin did not expect the response he has received amidships from the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia. Earlier, Russia chose to walk away from the OPEC talks in Vienna that were aimed at reaching an agreement on how to reduce world oil production (and protect oil prices) in the light of the fall in demand being caused by the coronavirus. No doubt, Russia and its allies in the US shale industry probably glimpsed an opportunity to undercut OPEC and seize some of its customers. Bad move. In reply, Saudi Arabia has smashed the oil market by hugely ramping up production, signing up customers and drastically cutting the oil price in a fashion designed to knock Russia and other oil suppliers right out of contention. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On 22 Short Takes About Super Tuesday

With obvious apologies to the Simpsons….Here’s my 22 short takes on the 14 Super Tuesday primaries that combined yesterday to produce a common narrative –Bernie Sanders NOT running away with the nomination, Joe Biden coming back from the dead, and the really, really rich guy proving to be really, really bad at politics. In the months ahead, it will be fascinating to see if the real Joe Biden can live up to the idea of Joe Biden that people voted for yesterday – namely, the wise old guy who can save the country from the political extremism of the right and the left... More>>

Gordon Campbell On Shane Jones: A Liability No-One Needs To Bear

New Zealand First has needed a diversion after weeks of bad coverage over its dodgy handling of donations, but it really, really doesn’t need what Shane Jones has chosen to provide. According to Jones, New Zealand has ... More>>

Binoy Kampmark: Strong Man Legacies: Burying Mubarak

Reviled strongmen of one era are often the celebrated ones of others. Citizens otherwise tormented find that replacements are poor, in some cases even crueller, than the original artefact. Such strongmen also serve as ideal alibis for rehabilitation ... More>>

Caitlin Johnstone: Humanity Is Making A Very Important Choice When It Comes To Assange

The propagandists have all gone dead silent on the WikiLeaks founder they previously were smearing with relentless viciousness, because they no longer have an argument. The facts are all in, and yes, it turns out the US government is certainly and undeniably working to exploit legal loopholes to imprison a journalist for exposing its war crimes. That is happening, and there is no justifying it... More>>

Gail Duncan: Reframing Welfare Report

Michael Joseph Savage, the architect of the 1938 Social Security Act, wouldn’t recognise today’s Social Security Act as having anything to do with the kind, cooperative, caring society he envisioned 80 years ago. Instead society in 2020 has been reduced ... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Addiction To Chinese Student Fees

Last week, Australian PM Scott Morrison extended its ban on foreign visitors from or passing through from mainland China – including Chinese students - for a third week. New Zealand has dutifully followed suit, with our travel ban ... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Coronavirus, And The Iowa Debacle

As Bloomberg says, the coronavirus shutdown is creating the world’s biggest work-from-home experiment. On the upside, the mortality rate with the current outbreak is lower than with SARS in 2003, but (for a number of reasons) the economic impact this time ... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Dodging A Bullet Over The Transport Cost Over-Runs

As New Zealand gears up to begin its $6.8 billion programme of large scale roading projects all around the country, we should be aware of this morning’s sobering headlines from New South Wales, where the cost overruns on major transport projects ... More>>


  • PublicAddress
  • Pundit
  • Kiwiblog