Lucky Coup Among Authoritarian Regimes
BANGKOK, Thailand -- Myanmar's coup leader may be lucky
Asian country is wedged among authoritarian regimes which are
interested in making money by accessing its natural resources and
strategic geography, instead of condemning the destruction of its
Nearby key investors, including China and
Thailand, muted their
responses to the coup in Myanmar, a France-sized nation also known as
U.S., Europe, Australia and several other more distant
denounced Commander-in-Chief Senior General Min Aung's bloodless coup
at dawn on February 1.
call upon the military to immediately end the State of
restore power to the democratically-elected government, to release all
those unjustly detained, and to respect human rights and the rule of
law," the Group of Seven major economic powers said after the coup.
The G7 comprises the U.S., Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, and the U.K.
In contrast, China
did not support a UN Security Council's effort
February 2 to produce a joint statement condemning the putsch.
Beijing is one of five permanent members of the council and wields veto power.
If Western nations
do curb diplomatic, financial or military links
with Myanmar, then China may seek to fill the resulting vacuum,
Publicly, Beijing insists
sanctions and other international
intervention would wreck Myanmar and impoverish its people even more
than the military's harsh rule.
For decades, Beijing has
barged deeper south across their border,
tapping Myanmar's abundant natural resources, establishing
Chinese-populated towns, and gaining access through its southern coast
to the Bay of Bengal, Andaman Sea and Indian Ocean.
When Western nations clamped
crippling economic sanctions on Myanmar
during the 1990s, hoping to push it toward democracy, China offered
military deals, infrastructure, and investment.
China's reach into Myanmar was so deep, it began to rattle the
military regime during those years.
"We knew we had to diversify our relationships,
open up, and that
meant releasing Aung San Suu Kyi," Myanmar's then-President Thein Sein
told Japan-based Nikkei Asia in 2012.
Myanmar's generals created a
unique position for Ms. Suu Kyi as de
facto civilian leader, sharing some powers with the military.
expected her freedom from 15 years of house arrest would
Western nations to do business with the country, analysts said.
But the military recently began to
worry she was cozying up to Beijing
"Nothing better illustrated the
dissatisfaction than his [Thein
Sein's] abrupt suspension of China's $1.4 billion Myitsone dam project
in northern Kachin state, which remains on hold," Nikkei reported.
In Beijing's latest move to woo both sides,
Chinese Foreign Minister
Wang Yi met Commander-in-Chief Senior General Min and Ms. Suu Kyi on
January 12 during his Southeast Asian tour.
After the coup, Beijing may be disappointed with having to deal solely
with Myanmar's reluctant military, analysts said.
that all sides in Myanmar can appropriately resolve
differences, and uphold political and social stability,” China's
Foreign Ministry Spokesman Wang Wenbin said.
In Buddhist-majority Thailand meanwhile,
Deputy Prime Minister Prawit
Wongsuwan said hours after the coup, "It’s their own business, it’s
their internal affair."
Thai Prime Minister Prayuth
Chan-ocha even warned journalists how to
report the coup.
"I want news reports to be presented carefully,
to avoid any impacts
on the economic benefits," Mr. Prayuth said February 2.
"I don't want any conflict to
escalate, particularly in Thailand,"
where some Bangkok street protests urged democracy be restored in
Mr. Prayuth seized power in a bloodless
military coup in 2014, and
maintains tight control even after winning a 2019 election.
Philippines President Rodrigo Duterte's spokesman
that indifference to Myanmar's coup and said, "This is an internal
belong to a diplomatic group widely perceived
rhetorical and moribund, known as the Association of Southeast Asian
It also includes
Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia,
Singapore, and Vietnam.
ASEAN's foundation is "non-interference" in members' domestic affairs.
Most of their governments meander between
allowing some democratic
freedoms while committing human rights abuses.
"Political stability in ASEAN member
states is essential to achieving
a peaceful, stable and prosperous ASEAN community," the group said in
response to the coup.
"We encourage the pursuance of dialogue,
reconciliation and the return
to normalcy in accordance with the will and interests of the people of
Malaysia and Indonesia -- both with
Muslim majorities -- expressed the
strongest support within ASEAN for a return to democracy in Myanmar.
Myanmar's western frontier, Muslim-majority Bangladesh also
for peace and stability.
More than 750,000
minority ethnic Rohingya Muslims fled Myanmar in
2017 after Myanmar's Buddhist-majority military unleashed what UN
investigators described as "genocide" against them.
Today, they languish in wretched refugee camps
in Bangladesh unable or
unwilling to return home.
Beyond Myanmar's western border meanwhile, India
is locked in hostile
relations with China, and competes in Myanmar for investments and
believe that the rule of law and the democratic process must
upheld," India's foreign ministry said in response to the coup.
While governments decide what to do next,
are already reacting to Myanmar's downturn.
"Is Your Business Funding Myanmar
Military Abuses?" New York-based
Human Rights Watch (HRW) titled a report on February 3.
"The human rights,
reputational, and legal risks of continuing to
business with Myanmar’s military are immense," wrote Aruna Kashyap, a
HRW senior counsel.
"has been accused of genocide and crimes against
against Rohingya Muslims, and war crimes against other ethnic
minorities. And now it has overthrown a civilian government that won
a massive re-election, with over 80 percent of the vote, in November
2020," Ms. Kashyap said.
In Thailand, Amata temporarily halted
its $1 billion industrial estate
development work in Myanmar amid concerns that international sanctions
could make the project taboo for international investors.
"We and our clients are concerned about a
possible trade boycott by
Western countries," Amata's Chief Marketing Officer Viboon Kromadit
said on February 2.
Suzuki Motor stopped its two car-making factories
in Myanmar until the
post-coup situation stabilizes.
Myanmar has had rough relations with foreign nations for centuries.
conquered the country in 1824, causing traumas
that continued into the 20th century.
during World War II gave way independence in 1948,
which led to a doomed Chinese-backed Communist insurgency.
That scattered fighting morphed into
decades of guerrilla wars which
are still being fought by minority ethnic groups for autonomy or
Ms. Suu Kyi was cursed by the
military for much of her political
career as an "axe handle" for British and other foreign governments
who wanted to exploit the country.
She was barred from becoming president because she married a British citizen.
Ms. Suu Kyi was warned if she went to visit
him in England or attend
his funeral, she would not be allowed to return to Myanmar.
Ehrlich is a Bangkok-based American foreign
reporting from Asia since 1978. Excerpts from his new nonfiction book,
"Rituals. Killers. Wars. & Sex. -- Tibet, India, Nepal, Laos, Vietnam,
Afghanistan, Sri Lanka & New York" are available at