Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


Hodgson should withdraw dioxin analyst

30 October 2006

Hodgson should withdraw dioxin analyst, correct confusions

Green Party Health Spokesperson Sue Kedgley has called on Health Minister Pete Hodgson to re-think and withdraw his choice of Dr.Allan Smith as the 'independent' expert appointed to review the findings of forensic accountant John Leonard, contained within the recent TV3 dioxin documentary.

"The expert must not only be independent, but must be perceived to be independent if his conclusions are to have any credibility with the Paritutu community. On that score, I was concerned to read the 1 June 2003 submission by retired Major John Moller to the Health Select Committee inquiry into the exposure of Defence Personnel to Agent Orange, which reports ( on pages 16-17) that the Environment Ministry had organised public lectures by Professor Allan Smith, Dr Michael Bates and other officials regarding dioxin concerns then in the public arena.

"This participation in Government programmes of re-assurances about dioxin should discount Dr Smith as an independent authority," Ms Kedgley says. .

"Mr Hodgson can only commence the corrective process by clarifying his apparently misleading statement to the House during question time on 26 October.that ' the anonymised data in question [ie the individual serum results from the 2005 MoH study] was provided to the international peer reviewers.'

"This is not what Public Health Director Dr Mark Jacobs says. In a letter posted on the TV3 website, and received one working day before the TV3 doco screened, Dr Jacobs states :"The local and international reviewers did not receive individual test results contained in appendix O, just the analysed data."

"Furthermore, I have sighted correspondence between the four international peer reviewers and the makers of the TV3 doco, and the reviewers either say that they were not given the individual serum results or, in one case, said they couldn't remember getting it. It is now up to Pete Hodgson to show that the international peer reviewers were given the individual blood serum results, since the credibility of his reassurances about the 2005 MoH dioxin study hinges on whether the peer reviewers considered all of the data.

"It would hardly be surprising that Mr Hodgson seems confused, because the Ministry's utterances contradict their own Public Health Director..The Health Ministry's 26 October press release for instance says : "Peer reviewers received the individual data for their review..." This is in clear conflict with what Dr Jacobs and the reviewers themselves are saying.

"Finally, can Mr Hodgson assure us that who-ever ultimately gets to carry out the overview report on the Paritutu situation will receive and consider the blood serum results? That anonymised individual data is crucial as to whether - as the TV3 documentary argues - some individuals were wrongly categorised. Clearly, such a step is essential if any definitive verdict is ever to be reached. To do less would be a whitewash, and a sheer waste of taxpayer money." "


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Why Worksafe’s Whakaari/White Island Prosecutions Are Good News

Somewhere in Heaven, Helen Kelly must be smiling about Worksafe’s criminal prosecution of 10 firms and three individuals for their roles in the lead up to the Whakaari /White Island tragedy. In tandem with the subsequent coronial inquest, these court proceedings will hopefully culminate in the creation ( finally!) of a central agency to regulate the adventure tourism sector and improve public safety on matters like risk assessment, safety guidelines, inspection, enforcement and injury reporting... More>>


Pill Testing: Govt Moves On Drug Checking To Keep Young New Zealanders Safer This Summer

The Government will pass time limited legislation to give legal certainty to drug checking services, so they can carry out their work to keep New Zealanders safer this summer at festivals without fear of prosecution, Health Minister Andrew Little ... More>>


WorkSafe: 13 Parties Charged Over Whakaari/White Island Tragedy

WorkSafe New Zealand today filed charges against 13 parties in relation to the Whakaari/White Island eruption in December last year. “22 people have lost their lives in this tragic event. WorkSafe is tasked with investigating workplace incidents to determine ... More>>


Pay Gap: Progress On Pay Equity For DHB Staff

Today’s initial agreement between DHBs and the PSA on pay equity for clerical and administration staff is an important step toward better, fairer pay for this crucial and largely female workforce, Health Minister Andrew Little says. More>>


Media: Stuff Holds Itself Accountable For Wrongs To Māori

Stuff has today published the results of an investigation into itself, and issued a public apology, for the way the media organisation has portrayed Māori, the indigenous people of Aotearoa New Zealand, from its first editions to now. Tā Mātou Pono | More>>


New Zealand Government: To Declare A Climate Emergency

The Government will declare a climate emergency next week, Climate Change Minister James Shaw said today. “We are in the midst of a climate crisis that will impact on nearly every aspect of our lives and the type of planet our children will inherit ... More>>


Economy: Crown Accounts Reflect Govt’s Careful Economic Management

The better-than-expected Crown accounts released today show the Government’s careful management of the COVID-19 health crisis was the right approach to support the economy. As expected, the Crown accounts for the year to June 2020 show the operating balance ... More>>





InfoPages News Channels