Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


Hodgson must consult the people of Paritutu

1 November 2006

Hodgson must consult the people of Paritutu, Greens say

As the Ministry of Health seeks to dampen criticism of its response to the TV3 dioxin documentary, its adding of a secondary WHO approved analyst will do nothing to allay concerns among the Paritutu community about the prime reviewer, Professor Allan Smith, Green Party Health Spokesperson Sue Kedgley says.

"The addition of a second analyst is a diversion from the concerns about Professor Smith's appointment. So long as Professor Smith is involved with the review, the entire process will readily seem like a whitewash, and can only be a waste of time and taxpayer money.

"It is clear that Health Minister Pete Hodgson must pull the plug on Professor Smith entirely, and not seek to put someone else alongside him to deflect the criticism and misgivings within the Paritutu community, whose suffering is at the heart of the dioxin scandal, " Ms Kedgley says.

" Mr Hodgson needs only look at Professor Smith's address to a November 2005 dioxin symposium where he used very flattering terms to describe the Ministry of Health study on dioxin poisoning in Paritutu: that is central to the dioxin scandal highlighted by TV3's investigative team..

"Professor Smith told the symposium : 'Now there's an excellent report come out [on] the dioxin exposures in Paritutu in New Zealand and I do want to say before I say my little word of criticism [that] I think it is an excellent report...." The one sentence to which Professor Smith objected to was the authors' call for an epidemiological study on the health effects or not, on the exposed Paritutu community. That aside, Professor Smith then says for the third time : 'Its an excellent report.' ...."After that effort, how How can Pete Hodgson expect the Paritutu community to perceive Professor Smith as the neutral expert able to lead a dispassionately assessment of the study's shortcomings alleged by TV3 ? " Ms Kedgley says.

" To convince the community, the experts chosen must not only be independent but be perceived as independent by the people central to the scandal. As long ago as 1981, Professor Smith was described in departmental correspondence as the honorary epidemiologist to the Department of Health.. In 1999, Professor Smith fronted a series of public meetings entitled "Dioxins and Public Health" as part of an Environment Ministry programme to address public concerns about dioxins PCBs and organ chlorine pesticides.

"This sort of participation in Government programmes of re-assurances about dioxin discounts Dr Smith from being credibly presentable as an independent authority," Ms Kedgley says.

" What Mr Hodgson now has to do is start afresh, and directly consult and notify the Paritutu community and gain their endorsement of his selected expert, via a public meeting. Mr Hodgson also needs to ensure the expert selected receives the corrected individual serum data, and not the original data sets that allegedly contains the key categorisation errors."


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Australian Election Toss-up

The foibles of the Aussie electoral system are pretty well-known. The Lucky Country doesn’t have proportional representation. Voting for everyone over 18 is compulsory, but within a preferential system. This means that in the relatively few key seats that decide the final result, it can be the voters’ second, third or fourth ranking preferences that finally get the winner over the 50% line...


Budget: Climate Investments Provide Path To Economic Security
The Government is investing in New Zealand’s economic security by ensuring climate change funding moves away from short-term piecemeal responses and towards smart, long-term investment... More>>


Budget: Updated My Vaccine Pass For Those Who Want It

New Zealanders who are up-to-date with their COVID-19 vaccinations will be able to download an updated My Vaccine Pass from 24 May, COVID-19 Response Minister Chris Hipkins said today... More>>

Speaker: 2022 Register Of Pecuniary And Other Specified Interests Presented
The 2022 Register of Pecuniary and Other Specified Interests of Members of Parliament was presented in the House today. It contains a summary of members’ interests as at 31 January 2022... More>>

Classification Office: Following Decision To Ban Manifesto The Buffalo Mass Shooting Livestream Is Now Banned
The livestream video of yesterday’s mass shooting in the United States has now been banned, Acting Chief Censor Rupert Ablett-Hampson announced this morning. The decision follows on from his decision yesterday to call in and ban the ‘manifesto... More>>

Borders: New Zealand Poised To Welcome International Students Back
New Zealand is fully reopening to international students and the Government is committed to help reinvigorate and strengthen the sector, Education Minister Chris Hipkins said today... More>>

Inland Revenue: Commissioner Appointed
Deputy Public Service Commissioner Helene Quilter QSO has today announced the appointment of Peter Mersi to the position of Commissioner and Chief Executive, Inland Revenue Department... More>>




InfoPages News Channels