Parliament

Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search

 

Criminal Justice Changes: Issue Disputes

FACT SHEET 5: DEFENCE IDENTIFICATION OF ISSUES IN DISPUTE

What is the general proposal?

As part of the new case-management approach, the defence will be required to give notice of the issues that are in dispute in a particular case.

Why change the law?

There is currently no requirement, before a trial begins, for the prosecution and defence to discuss or agree on those aspects of a case that will need to be determined by the court, and those which the defendant does not seek to challenge.

This means that cases must progress as if everything is disputed, unless the defence voluntarily identifies issues that are agreed. As a consequence:

The prosecution must undertake preparation that is ultimately not required.

Witnesses are called unnecessarily.

Trials are unnecessarily complex and the judge or jury’s job is made more difficult.

Some trials progress further than they should.

How?

As part of the new case-management approach, the defence will be required (before trial) to give notice of the issues that are in dispute. If the defence unreasonably fails to follow this requirement, the judge and jury are entitled to draw their own inferences about why the defendant did not do so. If, for example, a defendant raises a defence at trial that it could have done at the earlier stage, a judge or jury might draw an inference about the credibility of that defence. Such inferences would not, by themselves, be enough to determine guilt, but would be another of the matters a judge or jury could take into account in reaching their decision. To ensure this process is fair, a judge must give both parties a chance to be heard on any failure to identify issues in dispute before any comment is made to the jury.

Benefits of proposal

Prosecution and defence resources would be saved by ensuring they are not misdirected to irrelevant matters. It is estimated, for example, that requiring the defence to identify issues in dispute will save approximately 450 court days per year, or around 10 per cent of expected total judge-alone and jury time.

Victims and witnesses will be inconvenienced less because they will have to appear only when they are really needed.

Because they will know what the case is before the trial begins, the fact-finder (judge and juries, but particularly juries) will be in a better position to assess the significance of the evidence presented.

The number of trials required may also decrease because defence counsel may determine that the case has little prospect of success.

International comparisons

Similar regimes are in place in the United Kingdom1, Victoria2, New South Wales3, Western Australia4, and South Australia5. Of the Australian states, Victoria’s regime is the most comprehensive.

1 Criminal Procedure and Investigation Act 1996

2 Crimes (Criminal Trials) Act 1999

3 Criminal Procedure Act 1986

4 Criminal Procedure Act 2004

5 Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935

ends

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Next Governor-General

The next Governor-General will have to be named quite soon. Dame Patsy Reddy (appointed 2016) is nearing the end of her five-year term. At the best of times, being a credible local stand-in for a head of state that’s based in London cannot be an easy job. Yet for the next appointee, the usual republican rumblings will be the least of it. The next G-G will almost certainly be in office when the Elizabeth II era finally comes to an end, and when the reign of her deeply uncharismatic son gets under way... More>>


 
 

Office Of The Speaker: 2021 Register Of Pecuniary And Other Specified Interests Presented

The 2021 Register of Pecuniary and Other Specified Interests of Members of Parliament was presented to the House today. It contains a summary of members’ pecuniary and other specified interests as at 31 January 2021. The Speaker of the House, Rt Hon ... More>>

Budget 2021: Boosts Carbon Neutral Government Commitment

· Budget 2021 delivers $67.4 million to support the transition to a carbon neutral public sector by 2025 · State Sector Decarbonisation Fund receives significant boost to support more schools, hospitals and other government organisations to replace ... More>>

Government: To Rev Up Reductions In Transport Emissions

The Government is calling for feedback on a range of potential policies to eliminate emissions in the transport sector. Transport Minister Michael Wood today released Hīkina te Kohupara – Kia mauri ora ai te iwi - Transport Emissions: Pathways to ... More>>

Child Poverty: Reports Highlight Need For Ongoing Action

The Government has released the first Annual Report for the Child and Youth Wellbeing Strategy and the second Child Poverty Related Indicators (CPRI) Report, both of which highlight improvements in the lives of children as a result of actions of the Government, ... More>>

ALSO:

PM: Statement On The Speaker And Annual Review Debate

“The serious issue of alleged sexual assault and harassment at Parliament was poorly managed and inappropriately politicised last night. The tone of the debate did not reflect well on Parliament as a whole,” Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern said. ... More>>

Local Government: Independent Review To Explore Future

Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta says an independent review of local government will explore how councils can maintain and improve the wellbeing of New Zealanders in the communities they serve long into the future. More>>

ALSO:


 
 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels