Parliament

Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search

 

Treasury NZ Rail report 'garbage'

Jim Anderton A Treasury cost-benefit study on the privatisation of NZ Rail released today is garbage, Alliance leader Jim Anderton says.

'This is far right ideology masquerading as maths. The economic analysis is of such poor quality that it demands an inquiry into the shabby state of economic competence at Treasury and at the Victoria University front-organisation set up to produce the study.

'Analysis of the study by independent professional economists commissioned by the Alliance showed that equations underpinning th e study contained political assumptions normally associated with far-right economic analysis.

'The Government's net revenue is the only truly measurable figure in the document. The rest is based on highly subjective assessments of items such as 'consumer surplus'. The study uses far-right economic assumptions to weight the importance of many elements.

'The welfare benefits of New Zealand and foreign ownership are assumed to be equal. So, for example, if the sale of NZ Rail has resulted in profits flowing out of the country, worsening the balance of payments deficit, then all New Zealanders pay higher interest rates. But the study assumes the effect is zero.

'The study assumes that there is no benefit to consumers from public ownership of a network. So for example, if the railway makes a small provincial town viable, the study assumes there is no benefit from that, nor any benefit to a company which can ship goods more cheaply.

'The most sinister assumption is in the statement 'we do not distinguish between the welfare of economic agents as between their actions as consumers or providers of labour.

' To see what this means, imagine that NZ Rail under private ownership lays off staff and stops providing apprenticeships, but makes more profit and therefore pays more tax to the Government. If the Government used that money to give tax cuts to the wealthy, then the study regards that as welfare-neutral exercise. The person who loses their job or training opportunity is assumed to be no worse off, and society is assumed to be no worse off because of high levels of unemployment and falling skill levels.

'This is economic garbage of the most sinister and far-right variety and Treasury should be ashamed of its involvement in it,' Jim Anderton said.


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Perils Of Declaring Premature Victory


Sure enough, Saturday’s Vaxathon was a barrel of fun and a throwback not merely to the Telethons of the past. It also revived memories of those distant days of early 2020, when we were all carefully wiping down our groceries, not touching our faces, washing our hands for 20 seconds and responding to level four lockdowns by putting teddy bears in the window for the benefit of the little kids walking by in their family bubbles. Those were the days, when the Team of Five Million felt like a real, organic thing... More>>

RNZ: Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern announces Cabinet decision on Covid-19 alert levels


Northland will move to level 2 at 11.59pm on 19 October. Waikato will be held at level 3, to be reviewed on Friday. Auckland will remain in level 3 with current restrictions for another two weeks... More>>

ALSO:




 
 

Economy: Inflation highest in over a decade
The consumers price index rose 2.2 percent in the September 2021 quarter, the biggest quarterly movement since a 2.3 percent rise in the December 2010 quarter, Stats NZ said today. Excluding quarters impacted by increases to GST rates, the September quarter movement was the highest since the June 1987 quarter... More>>

ALSO:


Government: New Zealand Increases Climate Aid Contribution

The Government is making a four-fold increase in the support it provides to countries most vulnerable to the climate emergency, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Climate Change Minister James Shaw announced today... More>>

Government: Opportunity To Shape NZ’s First Emissions Reduction Plan
The Government is inviting New Zealanders to inform the country’s first Emissions Reduction Plan with the release of a consultation document containing a range of policy ideas to decrease the country’s emissions, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Climate Change Minister James Shaw announced today... More>>

ALSO:


CPay Cheque To Pay Cheque: Half A Million New Zealanders Have No Savings
New findings from the Consumer NZ sentiment tracker found that 15% of New Zealanders had no savings, and a further 27% were anxious about their level of savings and would like to have more tucked away... More>>


Government: Mandatory Vaccination For Two Workforces

Large parts of two workforces critical to preventing the spread of COVID-19 will be required to be vaccinated, COVID-19 Response Minister Chris Hipkins said today. “Our education and health and disability workforces have done an incredible job throughout this pandemic to keep themselves and people safe,” Chris Hipkins said.... More>>


Green Party: Deeply Concerned Space Launches May Be Breaching Nuclear-free Laws

The Green Party is deeply concerned that space launches by Rocket Lab may be breaching nuclear-free laws, given our long-standing position as a signatory of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty... More>>


 
 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels