Parliament

Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search

 

The old pragmatism versus ideology debate

Breaking the habit of a political lifetime, upton-on-line tuned into Holmes at 7 pm to catch the head to head leaders' debate between Jenny Shipley and Helen Clark.

Research reveals that readers of upton-on-line are highly articulate and politically aware, so we can safely assume that most would have viewed the debate themselves live (or failing that, that they are clever enough to programme their video recorders).

We will, therefore, make no attempt to pull the wool over such intelligent eyes. That said, it is clear to upton-on-line that Jenny Shipley won the debate hands down.

Fearing that he had lost his objectivity on this matter, upton-on-line did engage in some random polling of public responses. This wasn't as easy as one would assume. The first person was eating her dinner, and always turns Holmes off to aid her digestion. The second was out mountain-biking. The third would not reveal what he was doing. But, the old lady next door, found outside watering her garden agreed: it was a relief to find the two leaders finally face to face, looking each other in the eye and fighting it out.

Helen Clark slipped in a few good lines and was obviously very carefully schooled (notice that she 'cared passionately' about just-about everything). But so much of what she said wafted into generalities. Vision, passion and empathy are all very well, but they do not exist simply in their being stated. One cannot conjure up a fairer New Zealand simply by wishing it.

It's one thing to say you're 'standing behind' exporters and producers by giving them $100 million, but it's not much use if you're taking $200 million away through ACC, mangling the employment system and signalling an intention to tax success. Jenny had all the figures and they were persuasive.

Helen Clark mouthed an intention to 'care passionately', but Jenny Shipley pointed out that there was plenty of passion to be found on the West Coast and the Labour leader had refused to have anything to do with it.

Light relief was offered in the ad break by Jim Anderton's beaming visage somehow inveigling itself into the debate, claiming that the Alliance would create 80,000 new jobs. Upton-on-line is astounded by Mr Anderton's confidence. How on earth can he predict such a thing and with such accuracy? Unless he plans to buy back the Railways and hire 80,000 people to run the cafeterias, organise strikes on school holidays, and to make sure the trains don't run on time.

The ad breaks also saw plenty of balloons being blown up, which was exciting, although upton-on-line found the scene rather muddied by the Westpac ads. One never knows what kind of ad one is watching these days. A little girl in Carterton, while watching one of Wyatt Creech's efforts for the National Party, is said to have confidently announced that "he works for Westpac Trust".

The most telling moment of the evening came when Mr Holmes asked Helen Clark just how wedded to ideology she was. He asked (in words to this effect) would you oppose on principle public operations being done by private health practitioners even if it could be proved that it meant more operations were done, and presumably more lives were saved? Likewise, on the roads, would you oppose tolls being placed on new roads if it could be shown that that was by far the fastest way to get a particular road built?

Despite all her avowals of pragmatism and caring passionately, she could not answer. Labour is more interested in slogans like 'a fairer society' and 'better health-care for everyone', than it is in the grubby reality of facts, compromises and reality. The purity of their ideas is more important to them than people.

National and Jenny Shipley are often accused of doing anything to stay in power. That's one way of looking at it. The other way is to say that they are willing to work with what they've got and are driven by results not empty slogans. The OECD's prediction of New Zealand having the fourth highest growth rate of its members is not a bad one to throw into the debate.

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

PM's Statement: Deadly Eruption Of Whakaari / White Island

At this stage, we can confirm that amongst those currently listed as missing or injured are New Zealanders who were part of the tour operation, and tourists from Australia, the United States, the United Kingdom, China and Malaysia. That is to the best of our knowledge.

To those who have lost or are missing family and friends, we share in your unfathomable grief at this moment in time, and in your sorrow. Your loved ones stood alongside kiwis who were hosting you here. We grieve with you, and we grieve with them... More>>

Police Update: Five Confirmed Dead - Eight People Unaccounted For
Work has continued overnight to respond to the eruption on White Island. Enquiries with tour operators indicate that 47 people were on White Island at the time of the eruption. Police can now advise that in addition to the five people confirmed deceased, eight people remain unaccounted for following the eruption. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Eruption And Tourism Safety
Adventure tourism is a central theme in New Zealand tourism, and by definition, adventure always includes a certain level of risk. That said, New Zealand itself is also at risk of being seen as a tourism destination where commercial factors – rather than safety factors – are routinely allowed to determine the point where the boundary line of acceptable risk is being drawn. More>>

 

Big, Bold, Permanent Change Needed: Children's Commissioner On 2019 Child Poverty Monitor

“I want to see family incomes dramatically raised by increasing benefits and making the minimum wage a living wage. And the Government needs to move much faster at increasing the supply of social housing..." More>>

ALSO:

RNZ Live Updates: Weather Mayhem Strands Tourists; Major Roads Closed

Hundreds of tourists are stranded on the West Coast, and on the other side of the South Island a flood-damaged bridge has closed State Highway 1, after a weekend of torrential rain... More>>

ALSO:

Policing: Armoured Specialist Police Vehicles

New Zealand Police has taken delivery of three Armoured Special Purpose Vehicles. The vehicles are unmarked and look like standard Toyota Land cruisers... They will not be used for patrol. More>>

Single Use PVC And Polystyrene Out: Next Steps On Plastic Waste

The Government will phase out more single-use plastics following the success of its single-use plastic bag ban earlier this year and the release today of a pivotal report for dealing with waste. More>>

ALSO:

Faafoi Statement: Minister's Suspicious Immigration Texts

I have apologised to the Prime Minister and understand I have let her down in regards to my dealings with Jason Kerrison over an immigration matter concerning his family. More>>

ALSO:

NZ First Conflicts Of Interest: New Details Around Timeline

New information has emerged showing it was the New Zealand First chief of staff who identified potential conflicts of interest between a forestry company and two senior government ministers, sparking a series of declarations. More>>

Earlier:

Donations:

Five New Cancer Meds In Six Months: Pharmac Funds More Cancer Medicines, Faster Assessment

PHARMAC has confirmed that two new medicines – olaparib for ovarian cancer and fulvestrant for breast cancer – have been approved for funding... Rituximab and bortezomib, which are already funded, have also been approved for widened access following successful commercial proposals from new suppliers. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 


 

InfoPages News Channels