Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

United Future Supports 'Ambulances For Africa'


United Future Supports 'Ambulances For Africa'

So United Future's Gordon Copeland is upset that critics are describing their Commission for the Family as some sort of wishy- washy feel-good policy. If it's any consolation Gordon, I'm upset too, but for different reasons.

In his column, "The crucial importance of the family in the New Zealand economy", he bemoans the $1.5 billion cost of the DPB. He forgot about the accommodation supplement, family benefit and special benefit which many recipients also receive but I'll forgive that.

What I find harder to swallow is that United's first action, on agreeing to support the government, was to vote for MORE welfare. Treasury warned that if the DPB was not worktested, numbers would grow by 1,000 every year for the next three years but United ignored that. Numbers had dropped since the introduction of worktesting but United ignored that. Their own leader had voted against the bill before the election but the party ignored that.

United Future unnervingly jumped very quickly into bed with the leftist egalitarians who cry 'worktesting is punitive'. I am sure we all find work punishing on a bad day but we do it because somebody has to pay for the 400,000-odd working-age people who don't.

In fleshing out a grim picture of hardship, Mr Copeland refers to the New Zealand Living Standards 2000 report. But he makes no mention of the finding that people in work had better standards of living than those on benefits, even when their incomes were about the same. An earlier report, "Children in poor families: Does the source of family income change the picture?" found; "...there is considerable variation in the living standards of those below the poverty threshold, and (the results) suggest that poor children in families with government transfers as the main income source are a particularly vulnerable group."

Clearly a job is better than a benefit, especially where children are concerned. But Mr Copeland goes on to tell us that they support the government's approach to family breakdown which is to place ambulances at the bottom of the cliff by way of benefits and like payments. Does Mr Copeland seriously believe, hand on heart, that all benefits are ambulances? I wonder if he ever entertains a sneaking suspicion that they might be cop-outs or incentives, or even rewards for the irresponsible. Perhaps hush money for those in the too-hard basket.

If benefits were truly ambulances then they would be temporary for the able-bodied. People ride in ambulances to hospitals and surprise, surprise, they get out of them.

In an attempt to convince us that we need a Commission for the Family to "explore, advise and initiate programmes and policies aimed at strengthening marriage, relationships and parenting for the benefit of all New Zealand families," he adds that similar policies have shown early promise in Singapore and the US. Hello?

Singapore does not have a welfare state and since 1996 the US has treated welfare as strictly temporary. To say that those policies will work in the New Zealand environment is, to borrow Gordon's analogy, like to trying to win the America's Cup in a waka.

It is United's 'hope and dream' that their commission will reduce the number of ambulances at the bottom of the cliff and then state spending can be reduced and taxes lowered. Yet Mr Copeland admits that twenty five years of putting ambulances at the bottom of the cliff has only led to .....more and more ambulances being put at the bottom of the cliff. Good Lord, the congestion at the bottom of the cliff rivals an Auckland motorway.

How many more years will it take for people to wake up and realise that government social spending programmes don't work? What if, instead of taking the $10 million cost for the commission off the employer who is desperate to take on more staff but can't afford to, we simply left it in his pocket?

Jobs must come first.


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines


Gordon Campbell: On Our Weird Ways Of Funding Care For The Dying


National Party leader Judith Collins thinks the government’s traffic light system for emerging from Covid lockdowns is “confusing.” Perhaps she could be looking in the mirror because in recent weeks, National has hardly been a model of crystalline clarity. On RNZ this morning Collins was calling for the scrapping of all vaccine certificates and mandates once we hit 90% double dose vaccination. Yet in recent weeks, Chris Bishop, National’s Covid spokesperson has been indicating that vaccine certificates and employment mandates will be, and should be, part of our new Covid landscape... More>>

Covid-19: Two Cases Notified In Christchurch Last Evening


The Ministry of Health was notified last evening of two positive COVID-19 cases in Christchurch from the same household. One member of the household had recently returned to Christchurch from Auckland. The local public health unit is gathering information from the cases to identify close contacts and exposure events, including any locations of interest... More>>





 
 


Government: Considers Regulatory Safeguards For Three Waters Services
Public feedback is being sought on the regulatory safeguards required to ensure consumers and communities receive three waters services that meet their needs, Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister, Dr David Clark announced today... More>>


Three Waters: Government To Protect Vital Public Water Services For Future Generations
Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta today confirmed the Government will create four publicly owned water entities to ensure every New Zealander has access to affordable, long-lasting drinking, waste and storm water infrastructure... More>>

ALSO:



Government: Responds To Independent Review Into WorkSafe

The Government has clear expectations that WorkSafe must action the recommendations of the independent review into the regulator to improve its management of adventure activities following the tragedy at Whakaari White Island, Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Michael Wood says... More>>



Government: First Step In Managed Isolation Changes; Expanding QFT With Pacific

The Government is starting a phased easing of border restrictions that will see the time spent in an MIQ facility halved for fully vaccinated overseas arrivals from 14 November and home isolation introduced in the first quarter of 2022 at the latest, Chris Hipkins said today... More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels