Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

A Story of Trucks, Tractors and Injustice

Wed, 7 July 2004

Import News from the Importers Institute of New Zealand 7 July 2004 -

A Story of Trucks, Tractors and Injustice

A Southland farmer claims that Customs perverted the course of Justice thirteen years ago. He has been battling with officials and politicians ever since.

It all started in 1991, when Wallace Drummond imported a Mercedes-Benz Unimog (www.unimogtrucks.com). Customs called it a truck, the importer called it a tractor. The dispute went to Mike Bungay, who was then the tariff classification arbitrator. Bungay agreed with Customs and Drummond appealed to the High Court.

Mike Bungay told me that the Minister of Customs (at the time, Murray McCully) had tried to get him to change his ruling. I don't know where exactly Bungay told the Minister to file that plan, but I do know that he was not at all impressed with what he saw as an attempt to influence a judicial officer.

On the steps of the High Court, Customs withdrew the case, refunded $3,615 duty that it had collected from Mr Drummond and offered him $50,000 in compensation. That amount was then the highest amount that Ministers could pay out, without having to go to Cabinet for approval.

It was around this time that our alarm bells started to ring. Why would Customs go to such lengths to stop this matter from going to Court? The answer became clear later. A low-level Customs official had doctored some crucial evidence. His managers tried to cover that up.

As the classification matter never went to Court, Mike Bungay's binding decision means that the Unimog is still officially classified as a truck in this country. Because it is left-hand drive, it is a prohibited import. In the absence of a Court ruling overturning Bungay's decision, the duty refund was illegal.

Mr Drummond has been seeking redress of the injustices done to him ever since. He finally petitioned Parliament. A Select Committee headed by Peter Dunne recommended:

"That the Government compensate Peter Wallace Drummond for actual legitimate costs incurred by him in the course of obtaining the correct classification from the New Zealand Customs Service for his Unimog tractor." http://www.clerk.parliament.govt.nz/Content/SelectCommitteeReports/fdpet 99199.pdf

The ball is now in Helen Clark's court. As is her wont these days, she passed it on to an underling to front up, in this case Jim Anderton, who in turn consulted his farmer wife and decided that the Unimog is a truck after all. Anderton decided to reject the Select Committee's recommendation and said that Drummond will receive no compensation.

Anderton is merely the last in a long line of fools who think that Drummond will give up. He won't. He uncovered highly questionable conduct by officials and deserves to get the independent inquiry that he has been asking for all these years. Helen Clark should get someone competent to look into her government's response to the Select Committee's recommendation to compensate Wallace Drummond.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On National’s Incredible Disappearing Tax Policy


During the years of the Key government one hardy perennial of political journalism was that whenever the Labour Opposition would suggest a policy alternative to the status quo, the hard bitten response from the Gallery realists would be “But how’re you gonna pay for it?” National in Opposition has been almost entirely spared that level of sceptical scrutiny. Until now, that is. Until now, Christopher Luxon had largely been left free to witter on that it is entirely feasible to (a) repay debt faster (b) cut taxes significantly and (c) maintain, or even increase the current levels of spending on health and education and (d) do all that at once...
More>>




 
 


National: Five Years Of Failure For Light Rail
Construction of light rail in Auckland might not begin until 2025 despite tomorrow marking five years since Jacinda Ardern announced it would be delivered to Mt Roskill by 2021, National’s Transport spokesperson Simeon Brown says... More>>


Government: Representation Bill Passes Third Reading In Parliament
Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu welcomes the passing of new legislation tonight to reinstate Ngāi Tahu councillors to Environment Canterbury... More>>


Government: First Ever Climate Adaptation Plan Lays Foundations For Resilient Communities

New Zealand’s first National Adaptation Plan, launched today, will ensure communities have the information and support they need to prepare for the impacts of climate change... More>>



Government: More Women On Public Boards Than Ever Before

“Women’s representation on public sector boards and committees is now 52.5 percent, the highest ever level... More>>


Te Pāti Māori: Debbie Ngarewa-Packer Calls On PM To Support Bill To Ban Seabed Mining

Te Pāti Māori Co-leader, Ngāti Ruanui and Ngā Rauru uri Debbie Ngarewa-Packer is today celebrating that her Prohibition on Seabed Mining Legislation Amendment Bill has been drawn from Parliament’s biscuit tin... More>>

Housing: Building Consents Surpass 50k Again
New Zealand’s strong pipeline of housing construction is continuing with the annual number of new homes consented surpassing 50,000 for the fourth month in a row... More>>


 
 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels