Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


“Three Strikes” Law Would Save Lives

Media Release
12th December 2007

One Weekend Four Murders!
“Three Strikes” Law Would Save Lives

David Garrett is a Barrister in Auckland, he is also a spokesman for the Sensible Sentencing Trust, David, like many other New Zealanders believes New Zealand’s high and ever increasing level of violent crime is a direct result of corrupt sentencing policies combined with a political agenda that has tried to convince us that criminals are victims of society and best rehabilitated within the community rather than punished inside of prisons. David Garrett argues that if New Zealand adopted a “Three Strikes” law many innocent lives would be saved.

“In two recent high profile homicides, the alleged perpetrators each have at least three prior convictions for serious violence. It is not possible – or in fact desirable – to further identify the cases at this stage. This is for two very good reasons; firstly there are suppression orders in place, and to breach them invites contempt of court charges. Secondly – and perhaps more importantly from our perspective – if we identify the alleged killers, their lawyers are able to make an application for a discharge without a trial, because such publicity may prejudice a fair trial.

The identities of the alleged killers in these two cases will emerge in the fullness of time but at this stage, suffice it to say that if they are eventually found guilty, two people would have been alive now if a “three strikes” law was in force in New Zealand a month ago.

I am currently attempting to prise some no doubt embarrassing numbers out of the Department of Corrections using the Official information Act. The central question I have asked reads:

“How many persons currently serving life sentences for murder (regardless of the non - parole period if any) had, prior to their conviction for murder, three or more convictions for an offence of serious violence. (Examples of such offences are given below).”

One would have thought that the above is a relatively easy question for the officials to answer. Indeed, the person I am dealing with at the Department replied on 20 November – five weeks is not such a bad response time as these things go – indicating that the information had been obtained, but the formal response was “ with the Ministerial Co-ordinator.” I am still waiting.

From other sources, I have determined that if we had a “three strikes” law in which a “strike” was defined as “an offence of serious violence carrying a sentence of at least two years imprisonment”, our prison population would almost double. That, of course, will be at least one of the reasons for arguing that a “three strikes” law is impracticable. Building prisons with underfloor heating and top gym facilities is expensive.

Looking at that statistic from the opposite perspective – that of victims and prospective victims – the number is equally alarming. It means at there are about 8,000 violent recidivist offenders walking around in the community. Some of them may never commit another violent crime – but what is certain is that some of them will. And their next crime may be the most violent of all – homicide.

“Three strikes” laws overseas – particularly in the United States – have come in for harsh criticism – much of it justifiable. Because of the American distinction between “felonies” and “misdemeanors”, and poorly drafted laws, people can and have been locked up for 25 years to life for a simple theft without violence.

It is not difficult to draft a law which “catches only the really bad guys” and avoids those kinds of injustices – indeed I have recently drafted just such a law. I sent it to various people for comment, one of whom was the leader of a lobby group in California which seeks to amend California’s law so that it catches only violent felons.

The response was “…compared to what California has, yours in wonderful.” That is good enough for me, given that this lobby group is led by stereotype California liberals. I do not expect such a guardedly enthusiastic response from the liberals in New Zealand – no doubt there will be the usual howls of outrage at the prospect of increasing our prison population.

Incidentally, the leaders of the California lobby group were astounded – as was everyone else we met on our recent study trip to the USA – that we do not have Life Without Parole (LWOP) as even a option for our worst murderers. In the deluded minds of those who make penal policy in New Zealand, even Graeme Burton is capable of rehabilitation. God help our children”.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Elusive Charms Of Christopher Luxon

Well, the first 36 hours of viewing the Christopher Luxon selfie were always going to be the best, before the repetitions set in. We get it, already. He’s an extroverted/big ego/high achieving/God fearing/country music lovin’/family man who is not at all averse to mansplaining to little ladies like RNZ’s Kathryn Ryan what “technical” words like “productivity” actually mean. But wait, there’s more. National is back! Mind you, that’s not the Bad National of recent experience, but the Good National of days gone by... More>>


Cancer Society: Hopes Final Pharmac Report Is Stronger

Today the delayed Interim Report was released by the Pharmac Review Panel. The performance of Pharmac and access to cancer drugs is a major concern for the Cancer Society... More>>

Defence: New Zealand Response To Assist Peace And Stability In Solomon Islands
The New Zealand government has announced that it will deploy Defence Force and Police personnel to Honiara to help restore peace and stability. “New Zealand is committed to its responsibilities and playing its part in upholding regional security,” Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern said.... More>>

Government: Delivers Reactivation Package As Aucklanders Reconnect For Summer
A new support package will help revive economic, social and cultural activities in our largest city over summer, and ensure those in hardship also get relief. The Social Development and Employment Minister Carmel Sepuloni and the Economic and Regional Development Minister Stuart Nash... More>>

National Party: Bridges Appointed Finance & Infrastructure Spokesperson

Hon Simon Bridges is the National Party’s new Finance and Infrastructure spokesperson, National Leader Christopher Luxon announced today. “Simon has prodigious skills, incredible talent and the intellectual heft needed to excel as National’s Finance spokesperson,” Mr Luxon says.... More>>

Waitangi National Trust: Waitangi Week
The Waitangi National Trust has decided there will be no in-person events at Waitangi Treaty Grounds during Waitangi Week 2022. Under the COVID-19 Protection Framework it would be practically impossible to safely proceed with the usual events of Waitangi commemorations... More>>

Freedom Camping: Making Sure People Are Up To Play With Changes
People interested in finding out how the proposed improvements to freedom camping might affect them are being invited to an information-sharing webinar... More>>




InfoPages News Channels