Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

SSC On Clare Curran investigation

20 December 2007.

Commissioner's conclusions in respect of the Clare Curran investigation

Mark Prebble, State Services Commissioner,


I have received Mr Rennie's report into the facts surrounding the contract that Clare Curran had with the Ministry for the Environment during 2006. The background to this investigation was public concern and speculation that Ms Curran's contract might reflect either an inappropriate action by a Minister to secure the employment of a political ally, or an attempt to ensure that the work of the Ministry was aligned to or contributing to the Minister's political agenda.

Mr Rennie's investigation has shown that there was no ministerial direction and no inappropriate politically aligned work. On the contrary, a person of merit, with no unmanageable conflicts, was retained for an appropriate job, she did appropriate work on appropriate terms. That is the first major conclusion that can be drawn from this review.

The second conclusion however, relates to the perceptions around this matter. In this case, the Ministry's management of this contract contributed to a perception of a possible breach of neutrality. This is significant, because perceptions matter in this area.

Putting it briefly, therefore, I conclude that in substance the appointment and the work of Clare Curran were appropriate. I also conclude that the Ministry should have done more to maintain the necessary perception of neutrality.

The basis for these conclusions may be found in Mr Rennie's detailed account and comments on the events of May to July 2006. That contains a thorough account of the actions of each of the people involved.

Before moving on to draw lessons for the Public Service from these events, I need to allude briefly to another matter of recent public interest. Following her public comments about this case, Ms Erin Leigh became the subject herself of some comment in Parliament. Over the last couple of weeks both Mr Logan and the Minister have publicly explained how those comments came to be made and have offered their apologies. As a result it is unnecessary for me now to make any further comment on this matter.

As I turn to draw the lessons from this event, I am taking into account the broader pattern of behaviour that I am aware of across the Public Service. In recent months, in the context of this and the previous inquiry into the Ministry for the Environment, I have had the opportunity to check with senior management in other departments to see how they have approached similar matters. I have found many examples where managers can point to thorough and careful steps to maintain the political impartiality of the Public Service while addressing the needs of Ministers.

While that is reassuring, this report is still timely. Next year is an election year. That always leads to a heightening of political tension. At such time it is important that Public Service leaders maintain all the processes needed to support and defend the political impartiality of the Public Service. I will continue to provide guidance and assistance to agencies regarding all matters concerning the relationships, expectations and interactions among State servants, Ministers, Members of Parliament and political parties. I consider it appropriate that I take a conservative approach to such matters to ensure that impartiality is upheld.

The overall lesson, then, is that not only does our law and custom prescribe that New Zealand public servants must be impartial, we must always take care to display impartiality. It is quite reasonable that senior public servants are exposed to close public scrutiny. We cannot assume that our good intentions will always be clear to those who see our behaviour. We must continually take enough steps to demonstrate that we are maintaining impartiality. That may sometimes seem demanding, but it is a privilege to work in a democracy, and we have the opportunity to do our bit to maintain democratic values by working impartially for the government of the day.


ENDS


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Erebus Memorial In Parnell

Social media can be a wonderful tool for bringing people together in a common cause. It can also be a seedbed and spreader of mis-information on a community-wide scale. To which category do the protests against the siting of an Erebus memorial (to the 257 New Zealanders who died in that tragedy) in a secluded corner of a Parnell park happen to belong? IMO, it is clearly the latter, and the reasons for thinking so are explained below... More>>

 

National: Proposed Hate Speech Laws A Step Too Far

Reports of the Government’s proposed new hate speech laws go a step too far and risk sacrificing the freedoms New Zealanders enjoy, National’s Justice spokesperson Simon Bridges says. “The reforms are supposedly including protections to every ... More>>

ALSO:

Agriculture: Government To Phase Out Live Exports By Sea

The Government has announced that the export of livestock by sea will cease following a transition period of up to two years, said Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor. “At the heart of our decision is upholding New Zealand’s reputation for high ... More>>

ALSO:

Norman Gemmell: New Zealand’s New Housing Policy Is Really Just A New Tax Package — And It’s A Shambles

Norman Gemmell , Te Herenga Waka — Victoria University of Wellington Economists like to talk about “optimal policy instruments” — essentially, policies that achieve their objectives more effectively or efficiently than the alternatives, and ... More>>

Claire Breen: ACC’s Policy Of Not Covering Birth Injuries Is One More Sign The System Is Overdue For Reform

Claire Breen , University of Waikato Recent media coverage of women not being able to get treatment for birth injuries highlights yet another example of gender bias in healthcare in New Zealand. More>>

Police: Police Accept Findings Of IPCA Report Into Photographs Taken At Checkpoint

Police accept the findings of a report by the Independent Police Conduct Authority (IPCA) relating to photographs taken at a checkpoint in Northland. On November 16, 2019, Police set up a checkpoint down the road from a fight night event in Ruakaka ... More>>

ALSO:

Health: Drug-Testing Law To Be Made Permanent

Interim legislation that is already proving to keep people safer from drugs will be made permanent, Health Minister Andrew Little says. More>>

 
 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels