Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Which ‘climate science’ does Minister Smith accept?

25 January 2011
For immediate release

Which ‘climate science’ does Minister Smith accept?

Climate Change Issues Minister Nick Smith has been called on to amplify his statement to the New Zealand Herald’s Brian Fallow last Saturday: “We accept the science” relating to global warming and the forthcoming review later this year of the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS).

Fallow had written: “The review, to be chaired by David Caygill, is a statutory requirement. It is expressly not to revisit the issues, debated at tedious length for at least the past decade, about whether New Zealand should be taking action on climate change at all or whether an emotions [sic] trading scheme is the most appropriate response.”

The call to Minister Smith comes from Hon Barry Brill, chairman of the New Zealand Climate Science Coalition, and himself a former Minister of Energy and Minister of Science and Technology, who said: “Minister Nick Smith told the Herald ‘we accept the science.’ Fine. What science is that – the 2007 version (when the ETS Bill was introduced) or the 2011 version?

“Al Gore’s slogan ‘the science is settled’ has now well and truly passed into history. The US Government alone is budgeting $US10.6 million per day for new climate research during the current fiscal year. The UN’s IPCC is to be the subject of sweeping reforms. Closer to home, NIWA’s credibility is under severe strain.

“Within the past week, India’s influential Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh has released a new scientific paper showing that increases in the sun’s magnetic field has been the cause of much of the 0.75°C global warming recorded since 1960. Dr U R Rao, former chairman of Indian Space Research Organisation, says any contribution by CO2 is much less than the estimates of the IPCC – at least 44%.

The Hindustan Times has commented that “international climate science is mainly Western driven to support the view of the rich world that gases such as CO2 are the main contributor for global warming. Any scientific work challenging this view has been debunked as the work of skeptics.”

Mr Brill said that, in the past, the IPCC has consistently ignored solar magnetic fields and the impact of galactic cosmic rays (GCRs). But the chair of the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), Rajendra Pachauri, himself an Indian, has assured the Indian Government that the impact of these factors will now be studied in depth and reported upon in 2014.

Mr Brill added: “Major changes in the scientific world can hardly be ignored in the political world. The Caygill panel cannot form any authoritative view on whether the ETS is futile self-sacrifice, without considering the latest scientific advances. The present National-led government is wrong to eliminate in advance from the terms of the review any consideration of the many new questions of the now unsettled climate science, following the admissions by the IPCC of errors in its 2007 Assessment Review, and the revelations of fraudulently misleading climate claims in the leaked ‘Climategate’ emails.

“So we call on Minister Smith to justify his acceptance of what he terms ‘the science’ and to explain to New Zealanders in detail the science that he finds acceptable.

“Is it the science whose erroneous claim of the melting of Himalaya glaciers in a few years, was admitted by IPCC to be wrong?

“Is it the science of the University of East Anglia scientists in UK who conspired to thwart Freedom of Information Act requests for their data.

“Is it the science in which NIWA claims that its recent adjustment of its Seven Stations New Zealand temperature record received a positive peer-review by the Australian Bureau of Meteorology (BoM) and that BoM had concluded that ‘the results and underlying methodology used by NIWA were sound’; when in fact the BoM’s actual statement was ‘that evidence provided by NIWA generally supports (but does not prove) the corrections they made.’

“If this is the kind of science that Minister Smith finds acceptable, then it is time that Prime Minister John Key stepped in to restore the integrity of the Government he leads, and suggests that Minister Smith act more like a realist and less like a propagandist.

“The very least that the Prime Minister can now do is to widen the terms of the Caygill review panel to allow it to take into account changes in the science that have come to light since 2007”, Mr Brill concluded.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Our Local Responses To The Global Problems Of Inflation

In the United Kingdom, inflation is running at its highest rate in 30 years. In the US, inflation hit 7% during 2021. You wouldn’t want to be in Estonia, where inflation has just hit 12%. Across the Eurozone – the measurement methods vary – inflation is averaging out at 5%. In Canada, inflation is running at its highest level in 30 years. Inflation is not simply a problem afflicting developed countries. In a developing country like Brazil inflation is running at its highest level in seven years...


Government: Building And Shaping A City: Future-proofing Auckland Transport Infrastructure
The Government is bringing Auckland’s transport infrastructure into the future by moving forward with an additional Waitematā Harbour crossing, progressing light rail from Auckland’s CBD to the airport, and creating a linked-up rapid transport network as part of a 30-year plan... More>>

The Treasury: Financial Statements Of The Government Of NZ For The 5 Months Ended 30 November 2021
Interim Financial Statements of the Government of New Zealand for the 5 months ended 30 November 2021... More>>


Government: Announces Three Phase Public Health Response To Omicron
The Government has announced a three phase Omicron plan that aims to slow down and limit the spread of an outbreak, Associate Minister of Health, Dr Ayesha Verrall announced today. “Through the course of managing Omicron, we will be taking a phased approach. As case numbers grow both testing and isolation approaches will change in response... More>>

Ministry Of Transport: Have Your Say On The Future Of Road User Charges
Te Manatū Waka Ministry of Transport is inviting New Zealanders to submit their views on improving the Road User Charges system, says Secretary for Transport, Peter Mersi... More>>

TradeMe: New Zealand Rents Climb $40 Per Week In One Year

New Zealand’s national median rent climbed $40 a week in 2021 to reach $560 in December, according to Trade Me’s latest Rental Price Index. Trade Me Property Sales Director Gavin Lloyd said last month’s national median weekly rent showed an 8 per cent annual increase... More>>

Transparency International: New Zealand Retains Top Ranking In Annual Corruption Perceptions Index
New Zealand is once again ranked least corrupt in the world by Transparency International’s annual Corruption Perceptions Index. This year New Zealand’s score of 88 out of 100 is unchanged resulting in it being first equal with Denmark and Finland... More>>




InfoPages News Channels