Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Alan Haronga v Waitangi Tribunal and Others

19 May 2011

Alan Parekura Torohina Haronga v Waitangi Tribunal and Others (SC54/2010) [2011] NZSC 53

Click Here For Full Supreme Court Decision PDF of Haronga v Waitangi Tribunal and Others (SC54/2010) [2011] NZSC 53

This summary is provided to assist in the understanding of the Court’s judgment. It does not comprise part of the reasons for that judgment. The full judgment with reasons is the only authoritative document. The full text of the judgment and reasons can be found at www.courtsofnz.govt.nz.

The appellant, Mr Haronga, is the Chair of the Committee of Management of Mangatu Incorporation. The Incorporation, which today numbers 5,000 owners, was established in 1893 to represent hapū awarded the Mangatu No 1 block by the Native Land Court in 1881. In 1961, Mangatu Incorporation sold 8,626 acres of this land to the Crown. That land comprises almost a quarter of the Mangatu State Forest.

In 1992, claims were filed with the Waitangi Tribunal which contended that the Crown in acquiring the forest land had breached the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi and sought as redress the return of that land to Mangatu Incorporation for its proprietors. These claims were later amended and included in the Waitangi Tribunal’s district-wide Tūranga inquiry. The Tribunal, in its 2004 report, found the Crown’s acquisition in 1961 to be in breach of the Treaty.

However the Tribunal made no specific recommendations to the Crown as to remedy, notwithstanding its jurisdiction to make binding recommendations in respect of the licensed Crown forest land. The Tribunal suggested, rather, that all claimant iwi and hapū negotiate a single settlement for the whole Tūranga district and reserved leave to apply for further direction if necessary.

As negotiations between the Crown and claimants progressed, it became clear to Mr Haronga that the proposed settlement would not include specific redress to Mangatu Incorporation by way of return of the forest land to its owners.

Instead, the owners would share in the overall settlement which included the option to purchase the whole or part of the Mangatu forest, including the land sold in 1961. Accordingly, in July 2008, Mr Haronga filed a further claim to the Tribunal seeking the return of the 1961 land to Mangatu Incorporation and applied for an urgent hearing before negotiations reached a district-wide settlement, to be given effect by legislation.

His application for an urgent remedies hearing was twice declined by the Tribunal; by Judge Coxhead in August 2008 and by Judge Clark in October 2009. Mr Haronga then applied, unsuccessfully, for judicial review of the decision of Judge Clark in the High Court and Court of Appeal.

On further appeal, a majority of four judges of the Supreme Court (William Young J dissenting) has found that the Waitangi Tribunal is required to determine whether or not to make a binding recommendation for return of the forest land claimed by Mangatu Incorporation, having found the claim to be well-founded in its 2004 report.

The Tribunal’s statutory obligation of inquiry into every claim is not fully discharged by findings of Treaty breach. In such cases where the remedy sought is return of licensed Crown forest land, the inquiry must consider whether the land is to be returned and to which Māori or group of Māori. The Tribunal did not complete that inquiry, in respect of the forest land claimed, in its 2004 report.

If the appellant is to be heard on this matter, it is necessary that the Tribunal hear the claim with urgency. Under the proposed settlement with Te Whakarau, the owners of Mangatu Incorporation would suffer significant and irreversible prejudice as they will lose the right to adjudication of the claim.

The appeal is therefore allowed and the matter remitted to the Waitangi Tribunal with the direction that it proceed with urgency to complete its hearing of the claim.

Click Here For Full Supreme Court Decision PDF of Haronga v Waitangi Tribunal and Others (SC54/2010) [2011] NZSC 53


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Democracy 2.0: NextElection Partners With Scoop For Exciting Democracy Tech

NextElection, a technology platform empowering democracy and Government accountability, and Scoop Independent News have partnered to strengthen citizen participation in the 2020 New Zealand General Election, set for September 19th.

Scoop’s ambition for bringing NextElection to NZ is to use it to strengthen and expand Scoop Citizen activities under the auspices of the Scoop Foundation for Public Interest Journalism.

The nextelection.nz platform has been populated by the project team with channels for all the 2020 General Election candidates and political parties. It also features up to date geolocation data based on the latest electoral boundaries. More>> Joint Press Release: NextElection, Scoop.co.nz, ScoopCitizen


      Travel: Update On New Zealand And The Cook Islands Bubble

      The Prime Minister of New Zealand Jacinda Ardern and the Prime Minister of the Cook Islands Henry Puna have welcomed the completion of phase one in the establishment of a travel bubble between New Zealand and the Cook Island. More>>

      Election 2020: Labour Launch

      E ngā mana e ngā reo Ngāti whātua ngā mana whenua o Tāmaki Makaurau, e tika te kōrero Ehara taku toa he toa (taki tahi) he toa (taki tini) No rēira tātou e huihui mai nei, ka ‘Hoake tonu tātou’ Thank you for that welcome. And thank ... More>>

      Gordon Campbell: On Political Twins, And On Labour Extending Its Wage Subsidy Scheme

      A quick quiz for the weekend. Which political party currently represented in Parliament issued a press release yesterday that contained these stirring passages: “[We have] long supported a free trade and free movement area between Canada, Australia, New ... More>>


      Parliament Adjourns: Adjournment Debate: Speaker Trevor Mallard

      The 52 Parliament has sat for the last time before the September Election. It sat for 245 days... More>>


      E-Cigarettes: Vaping Legislation Passes

      Landmark legislation passed today puts New Zealand on track to saving thousands of lives and having a smokefree generation sooner rather than later, Associate Health Minister, Jenny Salesa says. The Smokefree Environments and Regulated Products (Vaping) ... More>>


      National: $4 Billion Investment To End Wellington’s Congestion Woes

      A National Government will invest another $4 billion in transport infrastructure across Wellington, igniting the economy and delivering the congestion-busting solutions the region has long been crying out for, National Party Leader Judith Collins says. ... More>>


      Covid-19: Poll On Management Approval

      New Zealanders’ overall trust in the Ministry of Health and Government to manage the COVID-19 pandemic is at 82%, down from 91% during April. Overall distrust that the Ministry and Government will manage it in ways which best protect themselves More>>

      Election 2020: National Releases 2020 Party List

      National’s 2020 Party List is a strong mix of experience coming up through our Caucus, and new and exciting talent joining our team from communities across New Zealand, Party President Peter Goodfellow says. “The National Party is incredibly ... More>>

      Horizon Research Limited: How Judith Collins Stopped The Bleeding

      Horizon Research includes questions on voting from time to time in its surveys – for both forthcoming referenda and general elections. More>>

      Your Vote 2020: Bringing Election Coverage To Viewers Across TVNZ Channels And Platforms

      As New Zealand gets ready to head to the ballot box this September, 1 NEWS is bringing voters comprehensive coverage and analysis of this year’s General Election. TVNZ’s coverage will draw on the depth of experience held across the 1 NEWS team, says Graeme ... More>>

      Economy: 30% Believe Households Worse Off, 298,000 Expect To Lose Jobs

      64% of New Zealanders feel the economic position of their households is the same or better than a year ago – and 30% think it is worse or much worse, while 298,000 think they will lose their jobs in the next 12 months. Households’ perceptions ... More>>

      State Services Commission: Findings Of Investigation Into COVID-19 Active Cases Privacy Breach

      Deputy State Services Commissioner Helene Quilter has today announced the findings of an investigation into a breach of privacy regarding sensitive personal information. The investigation looked into who or what caused the disclosure of the information, ... More>>

      International Security: New Zealand Suspends Extradition Treaty With Hong Kong

      The New Zealand Government has suspended its extradition treaty with Hong Kong and made a number of other changes in light of China’s decision to pass a national security law for Hong Kong, Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters says. More>>




      • POLITICS
      • REGIONAL


      InfoPages News Channels