Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Claytons Emissions Trading Scheme Will Cost New Zealand

Claytons Emissions Trading Scheme Will Cost New Zealand Tax Payers.
Media Release

Kyoto Forestry Association

September 22nd 2012

Proposed amendments to the Climate Change Response (Emissions Trading and Other Matters) Amendment Bill will do nothing to stop the flood of cheap international carbon credits into New Zealand.

Roger Dickie from the Kyoto Forestry Association says the Governments proposed amendments to the ETS Bill will result in New Zealand having a sham Emissions Trading Scheme that does nothing to encourage emissions reduction or improved environmental standards.

The National Government came into power endorsing the ETS as New Zealand's primary climate change response tool. To be seen to be internationally credible New Zealand needs to use this tool to transition to a lower emissions domestic economy.

Instead the Government proposes to rely on the very cheapest imported credits to offset our emissions. This does nothing to reduce our emissions. To make matters worse the government expects taxpayers to continue to subsidise emitters beyond 2012 by retaining the 2 for 1 subsidy said Mr Dickie.

No other emissions trading scheme in the world allows 100% "low quality" CER, ERU and RMU units into their Emissions Trading Scheme. Russia has announced that it may release more than 300 million tonne of the low quality ERUs into the world market, this has the potential to further reduce the price. (The New Zealand market is around 16 million tonne per annum).

Australia, China, USA, European Union, Japan and Korea either ban these low quality units or permit them in very limited numbers.

Because we have allowed unfettered entry of these cheap units into New Zealand, our carbon market has collapsed with prices now below $3.00.

Some two or three election cycles from now the New Zealand taxpayer will be forced to pay out $hundreds of millions of dollars to meet our international carbon liabilities thanks to the irresponsible "head in the sand" attitude proposed by the National government.

Because of this there has been a total loss of confidence in new forest planting, with a net deforestation of 18,600 ha in the 2011 year. This is completely contrary to the intentions of ETS.

Mr Dickie said when National came to power in 2007 they promised
to encourage the planting of 600,000 to 800,000 hectares of hill country
land that is prone to erosion and is not currently forested (see

Politicians from all political parties have regularly agreed that New Zealand needs 20,000 ha of new planting each year to meet our emissions targets and to counter the harvest of mature trees forecast to begin in the next six to eight years.

Mr Dickie said New Zealanders must be getting sick of politicians lying to the public just to secure votes. John Keys national government must be the most environmentally unfriendly government New Zealand has ever seen. They lied to the New Zealand public about their intentions to sequester carbon by planting forests and now they expect every New Zealand tax payer to subsidise our corporate emitters. Even their own Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment described their proposed changes to the ETS as a "farce"

Mr Dickie said there is zero interest from foresters and investors in new planting at these artificial low carbon prices subsidised by the New Zealand taxpayer.


KFA represents the more than 30,000 ordinary New Zealanders and forestry
companies who risked as much as $175 million per annum of their own
capital to invest in more than 250,000 hectares of new forestry in the
1990s, both because of the benefits predicted to arise from the sale of
wood products and for the carbon credits earned from carbon

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On How Women Are Suffering The Most From The Covid Economic Recession

Both here and abroad, the Covid-19 economic recession has been disastrous for women workers and their families. In November, young women below 30 in particular were feeling the consequences:

Of concern is the sustained deterioration in youth employment, particularly for females, with a -4.3% pa drop in filled jobs for females aged below 30, and a 3.9%pa drop for males aged below 30....More>>


A New Year: No politicians at Rātana in 2021

Annual celebrations at Rātana pā will be different this year, amid a decision to hold an internal hui for church adherents only… More>>


Covid: Border Exception for 1000 International Students

The Government has approved an exception class for 1000 international tertiary students, degree level and above, who began their study in New Zealand but were caught offshore when border restrictions began....More>>





InfoPages News Channels