Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
License needed for work use Register

Video | Business Headlines | Internet | Science | Scientific Ethics | Technology | Search


Otago Uni Genetics Lecture Outdated and Likely to Mislead

Otago University Genetics Lecture 'Outdated' and Likely to Mislead

The University of Otago is being challenged to put caveats on claims made in its Genetics lectures, that international consumer concern over Genetically Modified food can be ignored.

The lectures based on research over ten years, claim our overseas customers won't care about GE in our food exports, and that there is no risk to Brand New Zealand from Genetically Engineered foods. One study also shows nuclear power stations, and intensive feed-lots are fine for our Brand and international reputation.

However, the claims are based on research that with hindsight is clearly flawed. 

Work by a team led by Otago University Marketing lecturer Associate Professor John Knight, included running food stalls in different countries to test consumer acceptance of GE food, and interviewing first-time tourists on arrival in Auckland.

Much of the research was based on the assumption that a key consumer benefit would be that GE food will have fewer toxic chemical sprays than conventional crops. But data on chemical exposure are showing this to be the least likely outcome from GE foods over the past decade.

Another assumption was that consumer concerns for food safety were unfounded, and the result of media hype and scaremongering. The fact that Food Authorities had approved these foods as safe was taken as doctrine. Today scientists are warning of serious risks evidenced in peer-reviewed studies.

"These basic assumptions are now highly doubtful, which means the data is unreliable and could likely mislead decision-makers," says Jon Carapiet, spokesman for GE-Free NZ in food and environment.

Advertisement - scroll to continue reading

Are you getting our free newsletter?

Subscribe to Scoop’s 'The Catch Up' our free weekly newsletter sent to your inbox every Monday with stories from across our network.

"The rosy picture painted that consumers don't mind GE is based on incomplete knowledge on the part of the consumer to make a reasonable judgement."

The research is also totally blind to Brand marketing: promoting New Zealand products as GE-free and meeting the highest organic standards for purity in the world, both of which fit our values and clean green image.

"There is a need for successful Brands to be authentic and consistent in their positioning," says Jon Carapiet.

"What is the opportunity cost in not protecting and leveraging a GE-free brand positioning for food exports, and having the highest organic food standards in the world?"

The University of Otago should act responsibly by ensuring there are caveats around the claims being made in the latest lectures.

Decision-makers in government and industry would be wrong to believe from these lectures that Brand New Zealand can only gain, and has nothing to lose from 'going GE', instead of promoting GE-free and organic production, and using gene science ethically inside the lab.

Of course consumers overseas care about GE. Look at the battle for GE-labelling going on today in California, with Monsanto throwing in millions of dollars to oppose it.


© Scoop Media

Advertisement - scroll to continue reading
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

FMA: MAS To Pay $2.1M Penalty For Making False Representations

Following proceedings brought by the FMA, MAS has been ordered to pay a $2.1M penalty for making false and/or misleading representations to some customers. MAS admitted failing to correctly apply multi-policy discounts and no claims bonus discounts to some customers, failing to correctly apply inflation adjustments on some customer policies, and miscalculating benefit payments.More

IAG: Call On New Government To Prioritise Flood Resilience

The economic toll of our summer of storms continues to mount, with insurance payouts now topping $1B, second only to the Christchurch earthquakes. AMI, State, & NZI have released the latest Wild Weather Tracker, which reveals 51,000 claims for the North Island floods & Cyclone Gabrielle, of which 99% (motor), 97% (contents), and 93% (home) of claims have now been settled. More


Join Our Free Newsletter

Subscribe to Scoop’s 'The Catch Up' our free weekly newsletter sent to your inbox every Monday with stories from across our network.