Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
License needed for work use Register



Cablegate: "Alternative Armenian Conference" Goes Forward

This record is a partial extract of the original cable. The full text of the original cable is not available.





E.O. 12958: N/A


B. ANKARA 4951
C. ANKARA 3032

1. (U) Summary: The "Alternative Armenian
Conference" (on Armenians in the late Ottoman
Empire) unfolded without incident on September 24 and 25
at a campus of its third organizer, Bilgi University,
less than 48 hours after an Istanbul court had attempted
to block it. Foreign Minister Gul, who, along with PM
Erdogan, had earlier condemned the court's intervention,
saluted the initiative and expressed hope it would contribute
to improving relations with Armenia. It was a victory of
courage and persistence for conference organizers and
presenters; the government,s reaction is without precedent.
Widely covered in the press, the conference attracted only
scattered protests, although some participants were
splattered with tomatoes and eggs. Still to be seen is the
reaction of the Turkish legal system, which in the past has
sought to prosecute those who dared to question Turkish
orthodoxy on the events of 1915. End Summary.

2. (SBU) With GOT encouragement and support, three
Istanbul universities faced down a court order and
nationalist protesters to hold their twice-postponed
"Alternative Armenian" conference at an "alternative"
location. Following Justice Minister Cicek's suggestion,
conference organizers quickly moved the event to Bilgi
University, the third co-organizer, unnamed in the court
injunction (ref A) and opened there on September 23. The
original three-day program was condensed into two. More than
300 participants stayed for close to 12 hours on both
Saturday and Sunday to hear panel after panel of historians,
sociologists and journalists -- more than 40 in total --
challenge the traditional Turkish narrative about the mass
killings and forced deportation of ethnic Armenians in

Advertisement - scroll to continue reading

Are you getting our free newsletter?

Subscribe to Scoop’s 'The Catch Up' our free weekly newsletter sent to your inbox every Monday with stories from across our network.

3. (U) Presenters covered topics ranging from academic
issues (inadequate archival information, biased
interpretations, and politicization of the issue), to
historical facts (the relationship between societies in the
Ottoman Empire, tales of escape, witness reports) and present
day implications, including the "historical-psychological
suffocation of Turkish public opinion on the Armenian
problem." While the "G Word" -- a term the presenters,
themselves used in English -- was uttered on more than one
occasion, participants were at pains to explain that the
conference's aim was not to decide whether or not genocide
had been committed, but to freely air academic views on a
heretofore taboo subject.

A Milestone

4. (U) There was an air of nervous excitement and a sense
that history was being made inside the conference grounds
Saturday morning, as registrars carefully checked for
invitations and identity documents. Even academics who had
earlier expressed skepticism, saying the event had "lost its
academic value," acknowledged that the mere fact they were
holding it marked an important mi\estone. Several
participants praised Bilgi University for stepping in at the
last minute.

5. (SBU) Conference organizing committee member Edhem Eldem
was modest in his characterization of the event, saying that
it was perhaps "a little naive" to think the conference would
change things at a national level. For his part,
controversial Turkish scholar Halil Berktay saw the event as
immensely important and told poloff that the conference was
no longer about history, but about democracy and the role of
civil society in Turkey. Hrant Dink, publisher of Turkey's
only Armenian-language newspaper, Agos, thought another major
benefit of the conference could be to soften the Armenian
diaspora's hard attitudes.

View on GOT Reaction: Thumbs Up

6. (U) Several conference participants expressed to us
satisfaction with the government response to Thursday's
cancellation notice (ref A). In addition to the Prime
Minister and Foreign Minister's comments condemning the
conference's postponement, even Turkey's Higher Education
Board (YOK), often a source of controversy itself, received
points from this academic community for its statement
criticizing the court's intervention. Participants also
expressed appreciation for the tone of the messag&*from
Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul, delivered at the opening of
the conference by Bogazici University Rector Ayse Soysal.

7. (U) In his greeting, Gul pledged Turkey would continue
work in modernizing its archives, and said that a deeper
examination of history would contribute to improved relations
between governments and peoples. He pointed to Turkey and
Armenia's 1000 years of shared history, during which the two
societies contributed to each other's culture, prosperity and
security. He claimed that
tolerance toward Armenians in Turkish society "constitutes a
major advantage for the future of relations between the two
peoples." He lamented that many historical studies about
that "tragic period" were subjective and politicized, and
stressed that society must learn what happened and draw
lessons from the facts. He added that he hoped the
"alternative" conference would constitute a contribution to
awareness-raising. (Complete text of Gul remarks e-mailed to

More on Content

8. (U) After opening remarks by the rectors of Bogazici,
Sabanci and Bilgi universities, the first panel comprised
presenters whom one observer called "the most hated by the
nationalists" (Murat Belge, Halil Berktay and Selim
Deringil). Composed but tense, they kicked off the event,
and had visually relaxed by the Q and A session. Throughout
the day, while not shying away from provocative language
about historical facts, presenters focused on the importance
of breaking taboos and confronting denial. Fikret Adanir, a
Turkish historian who has for years challenged Turkish
orthodoxy on the events of 1915, instead of striking a
controversial tone, noted that the most important thing was
for the government to brin'about conditions to allow
everyone to examine all available information for themselves
and make up their Nn minds. This remark brought the
greatest applause of the day on Saturday. Day two,s
presentations took oa "therapy s!ssion" character at times,
with one presenter 4ting that t(Y Qmenian and TMQish
people needed two clinics: one for trauma and one
for paranoia.

9. (U) Throughout the weekend there were lamentations about
diversity lost forever and "defense mechanisms" used by Turks
when discussing thE$topic. TheQighlight of Sunday, however,
was an emotional presentation by Hrant Dink, who moved many
in he audience to tears. Dink, who already has two cases
opened against him in Istanbul courts for "insulting the
state," used the expression "I am a person from Turkey,"
rather than a Turk, to descriwe himself anDexplained whyuArmenians feel
attached to the land here - they want, he
said, to be buried where they camQ from. Many drew parallels
between the "Armenian problem" and the currently Kurdish
pr-Qlem, with warnings about the danger of the mass
mobilization of hate.

10. (U) Most questions posed to the panelists were respectful
an in the spirit of an academic onference. Examples
include, "Why did many Armenians run to Syria, still part of
the Ottoman Empire, if the empire were so evil?" and "Did
researchers have any exact number of fully emptied villageQC
around Ankara that had been referenced?" And from a
U.S.-based Turkish scholar, "Why didn,t the conference
organizers invite independent,academic voice+`from the
Armenian diaspora?"

Lonely disenters, outnumbered protesters

11. (SBU) A few participants did attempt to interrupt
speakers and provoke a reaction. One such interjector
apparently came from the ranks of the nationalist Turkish
Forum group, which includes several retired generals. In
another instance, one Marmara University professor engaged in
a loud exchange with several participants. The incident
ended quickly, and the professor reportedly decided to leave
the conference, but not before cameras had captured a heated
discussion between him and presenter Halil Berktay. (Note:
Some academics at the conference told us they wished Berktay
would not be so provocative; it made them uncomfortable. End

12. (U) Promised protests were limited, causing
anti-conference commentators on a Kanal B television program
Sunday night to appear perplexed as to why so few in a city
of 15 million had come out to express their outrage. On
Saturday morning, some 250-300 Workers Party members
demonstrated, chanting slogans against, among other things,
philanthropist George Soros, who contributes to Bilgi
University. (Bilgi organizers reportedly took out 300
sandwiches to offer the protesters, which they refused.) In
the afternoon, a demonstration by members of the Nationalist
People's Party (MHP) was quickly dispersed and, by the time
participants exited in the afternoon, just a small group of
protesters lingered. Despite their relatively small numbers,
however, protesters did inflict some damage, as they showered
attendees, including former Deputy Prime Minister Erdal
Inonu, with eggs and rotten tomatoes. Inonu nevertheless
made a dignified exit on foot, refusing to accept police
offers of a taxi and instead facing down the demonstrators.

13 (SBU) Comment: It is a tribute to the courage and
persistence of this conference,s organizers and presenters
that it finally got off the ground. The government deserves
plaudits for its defense of the conference,s right to
proceed this time around.

14. (SBU) Comment, continued: This conference represents a
milestone for academic freedom in Turkey. It remains to be
seen if it represents a milestone in freedom of expression as
well, as it is not out of the question that a prosecutor
could open a case against one or more participants for their
remarks to the conference. (The conference was filmed in its
entirety by several news agencies, so there will be no
question about what was actually said.) But, this conference
is only the most recent example showing that social change is
afoot and more open public debate on the rise. End comment.

© Scoop Media

Advertisement - scroll to continue reading
World Headlines

UN News: Aid Access Is Key Priority

Among the key issues facing diplomats is securing the release of a reported 199 Israeli hostages, seized during the Hamas raid. “History is watching,” says Emergency Relief Coordinator Martin Griffiths. “This war was started by taking those hostages. Of course, there's a history between Palestinian people and the Israeli people, and I'm not denying any of that. But that act alone lit a fire, which can only be put out with the release of those hostages.” More

Save The Children: Four Earthquakes In a Week Leave Thousands Homeless

Families in western Afghanistan are reeling after a fourth earthquake hit Herat Province, crumbling buildings and forcing people to flee once again, with thousands now living in tents exposed to fierce winds and dust storms. The latest 6.3 magnitude earthquake hit 30 km outside of Herat on Sunday, shattering communities still reeling from strong and shallow aftershocks. More

UN News: Nowhere To Go In Gaza

UN Spokesperson Stéphane Dujarric said some 1.1M people would be expected to leave northern Gaza and that such a movement would be “impossible” without devastating humanitarian consequences and appeals for the order to be rescinded. The WHO joined the call for Israel to rescind the relocation order, which amounted to a “death sentence” for many. More

Access Now: Telecom Blackout In Gaza An Attack On Human Rights

By October 10, reports indicated that fixed-line internet, mobile data, SMS, telephone, and TV networks are all seriously compromised. With significant and increasing damage to the electrical grid, orders by the Israeli Ministry of Energy to stop supplying electricity and the last remaining power station now out of fuel, many are no longer able to charge devices that are essential to communicate and access information. More


Join Our Free Newsletter

Subscribe to Scoop’s 'The Catch Up' our free weekly newsletter sent to your inbox every Monday with stories from across our network.