Cablegate: Media Reaction Report - Middle East - G8 Summit

null
Lucia A Keegan 07/18/2006 03:08:55 PM From DB/Inbox: Lucia A Keegan

Cable
Text:

UNCLAS PARIS 04825

SIPDIS
cxparis:
ACTION: PAO
INFO: AMB ARS DCM POL

DISSEMINATION: PAOX
CHARGE: PROG

APPROVED: PRS: LPLATT
DRAFTED: PR: SDOSSANTOS
CLEARED: NONE

VZCZCFRI778
OO RUEHC RUEAIIA RUEATRS RHEFDIA RUEKJCS RHEHAAA
RUCPDOC RUEHRL RUEHRO RUEHMO RUEHNO RUEHVEN RHMFIUU
DE RUEHFR #4825/01 1981035
ZNR UUUUU ZZH
O 171035Z JUL 06
FM AMEMBASSY PARIS
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC IMMEDIATE 9524
INFO RUEAIIA/CIA WASHINGTON DC
RUEATRS/DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY WASHDC
RHEFDIA/DIA WASHINGTON DC//ASD/ISA//
RUEKJCS/SECDEF WASHINGTON DC
RHEHAAA/WHITE HOUSE WASHDC
RUCPDOC/USDOC WASHDC
RUEHRL/AMEMBASSY BERLIN 6207
RUEHRO/AMEMBASSY ROME 7814
RUEHMO/AMEMBASSY MOSCOW 5471
RUEHNO/USMISSION USNATO 3528
RUEHVEN/USMISSION USOSCE 3078
RHMFIUU/COMSIXTHFLT

UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 03 PARIS 004825

SIPDIS

DEPT FOR INR/R/MR; IIP/RW; IIP/RNY; BBG/VOA; IIP/WEU;
AF/PA; EUR/WE /P/SP; D/C (MCCOO); EUR/PA; INR/P; INR/EUC;
PM; OSC ISA FOR ILN; NEA; WHITE HOUSE FOR NSC/WEUROPE; DOC FOR
ITA/EUR/FR AND PASS USTR/PA; USINCEUR FOR PAO; NATO/PA; MOSCOW/PA;
ROME/PA.

E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: OPRC KMDR FR

SUBJECT: MEDIA REACTION REPORT - Middle East - G8 Summit

PARIS - Monday, July 17, 2006

(A) SUBJECTS COVERED IN TODAY'S REPORT:

Middle East
G8 Summit

(B) SUMMARY OF COVERAGE:

Although Lebanon leads all of the print and electronic top stories
and commentaries, the G8 meeting in Saint Petersburg is the second,
and related, item.

Right-of-center Sunday newspaper Le Journal du Dimanche asks: "Who
wants Lebanon's death?" The editorial by Jacques Esperandieu laments
that the international community worries over the "disproportionate"
Israeli riposte instead of focusing on the fact that the "Middle
East is on the edge of chaos." Right-of-center Le Figaro's editorial
condemns the West for being more preoccupied with getting its
citizens out of Lebanon than with trying to find a solution to end
the conflict. The statement issued by the G8 members on the
Israeli-Lebanese conflict is seen as "harsh in form and vague in
content" by regional editorialist Jean-Claude Kiefer. (See Part C)

Left-of-center Le Monde carries an op-ed entitled "Defending the
G8." (See Part C)

Right-of-center Le Figaro reports that bilateral meetings between
the U.S. and Russia made it possible to come to an agreement
concerning the reprocessing of spent nuclear fuel. "The two great
Cold War superpowers opened the ball at the G8 with a bilateral
meeting which gave a flavor of G2 +6 to the rest of the Summit."

Right-of-center Le Figaro reports that the UN is condemning North
Korea "After eleven days of equivocation... A compromise was found
between Washington's hard line approach and the moderation advocated
by China and Russia."

In left-of-center Le Monde, Washington correspondent Corine Lesnes
writes discusses the "Condistas," those Republicans who believe that
Secretary of State Rice has a chance at the nomination to be the

SIPDIS
Party's Presidential candidate in 2008. "The Secretary tirelessly
repeats that she is not a candidate... but for the Republicans she
is the symbol of redemption... and even if she has not made any
major breakthroughs on the Iranian or North Korean nuclear issues,
she has succeeded in terms of her image. According to a Washington
Post poll, she is the most popular person in the Bush Administration
in front of the President himself by 20 points... As Secretary of
State she finds favor in the eyes of moderate Democrats... In 17
months she has spearheaded an impressive transformation of American
diplomacy. Washington has given more to its allies or adversaries
than it has ever done before. India was assured of a nuclear
cooperation that it had been seeking for over thirty years... Iran
has been lured by the promise of direct talks... Contrary to her
predecessor Colin Powell... she has the President's ear... When she
left the White House she took a certain number of advisors with her
including Jim Wilkinson... who has set up a media campaign to boost
her image... which surprisingly has been unaffected by the failure
in Iraq."

(C) SUPPORTING TEXT/BLOCK QUOTES:

Middle East

"Urgency"
The editorial by Jacques Esperandieu in right-of-center Sunday paper
Le Journal du Dimanche (07/16): "There are plenty of good reasons to
mobilize the international community to react faced with the
situation in the Middle East and yet division and inefficiency
prevail. Without surprise, the U.S. is saying that Israel has the
right to defend itself. Most Europeans, including France tends to
see the scope of Israeli retaliation as disproportionate... The UN
meets but decides nothing... Yet there is an urgency to act. Iraq is
in the throes of a full-scale civil war, Iran is continuing its
crusade toward acquiring the bomb and the region as a whole is on
the verge of explosion."
"Irresponsibility"
Left-of-center Le Monde's unsigned editorial notes that (07/16/17):
"The international community seems to be more powerless than ever.
It is paying the price for years of indifference and passivity with
regard to the deterioration of the Israeli Palestinian conflict...
In the Middle East the Bush Administration has invented a sort of
empty shell called the Quartet that is supposed to provide a
framework for negotiations... and whose aim it is to pretend to
favor a dialogue between Israeli and Palestinians. The Quartet
serves no purpose whatsoever. Who even knows when it met for the
last time? All of its members have chosen to remain powerless for
various reasons. Since George Bush took office, the U.S. abandoned
its role as the 'honest broker' sticking to Israel's position no
matter what that may be. Russia has no particular strategy, except
to be a thorn in America's side. Europeans have a hard time being
heard since politically they do not exist. And as we saw in last
Friday's pathetic demonstration at the Security Council, the UN is
impotent and a reflection of the unwillingness of the rest of the
world."

"G8 - Out of the Game"
Gerard Dupuy comments in left-of-center Liberation (07/17): "The G8
leaders, the crhme de la crhme of world power, seems to have latched
on to the conflict between Israel and Lebanon only to demonstrate,
once again, its total incapacity to act in a vaguely effective way
in this region... through the conflict with Israel, Hezbollah is
seeking to destabilize the West that aside from sending life rafts
to its citizens and approving Israel's retaliation while condemning
its harshness, shows the extent to which it is out of the game in
the Middle East."

"Getting Involved"
Francois Ernewein in Catholic La Croix (07/17): "In the last few
days what ambitious proposals has the international community made
to promote peace? No need to rack your brain, there are none. The
key to the international community's powerlessness lies in the
age-old acceptance of the situation in the Middle East... This
disorganized diplomacy has only served to give legitimacy to the
various parties in their headlong rush towards violence... instead
of telling them once and for all 'enough!'"

"Powerless"
The editorial by Francois-Xavier Pietri in centrist economic La
Tribune (07/17): "We were expecting a G8 that would focus on energy
security, but instead it has focused on security in the Middle East
and the possible consequences on Western economies... The 80 dollar
barrel is just a heartbeat away... And world diplomacy seems
completely at a loss... the great powers of the G8 are in fact
powerless and the Summit appears to be a forum for settling old
scores between Russia, the U.S. and Europe... rather than coming to
the aid of staggering Arab diplomacy."

"Too Powerful"
For Jean-Pierre Bel in regional daily La Nouvelle Republique du
Centre (07/17): "The G8 is not powerless, it is too powerful. It has
become a symbol of an excess of power that destabilizes the world.
The members of the club of 8 are too entangled in protecting their
own national interests to be able to act rapidly and decisively in
the Middle East."

"Lebanon : The Wager of Weapons"
Pierre Rousselin editorializes in right-of-center Le Figaro (07/17):
"The evacuation of the citizens of the Western countries is intended
as a way to empty Lebanon of all of the potential hostages that
pro-Iranian Hezbollah could be tempted to take when things,
inevitably, get worse... But we must be careful. If the evacuation
of our citizens does not go hand-in-hand with a diplomatic
initiative, the Lebanese people will see it as the West's abandoning
them... The U.S., without whom nothing can be accomplished in the
region, have yet to send a high-ranking envoy."

G8 Summit

"Defending the Idea of the G8"
Eric Le Boucher writes in left-of-center Le Monde (07/16-17): "The
G8 has a bad image mainly because it is seen at once as being too
big and too small, incapable of resolving the global crises of
today. Bad because the final statement, prepared in advance by the
Sherpas... is the archetype of stonewalling... Do these types of
Summits still serve a purpose? If one looks at the four priorities
set out by President Chirac in Les Echos on July 13 the question
appears particularly relevant. Discussing energy policy without any
of the Gulf countries present and when President Putin himself is
one of the principal troublemakers seems absurd. And what of the
Kyoto Protocol that the U.S. did not ratify and that no country
respects? How can global warming be discussed when big CO2 producers
such as China and India are absent? Africa? No leader from the
continent is present. Iran? This may be the only topic that will be
usefully discussed... Reforming existing informal (G8) or formal
(UN, IMF, WTO...) international fora is urgent. In this context the
idea of the G8 is good... multilateralism may not look like a
French-style garden, but so what as long as it continues to bear
fruit." STAPLETON

© Scoop Media