Cablegate: Refugee Returns: Missed Benchmarks but Continued

DE RUEHVB #0707/01 2811451
R 071451Z OCT 08




E.O. 12958: N/A


1. (U) SUMMARY: In a September 17 meeting with ambassadorial-level
representatives of the international community (IC), the Minister of
Regional Development, Forestry and Water Management, Petar
Cobankovic, renewed the GOC's commitment to complete the process of
resettling former occupancy/tenancy right holders(OTRs- Serb
refugees who had been tenants in state owned properties before the
war). Cobankovic presented the GOC's 2009 benchmark of 2462 housing
units, which will bring the process or resettlement close to
completion. He acknowledged, however, that the GOC, in consultation
with a small number of affected returnees, would meet the 2007
benchmark target only in the Spring of 2009. Similarly, because of
slow construction during the winter season, a small number of the
housing units targeted for 2008 would slip into 2009. The presence
of high-level officials from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and
Croatia's EU accession negotiation team at the meeting underlined
the strong link between Croatia's performance on returns and its
progress toward the EU. Other topics of discussion included the
shape of the government's new appeals body for rejected
applications, regional discrepancies in application decisions, and
progress made towards convalidation of working time during the war.

2007 Benchmark: Delayed Completion Threatens Chapter 23 Negotiations


2. (U) In the meeting between ambassadorial-level representatives of
the European Commission, UNHCR, U.S. Embassy, the Zagreb based
office of the OSCE, and senior level GOC officials, Minister
Cobankovic acknowledged that delivery of the 1400 housing units
allocated to OTRs as part of the GOC's 2007 benchmark would likely
not be complete until May, 2009. The approach of winter, and other
factors, meant that needed construction activities in two apartment
blocks in rural areas would be hard to complete before then.
Completion of this benchmark is one of the prerequisites for opening
Chapter 23 EU accession negotiations (Judiciary and Human Rights).
The GOC says it will have the majority of outstanding units ready by
the end of 2008, but estimates that it will fall short of the total
by 10 housing units. Cobankovic maintained that the affected
families preferred to accept late delivery, rather then be moved
over the winter. In the meantime, GOC agreed to pay the rent of an
estimated 51 families until their housing units are delivered. The
senior members of the IC welcomed this interim measure but stressed
that this measure is only palliative and rent payments could not be
considered a permanent solution. The IC stressed that any delays in
delivering the units beyond May 2009 would be unacceptable. (NOTE:
The GOC keeps separate lists of beneficiaries for the 2007 and 2008
benchmarks. The process of fulfilling these benchmarks is done in
parallel and not on a 'first come, first served' basis. This creates
a dichotomy wherein the GOC has allocated approximately 600
apartments for its 2008 benchmark even though it has not yet
completed its 2007 target. Were the 2008 benchmark apartments to be
counted towards the 2007 benchmark, the 2007 benchmark would have
been met some time ago. END NOTE).

3. (SBU) Croatia's chief negotiator for EU Accession, Ambassador
Vladimir Drobnjak, asked the IC representatives, in particular EC
Delegation Head Degert, whether EU would consider the current status
adequate to verify that Croatia had met the required "opening
benchmark" for the purposes of beginning Chapter 23 negotiations
with the EU. Degert said he could not answer the question, as that
decision has to be made by member state representatives in the EU
Council. Failure to make further progress would potentially delay
any such decision. Drobnjak said that if the EU did not consider
the opening benchmark met then the GOC would continue construction,
and move the affected families, despite poor conditions, in order to
meet the benchmark. (NOTE: At a private lunch last week, the head of
UNHCR Croatia, Wilfried Buchhorn, told POLCOUNS that has UNHCR
recommended to the EC that the 2007 benchmark be considered met,
given the number of 2008 allocations already made. END NOTE).

4. (U) The GoC also noted that 68 families who have been allocated
some of the 400 units within Areas of Special State Concern
(essentially, the territory held by rebel Serbs during the war) have
yet to retrieve the keys for their units. The GOC agreed to work
with OSCE and UNHCR to try and locate these families within a month
and determine whether the families still intend to move into their

ZAGREB 00000707 002 OF 003

units. Units that are no longer desired will be reallocated to other
families awaiting housing.

2008 Benchmark: Progress But No Completion Until 2009

5. (U) In parallel with the 2007 benchmark process, the GOC said it
has also allocated approximately 40 percent of the 1400 housing
units promised as part of its 2008 benchmark. GOC acknowledged that
it would not complete all 1400 units in this benchmark by the end of
2008, but foresees completion no later then June 2009. Members of
the IC expressed special concern for the lack of progress in the
areas outside the ASSC. Cobankovic stated that progress was slow due
in large part to the high price of real estate in coastal and urban
areas, such as Dubrovnik or Split. The government's current price
cap per square meter for apartment space is far below the market
prices for real estate in costal areas. (NOTE: Interestingly, the
same problem does not exist in Zagreb, where the government reports
it has a more than sufficient number of units available. END NOTE).
The government is seeking to amend the ordinance regulating real
estate transactions to increase the amount they are able to pay.
The state secretary for the Ministry of Physical Planning, Zoning
and Construction, Alexsandar Russo, stated that they would soon open
tender for properties to purchase in these areas. Should no offers
be received, the government will consider buying land and building
apartments itself.

Appeals: The New Appellate System, and Regional Bias in the Initial

6. (U) The government has recently sent 1400 negative decisions to
housing care applicants. Recipients have 15 days to appeal this
decision, and as of mid-September approximately 80 appeals have been
received. The government's new appellate body (REF A) has not yet
begun to review these cases. The State Secretary for Regional
Development, Forest and Water Management, Milivoj Mikulic, explained
that the new body would consist of two lawyers and another worker
from the Department for the Areas of Special State Concern. The
director of this office would verify the decision of these three.
If the original refusal is confirmed, further appeal is possible
through the use of the court system. The GOC hopes to complete all
administrative appeals by the end of October in order to include any
overturned refusals in the 2009 benchmark. The IC encouraged the
progress the GOC has made in administratively resolving applications
and called for a transparent and fair appeals process.

7. (U) In previous meetings (REF B) the GOC agreed to partake in a
joint review with UNHCR of all negative decision cases made outside
the ASSC, before these rejections were sent to the applicants.
UNHCR reviewed roughly 500 of these 850 cases and of these, 40
percent were sent back by UNHCR for further review to the original
decision making bodies. UNHCR noted that there was a lack of
consistency in the decisions of regional offices and the bulk of the
40 percent were concentrated in a few jurisdictions. The GoC's
Zagreb office was particularly problematic, and many negative
decisions appeared to be unfounded. The GOC acknowledged that the
majority of negative decisions in Zagreb can be attributed to one
official, but due to local labor law their options to resolve this
problem are limited. As a temporary solution, other regional
offices have begun to review Zagreb's decisions. The IC reps
pointed out that this problem further delays the government's
progress towards its 2008 benchmark and encouraged the government to
review the situation and find a permanent solution.

2009 Benchmark: Unrealistic Goals?

8. (U) Minister Cobankovic also presented a revised benchmark goal
of 2462 housing units to be allocated in 2009. This number took
into consideration an estimation of positive decisions to be made in
cases not yet administered and in cases currently awaiting appeal,
and would effectively bring the process of resettlement of OTRs to a
close. Cobankovic estimated that this goal could be met by the
spring of 2010. Though this target has been reduced from previous
estimates, the IC still expressed concern that this goal might be
unrealistic given the government's inability to reach even the lower
targets from 2007 or 2008. The IC stressed that further slippage in

ZAGREB 00000707 003 OF 003

meeting declared targets only damaged Croatia's credibility,
especially as regards Croatia's EU accession negotiations, and urged
the GOC to make realistic estimates.

9. (U) Cobankovic replied that he understood why there were low
expectations, but insisted that progress on the 2009 benchmark would
be faster then previous years. Changes in the government and new
laws affecting refugee returns slowed progress during 2008, but with
the adjustment phase past, Cobankovic appeared optimistic.
Cobankovic did agree to review the benchmark and called for a
meeting at the beginning of October with the IC to review the
government's 2009 construction plan.


10. (U) In May 2008 the GOC implemented a new ordinance allowing for
the convalidation of pensions and the crediting of service in the
former Serb Occupied areas to pensioners. The GOC presented the
first statistics regarding the implementation of said ordinance at
the meeting. To date they have received 3223 applications for
convalidation of working years. 82 of these cases have been
resolved. 37 of the 82 cases received positive decisions and 45
received negative decisions. In regard to pensions the government
has received 173 requests and has resolved 129 of these cases. All
129 received positive decisions. The IC encouraged the progress the
GOC has made in this regard and asked to receive regular statistical
reports regarding this issue.


11. (SBU) The bureaucracy of this entire process threatens to
obscure the real picture. While a number of cases (in the low three
digits) remain from the 1400 units allocated under the 2007, the GoC
at the same time has resolved more than that number from its 2008
caseload. The EU's decision, expected prior to the issuance of the
annual Progress Report due in early November, will therefore be a
political one as to whether the GoC has demonstrated adequate
performance on returns. The commitment on the government's part to
pay rent for 2007 benchmark applicants who do not yet have their
homes, and the presence of senior MFA officials at working level and
principal level meetings indicate that the GOC understands the
importance and urgency of resolving this issue in as timely a manner
as possible. In our view, the government is committed to resolving
this issue, albeit not as quickly as their overly ambitious declared
targets claim. As Croatia moves further into EU accession
negotiations the pace for resolving refugee return issues will
likely quicken, but it appears this is an issue Croatia will
continue to be working on into 2010 and probably beyond. END


© Scoop Media

World Headlines


WMO: Another La Niña Impacts Temperatures And Precipitation – But Not Climate Change
La Niña has developed for the second consecutive year and is expected to last into early 2022, influencing temperatures and precipitation. Despite the cooling influence of this naturally occurring climate phenomenon, temperatures in many parts of the world are expected to be above average because of the accumulated heat trapped in the atmosphere...

UN: Violations Of Palestinian Rights Puts Two-State Solution At Risk, Chief Warns
The situation in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, continues to pose a significant challenge to international peace and security, United Nations Secretary-General, António Guterres, said on Monday... More>>

Oxfam: Afghanistan Faces Multiple Crises

ActionStation, Amnesty International Aotearoa New Zealand, Christian World Service, Oxfam Aotearoa and World Vision New Zealand say that while Afghanistan faces chronic poverty, persistent droughts, war, the Covid-19 pandemic and an economic crisis, winter is about to bring a whole new set of challenges...More>>

World Food Programme: Millions More In Need Of Food Assistance As A Direct Result Of Conflict In Northern Ethiopia

The number of people in need of humanitarian food assistance across northern Ethiopia has grown to an estimated 9.4 million as a direct result of ongoing conflict, the United Nations World Food Programme (WFP) announced today... More>>

Food: Three Billion People Cannot Afford A Healthy Diet

Approximately three billion people, almost 40 per cent of the world’s population, cannot afford a healthy diet and another one billion people would join their ranks should further unpredictable events reduce incomes by one-third, the UN food agency said, launching a new report on Tuesday... More>>

COP26: Enough Of ‘Treating Nature Like A Toilet’ – Guterres Brings Stark Call For Climate Action To Glasgow
As the World Leaders Summit opened on day two of COP26, UN chief António Guterres sent a stark message to the international community. “We are digging our own graves”, he said, referring to the addiction to fossil fuels which threatens to push humanity and the planet, to the brink, through unsustainable global heating... More>>