News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search

 

Application For Discharge Of Suppression Order

Judgment On Application For Discharge Of Suppression Order

Media Statement

8 FEBRUARY 2000


OTAHUHU DISTRICT COURT


JUDGMENT ON APPLICATION FOR DISCHARGE OF SUPPRESSION ORDER

In the Otahuhu District Court today Judge Harvey has said he has no jurisdiction to grant the application by Wilson and Horton to discharge the suppression order in respect of a visiting American businessman made on 7 January 2000.

Judge Harvey said he was therefore unable to consider whether the application should be granted, or whether he should grant the application by Ms Dyhberg, counsel for the businessman (described in the judgment as “Mr L”), for a stay of the application by Wilson and Horton.

Judge Harvey said while there are important private and public issues that arise within the context of this case his function is to decide the matter according to law.

He also said his decision to decline jurisdiction is one that he reached according to law and not from any reluctance to revisit his earlier decision.

Judge Harvey said the Court cannot assume jurisdiction where none is clearly provided.

He said the District Court only has jurisdiction where the legislature says it does, unlike the High Court, which has inherent jurisdiction.

Judge Harvey said there is no statutory authority as far as orders for suppression of name are concerned whereby a Judge may, after making a final order for suppression of name under s. 140 of the Criminal Justice Act, revisit or reconsider such an order, other than in circumstances such as when the order could be described as a nullity.

“There is no suggestion in this case that the order made on 7 January 2000 was a nullity.”

Judge Harvey said if the legislature had intended that a Judge could subsequently vary or discharge a final order it would have said so.

He contrasted this situation with that of an interim order, which can be revisited by the Judge.

“Even in the High Court, with its inherent jurisdiction, final orders would not be set aside lightly.”

Judge Harvey said in the absence of any specific statutorily prescribed jurisdiction or any inherent jurisdiction there is the difficulty of overcoming the concept of “functus officio”.

The Judge quoted the authority of Police v. Gilchrist, which said this concept means that once a Judge has completed his role that is the end of the matter and the Judge has no power to later revisit or reopen the matter.

“The concept of finality is reinforced by the existence of remedies by way of appeal, rehearing and judicial review. It would be improper for a District Court to assume a jurisdiction in circumstances where it is not clear that provision for one has been made.”

Judge Harvey said he concluded therefore that a District Court Judge does not have the jurisdiction to discharge or review a final suppression order that has been made pursuant to s. 140 of the Criminal Justice Act 1985.

Ends

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines

 


Howard Davis Review: Tarantino's Pitch-Perfect Once Upon a Time … in Hollywood

Welcome back to the violent and misogynistic, yet always entertaining world of Quentin Tarantino, who this time around focuses his dyspeptic lens on Tinseltown's pimply backside. More>>


Westpac Exiting Cake Tin: Stadium Announces Naming Rights Agreement With Sky

Wellington Regional Stadium Trust (WRST) and Sky Network Television Ltd (Sky) have announced a new partnership that will see Sky secure the naming rights of the Stadium from 1 January 2020. More>>

ALSO:

ASB Classic: Serena Williams Confirmed For 2020

One of the biggest names in sport has confirmed she will be returning to the ASB Classic in 2020. Twenty-three time Grand Slam singles champion Serena Williams will return to Auckland’s ASB Tennis Arena to challenge for the ASB Classic title. More>>


Netball: Taurua To Coach Silver Ferns Through Two More Campaigns

Netball New Zealand has confirmed Taurua will guide the Silver Ferns as they take on the Australian Diamonds in October’s Cadbury Netball Series (Constellation Cup), along with the Northern Quad Series in late January. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • CULTURE
  • HEALTH
  • EDUCATION
 
 
  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland