Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


Marc Ash: Man Down

Man Down

By Marc Ash
t r u t h o u t | Perspective

Tuesday 11 May 2004

I write this at the beginning of May 2004.

Now, more than four hundred days have passed since the decision by the Bush administration to invade Iraq.

As of today, 772 U.S. soldiers - men and women - have given their lives for their country, or so they died believing.

I do not write this piece to remember the dead of Iraq, but let them not be forgotten.

In the frantic days prior to the U.S. led invasion, French president Jacques Chirac challenged the world to reject "the logic of war." The world heeded his warning. The Bush administration did not.

As in any war, a nation that sends it best to battle must not shrink from supporting them and their families. But in a war that never should have been, those who would make that war, will seek to wrap it in support that would be offered to the soldiers themselves. So is this nation today divided to its core.

The questions run deep

What is support? What is abandonment? If I support a war that is wrong have I supported those who give their lives in it? Or have I abandoned them? Is it enough to say to those I engage in conversation, "I support our troops"? Or is there some greater obligation on my part to seek the truth on behalf of those in the line of fire? What is my role? What best supports those on the front lines? Are they best served by my blind, and mute faith? Or would they be encouraged to know that I will not rest while they are sacrificed without just cause?

Torture that never ends

For those who have brought themselves to view the photographs from Auschwitz, Buchenwald and the other camps, the images from Abu Ghraib do not draw near that horror. But this horror will yet have its darkest day. It is most ironic to see the smiling faces of these sons and daughters of our great nation as they abandon their and our dignity forever. Their lifetimes will be far too short to forget their deeds at that prison from which they can exit but never leave. These crimes will not wash away or be forgotten by those who did them. So, for whom should our hearts break most? Those who have fallen in battle? Or those with a life sentence as guards at Abu Ghraib?

Well then, what is to be done?

There is a man I speak with often. I have on many occasions spoken with great concern about the purpose of this war with him. I fear he does not listen. Today he turned to me with genuine concern and asked, "Well then, what is to be done?"

In preparation for their invasion those who surround Mr. Bush chose to use the words freedom and democracy as slogans. Freedom and democracy are not slogans. They are in fact, perhaps the only things that can save Iraq from us, and save us from Iraq.

The people of Iraq want free and fair elections, and they want their country back. Nothing less will do.


- You can send comments to t r u t h o u t Executive Director Marc Ash at:

© Scoop Media

Top Scoops Headlines


Binoy Kampmark: Meddling For Empire - The CIA Comes Clean

One of the difficulties behind the podium stance of virtue taken by the US political establishment on Russian interference in the country’s electoral process is one of simple hypocrisy. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Gun Debate, Here And In The US

Gun ownership in the US is a mystery to New Zealanders, and so is the constitutional fetish that surrounds it. However, the attitudes involved are not static and unchanging, even if it can feel that way in the wake of each new gun atrocity. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Mueller Probe, And Russia’s Economy

In itself, the indictment of 13 Russian nationals and three Russian companies for interfering in the 2016 US wlll do little to change pre-existing views about the Robert Mueller investigation into Russia’s meddling in US presidential politics... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Nunes Memo

Every now and then the US system erupts and throws up a piece of political magma that can’t be described or explained in any rational fashion... More>>


Ross Webb: Our Union-Powered Past

Labour’s soon-to-implemented workplace relations policy aims to address the imbalances in our economy, but has sparked fears among some that it marks a return to ‘the bad old days’ of the 1970s. But what exactly was happening in the 1970s? And what has caused the ‘imbalances’ that Labour is now trying to fix? More>>