Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


Mad Butcher op ed

Mad Butcher op ed

The Mad Butcher debacle has captivated the country with all the dramatics of a season finale of Shortland Street. And let’s face it, Sir Peter Leitch is every bit as kiwi as Shorty and just as loved.

According to one shopper interviewed outside the Mad Butcher store in Manukau last week by a Stuff reporter, Leitch is a ‘good guy’. He is a ‘good guy’, said this Mad Butcher customer, because ‘he is a well-known New Zealand personality’.

Surely to qualify as a ‘good guy’ one might need more than just notoriety as the number one criteria? But then his popularity is based on his media shaped image as a person who is down to earth, mad as a meat axe and an all-around good bloke.

New Zealanders are not always too flash at questioning the status quo.

So, hats off to Lara Bridger for speaking out when Leitch called Waiheke Island a ‘white man’s island’. What makes Leitch think he has the power to define who belongs on Waiheke Island?

The answer to this question is multifaceted and deserves our full attention.

Let’s begin with Leitch himself. Of course Leitch’s justified his racist rant as ‘banter’. For him, that is what it was. I can guarantee that he has never had to analyse his underpinning assumptions, motivations and values based on his position as a white, pakeha wealthy male. Let me state uncategorically that there is no such things as ‘banter’ when it comes to assertions of power and superiority based on racial categories.

Neither should it be reduced to ‘casual racism’ as described in the media.

Leitch’s comments are more salt in the wound of New Zealand’s painful history of ingrained colonial attitudes of superiority and white man’s privilege. There is absolutely nothing ‘casual’ about that.

And there is a deep-seated irony in Leitch being called out as a racist that has not been picked up on yet. Leitch has profited enormously from the suffering, abuse and violent deaths of animals. In this respect he is in the same league as other well-known New Zealanders such as Sir Peter Tolley and many others thoughout Western history since the invention of slaughterhouses in the 1890s. He could also be likened to the railroad barons in America who demanded and enabled the slaughter of the bison.

Given the historical and existential similarity between the slave trade and the meat trade, being called out as a racist is entirely fitting. Leitch’s absolute and totalising speciesism ( the assumption of human superiority leading to the exploitation of animals) runs parallel to his racism.

Animal liberation is , of course, a cause that many have yet to embrace. This is probably nearly all of us are party to the exploitation and abuse that allows men such as Leitch to become rich. However, what has finally been revealed about the Mad Butcher with this fiasco is this – those who abuse and disrespect animals also show disrespect for humans in equal measures.

Lynley Tulloch is an educator and independent writer on animal welfare.

Paul Judge is a documentary filmmaker and writer on environmental issues.


© Scoop Media

Top Scoops Headlines


UN Rights Declaration At 70: We Are All Born Free And Equal

On Article 1 of the UDHR: Dignity is the foundation of all human rights. Human beings have rights, and should be treated with utmost care, precisely because each one possesses intrinsic worth. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On The (Delayed) Judgment Day For Theresa May

When under stress, British PM Theresa May reportedly eats peanut butter straight from the jar. Crunch time is looming... More>>


Gordon Campbell: On Politely Fake Political Obituaries (And The Paris Discord)

One unfortunate side effect of “personality politics” is that when prominent politicians die, the niceties we observe at the death of private individuals get automatically extended to them as well... More>>


Unique And Vanishing: NZ Biodiversity Losses Match Global Crisis

One might think that it is buffered from some of the effects of biological erosion, especially since people only arrived less than 800 years ago. But as we show, the impact on wildlife has been catastrophic. More>>

Your Name Here(ish): Sponsor A Section On! has just launched Section Sponsorships - the newest way for you to gain exposure for your brand to Scoop’s high value audience of 500,000 monthly readers. More>>


You Did It! The Scoop 3.0 PledgeMe Closes

Update: The Scoop 3.0 Crowdsale and Crowdfunding Campaign met its target with a total of $36,024 pledged. It looks like it has all been worthwhile. We are nearly there and will ride again in 2019, our 20th year of operations. Moreover the past week has brought a number of inquiries from larger organisations, many of which have till now failed to respond to our messages... More>>