Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Where does the money come from?

Where does the money come from?

Keith Rankin, 2 February 2011

On a number of occasions since his state of the nation speech promising to make the first $5,000 of earnings tax free, Phil Goff has been asked "Where will the money come from?", and as always it's a hard question for a politician to answer, and an easy score for a TV or radio journalist (eg TVNZ Breakfast, 1 February 2011). [see Bill English press release on Scoop]

For young children there are two difficult questions: "How are babies made?" and "Where does money come from?" We've become relatively comfortable about talking with children about sex, but have made very little progress on the money front.

Money is simply a circulating medium; a lubricant for market transactions. It circulates through buying/selling, and through lending/borrowing. Transactions are subject to taxation, enabling governments to buy goods and services with from money revenue.

If increasing numbers of people choose to park all or some of their savings as money, then the circulation of money becomes compromised (a kind of financial arteriosclerosis) and we need an increased supply of money to compensate. Fortunately modern money is very elastic; it can be created and destroyed at the will of the appropriate authorities, through processes of double-entry bookkeeping. Yes we do have pixies in the back garden; they are called central bankers. Unfortunately, if newly created money is parked - rather than spent - then the market economy remains congested. Money is only meaningful as money when it is circulating freely.

By suggesting we should remove income tax from the first $5,000 of each person's earnings, Phil Goff is suggesting a policy that will facilitate the circulation of money. Money is easy for central bankers to create, but can be hard to shift. Our incomes - and the government's revenue in particular - depend on the circulation of money.

The question "Where will the money come from?" is, in this case, code for: "How can you reduce taxes when your current tax revenue is insufficient to meet your present spending commitments"?

The answer for the present is, for every lender there must be a borrower. People cannot save more - ie lend more - in the absence of accommodating borrowers. When households and firms are borrowing less and lending more, then governments are required to borrow more. For every lender, there must be a borrower; for every party who sells more than they buy (creditor party), there must be another party (debtor party) who buys more than they sell.

Economic growth takes place, in large part, when business firms borrow and invest. (Note that it is borrowers, not lenders, who 'invest'. True investors are spenders, not savers; commonly they spend the savings of others). As a result of their investments, firms take risks with the expectation of increasing their future revenues, servicing their debts and making more profits.

Good governments also borrow and invest. To recover from a recession, they invest by implementing policies that facilitate the circulation of money. As a result of the success of such policies, tax revenues (which are determined in large part by the rate of circulation of money) increase.

If governments cut spending (or raise tax rates) at a time when the private sector is not increasing its spending (even worse if the private sector is reducing its spending), then less money circulates, economies contract, and government revenues end up falling; the exact opposite of what the governments intended when they cut their spending.

Conversely, when economies have substantial unemployed resources (as they do when in recession), if governments raise their own spending (or reduce bottom tax rates), then more money circulates, economies recover and eventually expand. Government revenues end up rising; the exact opposite of what the pundits said would happen when governments reduced bottom tax rates. When, in a recession, governments increasingly borrow and circulate money, then, as that policy takes effect, rising government revenues lead to deficits that are smaller than they otherwise would be.

It's a paradox. In a recession, increased government deficits lead, in a year or so, to reduced government deficits. Government retrenchment, on the other hand, leads to increased government deficits.

The loudest voices in our financial and economic debates are too often ill-informed, espousing mantra rather than logic. The mantra that people should save more and borrow less makes no logical sense. Likewise it makes no sense to claim that governments should spend less at times when private households and firms are also spending less.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Campbell on: the local body election result in Wellington

For obvious reasons, politics is more of a big deal in the capital city than anywhere else in the country. Even so, fewer than four in ten eligible voters bothered to vote in Saturday’s local body elections in Wellington (turnout 39.66%).

Even less was felt to be at stake this time around than in 2016, when 45% of the electorate voted Justin Lester into the mayoralty.

To put it mildly, the Lester-led Council failed to live up to expectations. Lester will be remembered mainly for the fact that somehow, he managed to lose this election. . More>>

 
 

Could Do Better: Post-Sroubek Review Of Deportation Info

Ms Tremain acknowledges that the review highlighted some aspects of the process that can be improved and makes five main recommendations to strengthen the existing processes for preparing files for decision-makers. Those recommendations are: More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On A New Book On The Leaky Homes Scandal

We all know that journalism is short of cash and under pressure from the speed, brevity and clickbait pressures of the 24/7 news cycle… but hey, given the right subject and a sufficiently stubborn journalist, it can still surpass most of the works of the academic historians... More>>

Regulation: Review Finds NZTA Road Safety Failings

The independent review, carried out by consultant agency MartinJenkins, lists at least 10 reasons for the failures including the agency being focused on customer service at the expense of its policing functions. More>>

ALSO:

Rod Carr: Climate Change Commission Chair-Designate Announced

Climate Change Minister James Shaw has today announced the appointment of Dr Rod Carr as Chair-designate for the Climate Change Commission. More>>

ALSO:

Compliance Complaints: 'Putting Right' Holidays Act Underpayment In Health

The Government is putting right a decade’s worth of underpayment to nurses, doctors and other health workers, says Health Minister Dr David Clark. More>>

ALSO:

IPCA: Disasterous Police Pursuit, Excessive Use Of Dogs

At no stage did Police follow the correct procedure for the commencement of a pursuit... A Police dog handler used his dog to help with the arrest of two of the young people. One suffered injuries resulting in his hospitalisation, and the Authority found that the use of the dog was an excessive use of force. More>>

ALSO:

‘Hard Place To Be Happy’: Report On Youth Residential Care

Children’s Commissioner Andrew Becroft says the report, A Hard Place to be Happy, contains important challenges from children and young people, aged 9 to 17, about their experiences in care and protection residences. “I found this report extremely difficult to read, and I think most New Zealanders would too.” More>>

Africa And Middle East Refugees: 'Family Link' Restriction Removed

The founder of the Double the Quota campaign has applauded the coalition government for Friday’s announcement that a discriminatory policy would be removed. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels