Winebox Speech From Ron Mark MP
Speech by Ron Mark, MP
Cashmere Club, 88 Hunter Terrace, Christchurch
EMBARGOED UNTIL 2PM FRIDAY 20 AUGUST 1999
It is a very significant day, not only because we have among
us the Leader of New Zealand First, the Right Honourable Winston
Peters, but also because the High court in Auckland will soon
release its findings into what is commonly referred to as the
case is at the heart of what New Zealand First stands
- fairness, equality, one law for all, and accountability.
New Zealand is fortunate to have a leader
as determined as Winston
Peters, who has never buckled or shrunk from the responsibility
to be accountable to the people who elected him.
Despite the venom from the
political establishment and the resources
of big business Winston has doggedly pushed for the interests
of ordinary New Zealanders and their families.
has been demonstrated not only in words,
but also in the personal and financial sacrifices he has been
prepared to make in order to see the Wine-box case through to
a successful conclusion.
Success in this context, means
that those who have twisted the
law to profit, should be brought before the highest court in
the land if necessary, to face the consequences, and to have
any unlawful gains extracted from them.
I would be remiss
too, not to thank the thousands of decent New
Zealanders who have demonstrated their abhorrence of big businesses
not paying their due share of taxation, thereby leaving the rest
of us; the little people, to carry the load.
Thank you to you all for your
contributions to the fight for
justice, by helping us pay the huge debts this fight has created.
I know that Winston
is moved by the generosity shown by his supporters,
many of whom have a struggle themselves, just to make ends meet.
The personal financial sacrifices made by Winston in
on against the well financed opposition of big business, is far
greater than most of us will ever know or understand.
Not only has the cost for him been measured
in financial terms,
but also personally both with regard to family, friends and political
saga which has become known as the Wine-box
Winston Peters has been pilloried and ridiculed from all sides
of the political spectrum.
As you will
be aware, many of Winston's political opponents
take every opportunity to attack him.
respect to the Winebox affair, their level of
knows no bounds.
Some of these political
characters, have reached a new low in
double standards though.
Talk about dribbling out of both sides of their mouths! At once!
Not content with taking every opportunity
to turn on Winston
and castigate him for continuing on with the case, rather than
just letting the big business tycoons carry on with their shonky
tax avoidance schemes, they are also prepared to seize a political
advantage if they can..
For example, some of those who have been the
most strident in
condemning him for staying on the case of big business taxation
rip-offs, have also praised him for his efforts.
Michael Cullen for example supported the Wine-box inquiry.
Mr Cullen was also critical of Sir
Ronald Davison being selected
to head a tax inquiry. He even suggested that with the former
Chief Justice heading it, it was being set up to fail.
The only area of
difference was that he wanted the inquiry to
be conducted "in house" by a Parliamentary Select Committee.
Michael Cullen, now the deputy leader of the Labour party, even
went so far as to state, "…that legal opinion made it quite clear
that in at least one case contained within those documents [the
Wine-box] we were dealing not with avoidance, as has been claimed,
but as the Member for Tauranga [Winston Peters] has persistently
claimed, with evasion, and in fact with fraud"
I wonder what made him change his mind because when
report came out, Michael Cullen was among the first to ridicule
Winston Peters for having accused the pillars of New Zealand's
business community of wrongdoing.
Interestingly though, and at the same time as
he attacked Winston
Peters for having the audacity to pursue big business, Mr Cullen
also said " Labour has no truck with the clever avoidance schemes
entered into by some New Zealand corporates over the period under
Now is that having a dollar each way, or what?
Another politician who has been condemning
over the Wine-box case was Rodney Hide.
Yes that's right Rodney Hide the very same
politician who has
become known for his single-issue pursuit of the IRD and their
unfair treatment of taxpayers.
Did you know that this very same Rodney Hide,
demanded in Parliament
that Jim Bolger apologise to the Commissioner of Inland Revenue
for the "hell" he had been put through during the Wine-box investigation?
Yet here is
a man who has staked his future in politics,
incidentally I don't think will last too much longer, on making
life as difficult as possible for the Commissioner of Inland
Talk about duplicitous
activity! For goodness sake Rodney slide
down one side of the fence or other and stay there.!
Yet another politician
quick to condemn Winston and defend the
right of big business to avoid paying their fair share of taxation
was Jim Sutton. Yes, the Honourable Jim Sutton a Minister in
the last Labour Government and standing for an electorate just
down the road from here.
Mr Sutton was
very vocal about the rights of big business to
feel elated when the Davison report was released.
I wonder how
Mr Sutton will feel when Winston is vindicated and
the tax avoidance we all know occurred, is finally sheeted home
to those very same characters Mr Sutton defended.
I have no doubt he will slink away to one
of his farms and hide
Another tired old
politician to crow about Davison finding, was
the National Member, John Banks.
The same John Banks
incidentally who every morning, whilst hosting
his radio programme tells us that he is the champion of the peoples'
Government and is opposed to the little battler from struggle
street being stomped upon by big business.
What a joke John. Keep flying your helicopter
and riding your
Harley Davison motor bike, Winston Peters will carry the real
fight to the big businesses on your behalf!
And what of that other self-proclaimed champion of
Richard Prebble. What was his contribution?
Nothing. In Richard's mind, big business
can do no wrong and
the solution to our country's ills are to hand everything over
to his big business buddies and they will take care of things
Well the hell they will Richard!
I could go on at quite some length
about the antics of some of
our nation's politicians but I will spare you the pain of that.
However one further individual does deserve a mention.
Again in a neighbouring
electorate, not far from here, sits a
very worried woman.
Yes folks Jenny is showing signs of serious
nervousness and she
is I understand, currently scraping together a CV.
What did Jenny do to assist the Wine-box
inquiry? Nothing -just
plain Nothing! And why?
it suited her purpose to have Winston on the ropes
the plan she was hatching did not include a place for Winston
Peters or the New Zealand First Caucus members.
Jenny wanted the field cleared for herself and
her brat pack
to seize the leadership and she saw the Wine-box as a means to
It suited her long term
plans not to lessen the tensions within
the coalition Government so rather than hosing them down with
water, she worked behind the scenes ensuring that plenty of petrol
was poured on the flames.
In closing I want to
again applaud Winston's efforts and thank
him on behalf of all New Zealanders for standing up for what
is right and not being intimidated by a most formidable and well
funded team of the country's QC's and best legal brains.
The brief retained by Winston to do the legal work
for him, Mr
Brian Henry, and his team have done a magnificent job and they
too are to be congratulated.
It is not an easy thing to stand out from
the crowd at times
and to do so against a backdrop of strong opposition from so
many quarters takes a special kind of dedication and belief in
what is the right thing to do.
Winston Peters has done that, not for himself, but
for all of
Winston on behalf of this
meeting, thank you-a thousand thank