Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


The falling Kiwi dollar and dancing Cossacks

Simon Orme writes from Sydney

The falling Kiwi dollar and dancing Cossacks

This week’s falling Kiwi dollar indicates fundamental structural weaknesses in the New Zealand economy compared with Australia. Let me speculate. This structural weakness can be traced back to the 1976 Muldoon government decision to can the Kirk-Rowling Government’s funded superannuation scheme.

In the 1975 election, Muldoon characterised Labour’s super scheme as a communist takeover of NZ in the infamous dancing Cossacks cartoon.

The scheme may have been imperfect, but the replacement was worse – a very generous super scheme funded from current Government expenditure, not savings.

The result is that, compared with Australia, NZ’s national savings are pitiful. Recent data indicates that Australia’s assets under funds management dwarf those of NZ, on a per capita basis. A related point is the continuing high debt levels of the NZ government compared with its Australian counterparts.

As a result, NZ is far more dependent upon foreign investment – NZ assets are more likely to be owned by foreigners.

Against this background, the flight of capital from NZ following this week’s US rates rise should not come as any surprise. The whole point of the move was to rein in the US equities markets.

The fact the NZ Reserve Bank matched the US rise would have done nothing to make Kiwi denominated investments less unattractive.

What’s interesting is that over the two day fall this week, while the Kiwi dollar lost around 4.2% against the $US, this was nearly matched with a loss of 3.7% against the $Australian (1).

This is against a background where Australia is far from popular with overseas investors.

Australian interest rates remain lower than those in the US and NZ. The Australian Reserve Bank has been reluctant to raise rates as far or as fast, against the background of a slowing Australian economy.

The Australian Federal Budget earlier in the month was widely seen as fiscally incontinent.

The headline Budget surplus did not survive closer scrutiny. The bulk of the surplus was based on revenue from the sale of third generation mobile telephone spectrum – a windfall gain from an asset sale.

Worse, a big chunk of the Budget balance was the result of a shonky transaction that wouldn’t look out of place if it turned up in a wine box.

Income from the new GST will be passed on to the States as grants. But in the Budget, part of these grants were classified as loans to the States. This means the sum appears as an asset on the balance sheet instead of an operating expense reducing the Budget balance.

But it was later revealed the loans would be translated into grants to the States in a classic 24 hour money-go-around bogus transaction.

The Budget revealed the fact the Federal government had committed a lot of lolly to compensate for the bitter taste of the new GST, and to shore up waning support in the bush. As a result, the cupboard was pretty much bare.

Returning to the Trans-Tasman comparison, it is difficult to attribute the relatively rough ride of the Kiwi dollar against the Australian to the fact the NZ Government is loosening up the purse strings.

Compared with some extra money for the West Coast and the NZ Symphony Orchestra, Australia’s Budget was a veritable lolly scramble.

Also, structural reform of the economy is pretty much at a stand still or even going backwards because of concerns over “reform fatigue” after Jeff Kennett’s Victorian election loss.

The contrast with Australia highlights the central issue for a centre left NZ Government – how to acquire economic and fiscal sovereignty when foreigners have a lien on your economy (as demonstrated by this week’s dollar fall).

The solution will not be found overnight. It is likely to involve putting in place a proper national superannuation system to get the national savings rate up and Government expenditure on super down.

© Copyright: Simon Orme 2000

Feedback to

© Scoop Media

Top Scoops Headlines


Binoy Kampmark: Vague Alternatives And G7 Summitry: The Build Back Better World Initiative

Summits often feature grand statements and needless fripperies. In Cornwall, the leaders of the G7 countries were trying to position and promote their relevance as the vanguard of democratic good sense and values... More>>

Suicidal Games: Tokyo’s Coronavirus Olympics

A pandemic crisis. A state of emergency. Overwhelming public opinion bristling with alarm. Notwithstanding these factors, Tokyo is still on track to host the Olympics that was cancelled last year in response to the global pandemic. The first sports team – Australia’s softball crew – has touched down. Is all this folly, bravery or self-interest?.. More>>

Binoy Kampmark: Burned By The Diana Cult: The Fall Of Martin Bashir

The interview was infamous, made his name and was bound to enrage. It also received a viewing audience of 23 million people who heard a saucy tale of adultery, plots in the palace, and stories of physical and mental illness. But the tarring and feathering of Martin Bashir for his 1995 Panorama programme featuring Princess Diana was always more than the scruples of a journalist and his interviewing methods... More>>

How It All Went Wrong: The Global Response To COVID-19

The Independent Panel for Pandemic Preparedness and Response was never likely to hand down a rosy report with gobbets of praise. Organised by the World Health Organization Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus last May, the panel’s gloomy assessment was grim: the COVID-19 pandemic could have been avoided... More>>

The Conversation: Is Natural Gas Really Cheaper Than Renewable Electricity?

Climate Explained is a collaboration between The Conversation, Stuff and the New Zealand Science Media Centre to answer your questions about climate change... More>>

Keith Rankin: The New Zealand Government’s 'Public Finance Rabbithole'

Last week, out of left field, the government placed a three-year embargo on normal public sector wage bargaining, essentially a salary freeze. While there has been a certain amount of backtracking since, it is clear that the government has been ... More>>